Crank no start
Crank no start
A few years ago, my 2008 Mini Cooper S R56 N14 engine was rebuilt (forged pistons, valves, timing chain, coil packs, MAF sensor). I don’t drive it much. Battery was replaced in November. The car is catless, has a larger intercooler, 1‑step colder plugs, and an AEM intake. It’s tuned, and the only recurring code I normally get is:
- 2B5F — DME: Air mass sensor, correction signal
Yesterday I went for a Costco run and then to the mall. While driving, I got these codes:
- 2D8E — DME: Knock sensor, electric
- 2D50— DME: Super knocking
The car went into limp mode for a few minutes, then recovered and drove normally. Later, at a downhill stoplight on the way home, the car shut off without me noticing. When the light turned green, I tried to accelerate and realized the engine was off. It would crank but not start. Since it’s a manual and I was on a downhill, I tried bump‑starting it — nothing. Had to tow it home.
I recharged the battery, but it still only cranks and won’t start. I have a basic OBD2 scanner (Xtool) and captured some data during cranking. Before this issue, maybe 1 out of 5 starts would crank longer than usual, but it always eventually started.
Right now I’m not sure if this is: High‑pressure fuel pump, Low‑pressure fuel pump, Bad JBE module, or something else entirely.
Any ideas on how to test these with limited tools?
- 2B5F — DME: Air mass sensor, correction signal
Yesterday I went for a Costco run and then to the mall. While driving, I got these codes:
- 2D8E — DME: Knock sensor, electric
- 2D50— DME: Super knocking
The car went into limp mode for a few minutes, then recovered and drove normally. Later, at a downhill stoplight on the way home, the car shut off without me noticing. When the light turned green, I tried to accelerate and realized the engine was off. It would crank but not start. Since it’s a manual and I was on a downhill, I tried bump‑starting it — nothing. Had to tow it home.
I recharged the battery, but it still only cranks and won’t start. I have a basic OBD2 scanner (Xtool) and captured some data during cranking. Before this issue, maybe 1 out of 5 starts would crank longer than usual, but it always eventually started.
Right now I’m not sure if this is: High‑pressure fuel pump, Low‑pressure fuel pump, Bad JBE module, or something else entirely.
Any ideas on how to test these with limited tools?
Last edited by Papote; Mar 22, 2026 at 12:38 PM.
A few years ago, my 2008 Mini Cooper S R56 N14 engine was rebuilt (forged pistons, valves, timing chain, coil packs, MAF sensor). I don’t drive it much. Battery was replaced in November. The car is catless, has a larger intercooler, 1‑step colder plugs, and an AEM intake. It’s tuned, and the only recurring code I normally get is:
- 2B5F — DME: Air mass sensor, correction signal
Yesterday I went for a Costco run and then to the mall. While driving, I got these codes:
- 2D8E — DME: Knock sensor, electric
- 2D50— DME: Super knocking
The car went into limp mode for a few minutes, then recovered and drove normally. Later, at a downhill stoplight on the way home, the car shut off without me noticing. When the light turned green, I tried to accelerate and realized the engine was off. It would crank but not start. Since it’s a manual and I was on a downhill, I tried bump‑starting it — nothing. Had to tow it home.
I recharged the battery, but it still only cranks and won’t start. I have a basic OBD2 scanner (Xtool) and captured some data during cranking. Before this issue, maybe 1 out of 5 starts would crank longer than usual, but it always eventually started.
Right now I’m not sure if this is: High‑pressure fuel pump, Low‑pressure fuel pump, Bad JBE module, or something else entirely.
Any ideas on how to test these with limited tools?
- 2B5F — DME: Air mass sensor, correction signal
Yesterday I went for a Costco run and then to the mall. While driving, I got these codes:
- 2D8E — DME: Knock sensor, electric
- 2D50— DME: Super knocking
The car went into limp mode for a few minutes, then recovered and drove normally. Later, at a downhill stoplight on the way home, the car shut off without me noticing. When the light turned green, I tried to accelerate and realized the engine was off. It would crank but not start. Since it’s a manual and I was on a downhill, I tried bump‑starting it — nothing. Had to tow it home.
I recharged the battery, but it still only cranks and won’t start. I have a basic OBD2 scanner (Xtool) and captured some data during cranking. Before this issue, maybe 1 out of 5 starts would crank longer than usual, but it always eventually started.
Right now I’m not sure if this is: High‑pressure fuel pump, Low‑pressure fuel pump, Bad JBE module, or something else entirely.
Any ideas on how to test these with limited tools?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Minimsippi
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
5
Aug 17, 2020 03:16 PM
H.Chi
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
2
Feb 18, 2020 06:14 PM






