Here are five reasons why I think MINI thought of a Coupe as a cheaper Roadster:

1. It has added weight due to bracing for top down motoring ...
2. There's no auto window-up, because canvas tops can't have pinch sensors
3. No grab handle can be attached to the canvas top
4. Seat belt anchors cannot be mounted to the B pillars
5. Stronger (and therefore noisier) heater fan

I do like my car, but I wish our Coupes were more a sportier hatchback and less a cheaper Roadster.

 

You are not driving the same car as me then. The points you raise do not compare to the sheer driving pleasure this car affords. I have an R56 and the R58 and out the two prefer the R58 hands down. Overall a more satisfying driver experience.

 

Now imagine how much more satisfying it would be without the weight added because of the Roadster...

 

I've driven the Roadster. Nice car, but it doesn't feel as planted and stable. the loss of the roof and the support structure affected it.

Not saying the Roadster isn't nice, just give the choice I'd go with the Coupe'r every time.