JCW Mods
#52
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: SoCaL (Agoura Hills)
Posts: 3,902
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I should also mention that after reading most of your thread it seems like your goal is to preserve your warranty and increase power. If you install ANY part on your car, you've endangered your warranty, regardless of whether it was JCW or some aftermarket brand. The ONLY way to keep your warranty intact is to have the ENTIRE JCW kit installed at an Authorized MINI Dealer. Anything less and you're in the exact same spot that someone with aftermarket parts and a failed engine would be in.
Just because you have a JCW pulley on your car doesn't mean you're protected from warranty troubles. Something to think about.
If you're serious about adding power to your car, talk to Jan from Revolution MINI. He's a no BS guy, and he'll tell you the truth about whether what you're trying to do is worth it or not. Adding a coil pack isn't going to do anything other than cost you money.
Last edited by Guest; 02-09-2008 at 01:58 PM.
#53
i am planning on going alittle further than just exhaust and injectors. i am in the process of ordering the alta 15% pulley and the jcw injectors. i am keeping my eyes peeled for a gp intercooler. once those are done, then will come the jcw exhaust. after that, i am unsure. we will just see where and how far the modding takes me.
#54
5th Gear
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Portland, Or
Posts: 780
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Keep in mind that in order to fully realize the added flow of the JCW injectors, you will need an ecu tune of some sort. Without it, your stock ecu will trim the new injectors to flow the same as your stock ones.
I'm not sure is this has been mentioned yet, but skip the wires (get the plugs). The stock wires and coil are more than enough for what you have planned.
I'm not sure is this has been mentioned yet, but skip the wires (get the plugs). The stock wires and coil are more than enough for what you have planned.
#55
Injectors would be a complete waste of money until you significantly improve the airflow all the way thru the engine. The additional injector capacity simply won't be used by the ECU. Period.
Start with pulley & plugs, CAI (JCW with a gauze filter is good), an ECU upgrade, and a cat-back. That will make maybe 185-190 est. HP. for around $1500 if you buy new parts. Or do it without the cat-back for maybe 3 HP less and half the cost. It's a Big difference either way.
If you have a another $2K to spend just on the engine, then consider injectors, head-work, and a re-tune, but you should be investing in suspension and brakes long before that. (rear sway-bar, lightweight wheels, braces, shocks, front brakes)
BTW, coil and wires are nothing but pretty bling, unless yours have somehow become "worn-out" (highly unlikely).
Start with pulley & plugs, CAI (JCW with a gauze filter is good), an ECU upgrade, and a cat-back. That will make maybe 185-190 est. HP. for around $1500 if you buy new parts. Or do it without the cat-back for maybe 3 HP less and half the cost. It's a Big difference either way.
If you have a another $2K to spend just on the engine, then consider injectors, head-work, and a re-tune, but you should be investing in suspension and brakes long before that. (rear sway-bar, lightweight wheels, braces, shocks, front brakes)
BTW, coil and wires are nothing but pretty bling, unless yours have somehow become "worn-out" (highly unlikely).
Last edited by OldRick; 02-09-2008 at 06:35 PM.
#56
Injectors would be a complete waste of money until you significantly improve the airflow all the way thru the engine. The additional injector capacity simply won't be used by the ECU. Period.
Start with pulley & plugs, CAI (JCW with a gauze filter is good), an ECU upgrade, and a cat-back. That will make maybe 185-190 est. HP. for around $1500 if you buy new parts. Or do it without the cat-back for maybe 3 HP less and half the cost. It's a Big difference either way.
If you have a another $2K to spend just on the engine, then consider injectors, head-work, and a re-tune, but you should be investing in suspension and brakes long before that. (rear sway-bar, lightweight wheels, braces, shocks, front brakes)
BTW, coil and wires are nothing but pretty bling, unless yours have somehow become "worn-out" (highly unlikely).
Start with pulley & plugs, CAI (JCW with a gauze filter is good), an ECU upgrade, and a cat-back. That will make maybe 185-190 est. HP. for around $1500 if you buy new parts. Or do it without the cat-back for maybe 3 HP less and half the cost. It's a Big difference either way.
If you have a another $2K to spend just on the engine, then consider injectors, head-work, and a re-tune, but you should be investing in suspension and brakes long before that. (rear sway-bar, lightweight wheels, braces, shocks, front brakes)
BTW, coil and wires are nothing but pretty bling, unless yours have somehow become "worn-out" (highly unlikely).
