Suspension Coilovers: The Agony and The Ecstasy
The more and more I look at coilovers, the more and more it seems like a more budget concious choice. The lousy part being any of the cheaper coilovers don't have their own camber plates and I'm not crazy about reusing old parts on a new $1000+ suspension. Edit: Do either of the H&R kits come with camber plates or is it limited to top of the line Cross and lower end Megans?
The more and more I look at coilovers, the more and more it seems like a more budget concious choice. The lousy part being any of the cheaper coilovers don't have their own camber plates and I'm not crazy about reusing old parts on a new $1000+ suspension. Edit: Do either of the H&R kits come with camber plates or is it limited to top of the line Cross and lower end Megans?
Banned
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 3,499
Likes: 0
From: Car Nut Since 1987, Owner Since Fall 2005, Vendor Since Fall 2007
Yes the Megan's do come with camber plates, NEW rear top hats and rear damper adjustment cables. They are priced right, they are not "low end" or "cheap".
My statement may have been a bit bold. A street oriented car will vary in weight on an almost daily basic depending on cargo, passengers etc. Though the car may not be completely asymmetrical, with a good alignment and installation I see no real world issues for a daily driven street car.
http://public.fotki.com/m8o/kar_kraz.../dscn0028.html
It was a total waste of money. It could not compare with:
a) finding the proper ride height front & back as that affects the suspension geometry & damper "sweet spot".
b) suitable caster & camber angles
c) the most importantly, the proper toe angle in front, and even more importantly, proper toe angle in the rear. (possible as I replaced most all the links w/adjustable ones w/hiem joints)
....that was worth the money in cost of trial & error experimentation by the speed shop doing the installs & alignment(s) ... I believe 6 in total before i found the right combos. This does not yield a 4 corner balanced setup, but does yield an extremely responsive and balanced suspension under extreme direction changes.
I will add, I'm not sure I have settled on the right set of spring rates front & rear. Presently @ 950ft-lb front & 600 ft-lb rear. I think I need to go to 650 rear or 700... So there's that too to consider.
Banned
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 3,499
Likes: 0
From: Car Nut Since 1987, Owner Since Fall 2005, Vendor Since Fall 2007
I've been in 2 cars with Megan's and hated every minute of both of them. Just my $.02 them. But how is the ride compared to stock with the BC's? I keep hearing of how the pricier setups not only handle better but also have a softer ride and this sounds truly appealing.


One of the big things I try to help my customers understand is "lowering" a MINI is not the only way to get better handling and most of the time cost more in cash and ride then you gain.
For bling owners with lot's of cash, buy the Cross or M7 setup, slam it and roll. Many of my customers are working within a budget and have found the Megan's and BC's to work very well within that budget. Many of them have also found a set of TSW Springs and IE Camber Plates work well and save them even more money.
I like the idea of coilovers but am not crazy about the thought of drilling a few holes in the back of hatch area to accomodate the adjuster cables. I know you can set them outside of the car before install but not having the adjustability kills the main point behind having them in the first place. Without going ***** to the wall *Cross*, is there any options that allow for adjustment on the bottom of the coilover unit?
I'm near ready to purchase new suspension as well & I'm up on all the products out there. My/our car is mostly for show & the occasional romp through the mountains. I guess I'm looking for something with a wicked stance, comfort level for my wife, well-balanced for the kind of driving I do, but able to be pushed to the limit should I choose to do that.
I really appreciated ChrisMCS04's ultimate coilover thread because I could get an idea of what the installed product looked like. I've decided to go with either TSW AST/Swift SA or KW v.2's (for a couple reasons), but I haven't seen any feedback from the people who have these setups. When I saw the title of the thread "The Agony and the Ecstasy", I laughed cuz' I keep having that thought. On that note...does anyone have feedback to these setups?
I really appreciated ChrisMCS04's ultimate coilover thread because I could get an idea of what the installed product looked like. I've decided to go with either TSW AST/Swift SA or KW v.2's (for a couple reasons), but I haven't seen any feedback from the people who have these setups. When I saw the title of the thread "The Agony and the Ecstasy", I laughed cuz' I keep having that thought. On that note...does anyone have feedback to these setups?

Do you think I have missed anything yet? If anyone wants to go to my thread and leave me some feedback or advise I would love it
OK, thread jack over
P.S. Fracky if you would like to expand on your choices in that thread I would love to know why you are looking at those options.
"Between Agony and Ecstasy" is a great movie!
If you are beginning, camber plates and a sway bar is all you need. If you are a good driver, you can accomplish a lot with these two mods. New springs and dampers can really complicate a set up...
If you are beginning, camber plates and a sway bar is all you need. If you are a good driver, you can accomplish a lot with these two mods. New springs and dampers can really complicate a set up...
I just replaced my H&R for for Tein basics and the car looks a whole lot better, more adjustments and didnt need camber plates, perfect fit. I can barley put my hand between the fender and the tire.
The more adjustability, the more agony.
A little bit of autoX. Definitely no serious track use. And want to be able to agressively run the curves in the mountains around here on without jarring my kidney's out of place. I already have an Alta 19mm rear sway bar on the stiffest setting. I have H&R sport springs. They are a little better than stock suspension, but not overly so. Dropping the car is not important other than what it contributes to handling.
For the money, tremendous deal. I'd say you're looking at decreasing gains going for something like the CROSS for 2x the $$$. Might be better in all aspects (no personal experience). Surely not 2x the performance. "IMHO"
edit: oh, and don't worry about the whole "drilling holes through your car" thing. It feels wrong at first, but out of sight, out of mind.
Being able to adjust all four corners rocks.
Sounds like the same compromise you get from progressive springs, which everyone is always complaining about..
Also Racers Edge in NJ I think...
Matt
MC2 had an article some time ago about these guys:
http://www.tcklineracing.com/
The article was an R56 with a TCK Koni coilover setup with adjustable camber plates. Any knowledge of them or the product? I looked on their site and found nothing but as we all know, this doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
http://www.tcklineracing.com/
The article was an R56 with a TCK Koni coilover setup with adjustable camber plates. Any knowledge of them or the product? I looked on their site and found nothing but as we all know, this doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
Click here then click the link in that post to the Technical manual, and read the section on damper theory (the pages I point out in that post).
Last edited by minim8o; Jul 24, 2008 at 06:51 PM. Reason: correct spring rate unit -- thanx Dr Obnxs


