R56 What Did You Drive Before Your R56?
New guy here!
My previous car was a 2003 BMW 330Ci, sold it to buy a 2010 FJCW last week. The E46 was a really nice car, but having had four 3-series BMW's, I wanted something different, something more nimble/fun. The JCW fits that bill very nicely indeed. :D
My previous car was a 2003 BMW 330Ci, sold it to buy a 2010 FJCW last week. The E46 was a really nice car, but having had four 3-series BMW's, I wanted something different, something more nimble/fun. The JCW fits that bill very nicely indeed. :D

I learned a lot about working on cars from that Saturn. Loved it but it was not one of GM's finest works. Alternators, fuel pump, suspension components, drive shaft, CV joint...
Replaced the SC2 with an R53, sold the R53 after my daughter was born and money was tight, drive an old beater Subaru for a couple years, finally picked up an R55S!
Really? I love my MCS, but I find this one hard to believe. Explanation please. What makes it more fun? Why did you give the 997 up? I could see where a C4 isn't as nimble or "tossable" as a 997 C2, and clearly a MINI might feel even more nimble, at least from the seat of the pants. Curious minds want to know. FYI, still waiting for the guy saying he traded his Ferrari for a MINI. Think I might call BS on that one.
Really? I love my MCS, but I find this one hard to believe. Explanation please. What makes it more fun? Why did you give the 997 up? I could see where a C4 isn't as nimble or "tossable" as a 997 C2, and clearly a MINI might feel even more nimble, at least from the seat of the pants. Curious minds want to know. FYI, still waiting for the guy saying he traded his Ferrari for a MINI. Think I might call BS on that one.


Haha, yeah a Ferrari to a Mini? Now that's a little more intense! The newer Porsche's have become incredibly livable. At regular speeds it felt like any other sedan. I drove it home from CA to WA and had zero issues. Amazing cars.
I traded an 07 Pontiac G5 for my Mini (LOL). I bought the G5 just to have something inexpensive to drive. it was a good car but pretty boring. The Mini is a nice upgrade for my daily driver. My background with performance cars has been with American V8's. I still have a 99 Camaro that I have modded quite a bit but I don't drive it much. I wanted something fun for a daily driver and so far the Mini is perfect. It is quite a bit different than anything I have had before.
VW Jetta
I finally gave up on my 1996 VW Jetta GLX VR6. A hot driver when new up through year 9, then it slowly started to fall apart...bit by bit. It is sitting in my Ex's driveway, a Non operational mess with a bad oil pump at 24200 miles. Bought my 2010 MCS and have upgraded. You think Minis have problems own a VW Jetta with bad window regulators, bad wheel bearings, great engine other than the plastic parts that fall to pieces due to thermal cycles and ozone. Great car, had every option.
As someone who also left VAG and even considered a Golf R for a next car, I'm pleased with my choice. But when Audi launches the S3 stateside in a year or so, it's gonna be hard to resist!
Know how you feel
Nice GTI! I love VWs, but the quality went south when they became Mexico assembled with Globally supplied parts. Of course the Minis are globally supplied parts and are having problems too.
New S owner..
My previous car was a 2011 Prius.. awesome car!! but just gets boring..
the mileage is insane.. the reliability was off the charts..
I jumped in my 2013 mini hardtop S TODAY>>>> just picked her up!!!!

... and fell in love.. the car is 1 billion percent different.. on every level.. (save mileage) hoping to achieve close to 30 plus on the mini to compare to the 45 ish on the Prius...
but wow... whatr a fun car!!! the mini is..
I got one pretty loaded up.. S, sport, Harmon Kardon, sunroof, etc etc.I got lucky .. I got one off the lot that had 99 percent of what I want..
the white silver with the black roof is AWSOME.. with the blacked out headlamps.. and the MINI S logo down the bottom ,, pretty cool look.. and a "modern" look i think with that silver/white /grey color very cool...
so .. here I am...
the mileage is insane.. the reliability was off the charts..
I jumped in my 2013 mini hardtop S TODAY>>>> just picked her up!!!!


... and fell in love.. the car is 1 billion percent different.. on every level.. (save mileage) hoping to achieve close to 30 plus on the mini to compare to the 45 ish on the Prius...but wow... whatr a fun car!!! the mini is..
I got one pretty loaded up.. S, sport, Harmon Kardon, sunroof, etc etc.I got lucky .. I got one off the lot that had 99 percent of what I want..
the white silver with the black roof is AWSOME.. with the blacked out headlamps.. and the MINI S logo down the bottom ,, pretty cool look.. and a "modern" look i think with that silver/white /grey color very cool...
so .. here I am...
Last edited by mini604; Jul 26, 2013 at 11:05 PM.







