F55/F56 F56 S brake upgrade JCW vs Willwood
#1
F56 S brake upgrade JCW vs Willwood
Hello everyone.
I noticed the price is pretty similar between JCW brakes retrofit and Wilwood front BBK only. Each one is a little over $1500. JCW brembo comes with the rear as well but isnt it the same as S except that JCW rear calipers are painted red?
So my question is this: if we are only comparing an upgrade to front brake kit wich one would be “the one” to get for stopping power, longevity etc. JCW or Wilwood?
any orher things that should be taken into consideration?
thanks guys
I noticed the price is pretty similar between JCW brakes retrofit and Wilwood front BBK only. Each one is a little over $1500. JCW brembo comes with the rear as well but isnt it the same as S except that JCW rear calipers are painted red?
So my question is this: if we are only comparing an upgrade to front brake kit wich one would be “the one” to get for stopping power, longevity etc. JCW or Wilwood?
any orher things that should be taken into consideration?
thanks guys
#2
#4
Vendor
iTrader: (10)
I've installed both and have to say I like the Wilwood better as it is better for performance and real abuse as it has real metal pistons that won't melt. Plus it had more clamping force that made it feel like it stopped much faster. Also was lighter weight than the JCWs
https://www.waymotorworks.com/wilwoo...5-f56-f57.html
But the JCW would be my second choice
https://www.waymotorworks.com/john-c...-cooper-s.html
https://www.waymotorworks.com/wilwoo...5-f56-f57.html
But the JCW would be my second choice
https://www.waymotorworks.com/john-c...-cooper-s.html
The following users liked this post:
bratling (08-10-2018)
#5
I have the Wilwood 6 pistons on my car. I came from having the stock S brakes with EBC reds on and it definitely is a big difference. The Wilwood's don't squeal at all and the install was a easy. I did a brake flush on all 4 corners including the clutch which was easy enough too. There are 4 bleed screws per caliper on the Wilwood's. You only bleed the top two and loosen only the black part of the screw. They are fragile and I broke one from over tightening so I had to order a new one. If you got any questions on the install let me know.
The following 5 users liked this post by Andrew Park:
8Balls (02-16-2020),
bratling (08-10-2018),
CallMeRacerB (08-10-2018),
ECSTuning (08-13-2018),
WayMotorWorks (08-10-2018)
#6
Two piece rotors are better, but if you are not tracking the car I'm not sure it matters.
pad choice determines pad / rotor life, some pads are designed to wear the pad more than the rotor, gloc/carbotech comes to mind. Some wear the rotor faster, hawk pads come to mind.
My absolute favorite street pad, hawk HP+ make lots of dust and wear the rotors out and the squeal like a stuck pig, but man do they ever stop the car even when ice cold. lots of initial bite & high torque pads.
pad choice determines pad / rotor life, some pads are designed to wear the pad more than the rotor, gloc/carbotech comes to mind. Some wear the rotor faster, hawk pads come to mind.
My absolute favorite street pad, hawk HP+ make lots of dust and wear the rotors out and the squeal like a stuck pig, but man do they ever stop the car even when ice cold. lots of initial bite & high torque pads.
#7
Wow, great info! Seems as I am leaning towards Wilwood set when the time comes. Andrew Park, your setup looks fantastic. Do you use winter wheels/tires? If so, how is the wheel clearance around those calipers. I use 17” RSe05 with Pilot Super Sport in the summer, but for the winder will have to switch back to winter tires mounted on stock 17 inch wheels. I wonde it my stock wheel will fit around those calipers
Trending Topics
#8
5th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Two piece rotors are better, but if you are not tracking the car I'm not sure it matters.
pad choice determines pad / rotor life, some pads are designed to wear the pad more than the rotor, gloc/carbotech comes to mind. Some wear the rotor faster, hawk pads come to mind.
My absolute favorite street pad, hawk HP+ make lots of dust and wear the rotors out and the squeal like a stuck pig, but man do they ever stop the car even when ice cold. lots of initial bite & high torque pads.
pad choice determines pad / rotor life, some pads are designed to wear the pad more than the rotor, gloc/carbotech comes to mind. Some wear the rotor faster, hawk pads come to mind.
My absolute favorite street pad, hawk HP+ make lots of dust and wear the rotors out and the squeal like a stuck pig, but man do they ever stop the car even when ice cold. lots of initial bite & high torque pads.
#9
Wow, great info! Seems as I am leaning towards Wilwood set when the time comes. Andrew Park, your setup looks fantastic. Do you use winter wheels/tires? If so, how is the wheel clearance around those calipers. I use 17” RSe05 with Pilot Super Sport in the summer, but for the winder will have to switch back to winter tires mounted on stock 17 inch wheels. I wonde it my stock wheel will fit around those calipers
#10
I have the Wilwood 6 pistons on my car. I came from having the stock S brakes with EBC reds on and it definitely is a big difference. The Wilwood's don't squeal at all and the install was a easy. I did a brake flush on all 4 corners including the clutch which was easy enough too. There are 4 bleed screws per caliper on the Wilwood's. You only bleed the top two and loosen only the black part of the screw. They are fragile and I broke one from over tightening so I had to order a new one. If you got any questions on the install let me know.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post