go with the sunroof! i have a 2003 pure silver with a black roof. sunroof is tinted and matches the black roof EXACTLY. i do agree with the fact that it would have been nice to have a solid sunshade but ..... also i agree, my last car i never used the sunroof...this one...every day!! as far as rattle and leaks go...since 2003 when new havnt had any yet. every couple of years it makes a weird snap sound but re-lubin takes care of that.