What is wrong here on NAM
Its kind of interesting that the issue of "humor" keeps arising. The fact that some people here on NAM as well as on other boards battling these issues keep referring to posts that some other users find offensive as "jokes, humor, being funny, etc".
Unfortunately, humor is not universal. Poles don't like Polish jokes; Jews don't like Jewish jokes; moms don't like dead baby jokes.... you get the idea. I'm not sure that moderation and administration can mitigate the personal issues that can fuel disagreements caused by reactions to another user's "jokes".
I do believe that some users use the "joke" defense to justify socially rude behavior. Sometimes things are said behind the anonymity of a screen name that they would never say face to face.
Unfortunately, humor is not universal. Poles don't like Polish jokes; Jews don't like Jewish jokes; moms don't like dead baby jokes.... you get the idea. I'm not sure that moderation and administration can mitigate the personal issues that can fuel disagreements caused by reactions to another user's "jokes".
I do believe that some users use the "joke" defense to justify socially rude behavior. Sometimes things are said behind the anonymity of a screen name that they would never say face to face.
Back on topic for a sec...
This morning this post was reported. I think is a great example of what doesn't feel like community to me. I responded by calling out the user and by including information so that others may add him to their ignore lists if they see fit.
Thoughts on this approach? Ideally I would like to see other members calling people out for their actions so that something like this doesn't require moderation intervention. Having members do that will not only reduce the moderator load but will archive the level of interaction we accept/don't accept as a community.
Mark
This morning this post was reported. I think is a great example of what doesn't feel like community to me. I responded by calling out the user and by including information so that others may add him to their ignore lists if they see fit.
Thoughts on this approach? Ideally I would like to see other members calling people out for their actions so that something like this doesn't require moderation intervention. Having members do that will not only reduce the moderator load but will archive the level of interaction we accept/don't accept as a community.
Mark
IMHO members are here to unwind, relax and deal with all things Mini. Moderators are the ones that have the tact approval of site management to help smooth this along, giving the "power to the people" I fear will lead to a form a anarchy.
I'm Jewish (unless you adhere to the belief that if your mother isn't Jewish neither are you), and I love Jewish jokes.
But I probably made a sage decision not to get vanity plates that said "NAPPY".
But I probably made a sage decision not to get vanity plates that said "NAPPY".
A man was on his deathbed at home, his son tending to him, his wife cooking in the kitchen. Man to son: “Tell your mother that her brisket will go with me to heaven. A last wish: I just want one piece.” The boy runs to the kitchen, then sprints back. Son to man: “Sorry, Dad. Mom says it’s for after the funeral.”
From Wikipedia, Troll; "An Internet troll, or simply troll in Internet slang, is someone who intentionally posts controversial or contrary messages in an on-line community such as an on-line discussion forum with the intention of baiting users into an argumentative response."
Eh?
Eh?
I like VOGON instead! That's Violation of guidelines of NAM.
Which, coincidentally, also is a member "one of the most unpleasant races in the galaxy. Not actually evil, but bad tempered, bureaucratic, officious and callous. - from The Hitchhiker's Guide (Doug Adams)" via wikipedia


And bringing it back on topic for a sec: I do realize that that may not be universally funny, but it's definitely not crass or some other kind of bad humor!
Which, coincidentally, also is a member "one of the most unpleasant races in the galaxy. Not actually evil, but bad tempered, bureaucratic, officious and callous. - from The Hitchhiker's Guide (Doug Adams)" via wikipedia


And bringing it back on topic for a sec: I do realize that that may not be universally funny, but it's definitely not crass or some other kind of bad humor!
Banned
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 4,054
Likes: 0
From: As far away from Florida as I can get.
Back on topic for a sec...
This morning this post was reported. I think is a great example of what doesn't feel like community to me. I responded by calling out the user and by including information so that others may add him to their ignore lists if they see fit.
This morning this post was reported. I think is a great example of what doesn't feel like community to me. I responded by calling out the user and by including information so that others may add him to their ignore lists if they see fit.
"sorry i forgot to put the
at the end."
Banned
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 4,054
Likes: 0
From: As far away from Florida as I can get.
And a perfect example of offensive humor that works.
Not sure that that makes his post less offensive, but at least his intention wasn't malicious, I guess.