#57
Please repeat after me: "Injectors would be a complete waste of money until you significantly improve the airflow all the way thru the engine."
An ECU upgrade cannot use additional fuel injector capacity unless there is more air to burn the gas. The stock injectors are perfectly capable of taking you to 195HP or so, and if the ECU actually did squirt more gas without more air-flow, you would simply be running too rich and lose power.
There are a lot of options for an ECU upgrade. The JCW is probably one of the least effective, as it is dialed in for the JCW parts, including the head you don't have. Most dealers will rip you off for serious money for the 5 minutes it takes to load.
You need not fear warranty issues, as the changes made to the ECU maps are not visible to your local dealer unless they dig really deep.
One of the less costly options, which lets you upgrade the tune as you upgrade over time, is from MTH. I have it on my car, and it's very good. You tell them what combination of add-ons you are using, and they send you new code that you can then upload into the car from a PC. YOu can also back-out the changes entirely, if you get nervous about the dealer noticing. See their NAM vendor forum for more.
Some other approaches add hardware that "fools" the ECU by changing the sensor readings (reduces reliability and adds complexity), or replace the ECU entirely, at the high-end (very costly). There are also plug-in generic upgraders, like the "Shark", but they are pretty worthless.
Many MINI tuner shops can do the ECU air/fuel and spark timing maps for you. There are several choices. Expect to pay on the order of $400 or so for such "canned" tuning without dyno time. Expect to get 10-12 HP from these tunes, if you have a 15% pulley.
All of the "canned" tuning approaches are somewhat generic, and will get you maybe 80% of the maximum performance increase possible with your engine. If the tuner actually measures performance on a dyno and tweaks the parameters to your specific car, you can get the most performance possible, but you will then be treading on thin ice - a single tank of bad gas could pop your engine if it was tuned to the utmost possible level. The cost of such a tune is usually measured in $/hour for the time it takes.
Whichever you select, I'd suggest you make sure that you don't have to pay again for an additional tuning upgrade for a year of so after purchase, as you would if you went the all-out dyno-based tune route.
An ECU upgrade cannot use additional fuel injector capacity unless there is more air to burn the gas. The stock injectors are perfectly capable of taking you to 195HP or so, and if the ECU actually did squirt more gas without more air-flow, you would simply be running too rich and lose power.
There are a lot of options for an ECU upgrade. The JCW is probably one of the least effective, as it is dialed in for the JCW parts, including the head you don't have. Most dealers will rip you off for serious money for the 5 minutes it takes to load.
You need not fear warranty issues, as the changes made to the ECU maps are not visible to your local dealer unless they dig really deep.
One of the less costly options, which lets you upgrade the tune as you upgrade over time, is from MTH. I have it on my car, and it's very good. You tell them what combination of add-ons you are using, and they send you new code that you can then upload into the car from a PC. YOu can also back-out the changes entirely, if you get nervous about the dealer noticing. See their NAM vendor forum for more.
Some other approaches add hardware that "fools" the ECU by changing the sensor readings (reduces reliability and adds complexity), or replace the ECU entirely, at the high-end (very costly). There are also plug-in generic upgraders, like the "Shark", but they are pretty worthless.
Many MINI tuner shops can do the ECU air/fuel and spark timing maps for you. There are several choices. Expect to pay on the order of $400 or so for such "canned" tuning without dyno time. Expect to get 10-12 HP from these tunes, if you have a 15% pulley.
All of the "canned" tuning approaches are somewhat generic, and will get you maybe 80% of the maximum performance increase possible with your engine. If the tuner actually measures performance on a dyno and tweaks the parameters to your specific car, you can get the most performance possible, but you will then be treading on thin ice - a single tank of bad gas could pop your engine if it was tuned to the utmost possible level. The cost of such a tune is usually measured in $/hour for the time it takes.
Whichever you select, I'd suggest you make sure that you don't have to pay again for an additional tuning upgrade for a year of so after purchase, as you would if you went the all-out dyno-based tune route.
Last edited by OldRick; 02-09-2008 at 07:14 PM.
#58
5th Gear
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Portland, Or
Posts: 780
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Each dealer will probably be different. Mine won't install the JCW tune without the entire JCW package. Your experience may vary, but I'm sure most will agree there are far better options than JCW.
#59
If the JCW software is what you meant, some of the dealer will be able to do it for you. Price varies from 1/2 hr. or an hour labor.
#60
i guess i wasnt specific. i was looking for the jcw software info. from my readings though, it sounds pretty worthless. if i do get it done the mini dealer will only charge 1/2 to an 1hr worth of labor and nothing more, right? i would think the jcw software would be the best for me since i am trying to stick with the jcw "theme" if you will.
#62
Rob - just like larger injectors, the JCW ECU flash will do absolutely zero to improve performance without the hardware necessary to move more air into and out of the engine, i.e. pulley&plugs, intake, and exhaust, at the least.
Thus, for your $100 or so, you get no results and an invisible ECU change, and it IS the JCW version of No Improvement, but you don't even get a badge to show you got it.
Thus, for your $100 or so, you get no results and an invisible ECU change, and it IS the JCW version of No Improvement, but you don't even get a badge to show you got it.
#63
This is it, go for any JCW stuff.
#65
i am planning on going alittle further than just exhaust and injectors. i am in the process of ordering the alta 15% pulley and the jcw injectors. i am keeping my eyes peeled for a gp intercooler. once those are done, then will come the jcw exhaust. after that, i am unsure. we will just see where and how far the modding takes me.
#66
Keep in mind that in order to fully realize the added flow of the JCW injectors, you will need an ecu tune of some sort. Without it, your stock ecu will trim the new injectors to flow the same as your stock ones.
I'm not sure is this has been mentioned yet, but skip the wires (get the plugs). The stock wires and coil are more than enough for what you have planned.
I'm not sure is this has been mentioned yet, but skip the wires (get the plugs). The stock wires and coil are more than enough for what you have planned.
#67
5th Gear
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Portland, Or
Posts: 780
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Oh what I could do with that $6K on my car....
#70
#1 CAI, Breath in.
#2 Cat Back, Breath out.
#3 15% pulley, Bigger lungs, breath faster.
#4 & 5 Larger injectors for more fuel to go with increased air.
JCW flash or better custom dyno tune (Jan) so the ECU knows they are there and to get all the mods singing in the same key, TUNED!
JCW Injectors at Minspeed.net $275.00.
#2 Cat Back, Breath out.
#3 15% pulley, Bigger lungs, breath faster.
#4 & 5 Larger injectors for more fuel to go with increased air.
JCW flash or better custom dyno tune (Jan) so the ECU knows they are there and to get all the mods singing in the same key, TUNED!
JCW Injectors at Minspeed.net $275.00.
Last edited by minimarks; 02-10-2008 at 08:17 AM.
#71
#1 CAI, Breath in.
#2 Cat Back, Breath out.
#3 15% pulley, Bigger lungs, breath faster.
#4 & 5 Larger injectors for more fuel to go with increased air.
JCW flash or better custom dyno tune (Jan) so the ECU knows they are there and to get all the mods singing in the same key, TUNED!
JCW Injectors at Minspeed.net $275.00.
#2 Cat Back, Breath out.
#3 15% pulley, Bigger lungs, breath faster.
#4 & 5 Larger injectors for more fuel to go with increased air.
JCW flash or better custom dyno tune (Jan) so the ECU knows they are there and to get all the mods singing in the same key, TUNED!
JCW Injectors at Minspeed.net $275.00.
#72
#73
5th Gear
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Somewhere just left of off center
Posts: 735
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Seriously, where you're at now, skip any more power mods and get a bigger rear sway bar.
#75
5th Gear
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Somewhere just left of off center
Posts: 735
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Free flowing head on our cars will do more that either of these 2 combined. $1100 for these 2 items or twice that for real power.
The JCW tune, even with the injectors does next to nothing for power. It's more of a factory safety tune to keep the car pig rich when running more boost. The only tune right now that truly optimizes injectors is a custom solution.
#3 15% pulley, Bigger lungs, breath faster.
#4 & 5 Larger injectors for more fuel to go with increased air.
JCW flash or better custom dyno tune (Jan) so the ECU knows they are there and to get all the mods singing in the same key, TUNED!
JCW Injectors at Minspeed.net $275.00.
#4 & 5 Larger injectors for more fuel to go with increased air.
JCW flash or better custom dyno tune (Jan) so the ECU knows they are there and to get all the mods singing in the same key, TUNED!
JCW Injectors at Minspeed.net $275.00.