R56 Speaker Doesn't Like the Rain
Speaker Doesn't Like the Rain
So...my MCS is just over 2 months old. Summer is turning to fall and we are having the occasional rain shower here in Sacramento. Last Friday it rained. While it was raining, an odd noise began to accompany all sound coming from the right passenger door speakers (one or both, not sure--I do not have the hi-fi system for those who are wondering). I can only describe the sound as a vibrating overtone. It was most obviously heard when I played acoustic guitar music and least heard with more electronic stuff.
Rain went away...within 12hrs, the noise went away as well. 3 days later it rains again. The noise is back. Again, within 8-10hrs of the rain stopping, the noise is gone.
Perhaps the association with the rain is pure coincidence, a confounder? They certainly seem temporally related. No rain since, but I'm waiting to see if it will be 3/3. Could the rain be leaking into the door and causing issues with the speaker? No obvious evidence of this...
Anyone have similar problems? Any theories?
Rain went away...within 12hrs, the noise went away as well. 3 days later it rains again. The noise is back. Again, within 8-10hrs of the rain stopping, the noise is gone.
Perhaps the association with the rain is pure coincidence, a confounder? They certainly seem temporally related. No rain since, but I'm waiting to see if it will be 3/3. Could the rain be leaking into the door and causing issues with the speaker? No obvious evidence of this...
Anyone have similar problems? Any theories?
Blame it on the rain, yea yea.... - Milli Vanilli
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwrL9...illi%20vanilli
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwrL9...illi%20vanilli
Last edited by r56mini; Oct 18, 2007 at 11:01 PM.
This is the only explanation I can come up with...trouble is, I'd like to take the car in while it's actually making the noise. I had an appointment scheduled for Monday, but it went away by then...
Take your MA through the car wash?
Trending Topics
I'm not sure a car wash is enough water for long enough. I haven't noticed the noise after washing the car myself...but the thought of my MA running alongside the car getting wet is pretty funny...

And Modnar...love your sig.
I do have a sunroof. Haven't noticed a leak...wouldn't it have to be dripping down the interior of the car to the speaker?
I'm not sure a car wash is enough water for long enough. I haven't noticed the noise after washing the car myself...but the thought of my MA running alongside the car getting wet is pretty funny...
And Modnar...love your sig.
I'm not sure a car wash is enough water for long enough. I haven't noticed the noise after washing the car myself...but the thought of my MA running alongside the car getting wet is pretty funny...

And Modnar...love your sig.
Last edited by djam43; Oct 20, 2007 at 05:18 AM. Reason: addenda
There are drains in the doors. They might be blocked. When I changed my speakers out I did it a few hours after I washed the car and there was still water in the door panel. Good thing I got the Polks that are Marine grade
There hasn't been much rain in my area this winter, but we've finally had a couple bouts in the past two weeks. On both occasions, same speaker noise. I took the car in and they disassembled the door...no water, all looked normal. It dried up again and the noise went away. Now they're back--both the rain and the noise. This time they say they'll just replace the speaker...I guess we'll see if it happens with the new one.
wondermini, hope the new speaker works out for you. How has your experience with Niello MINI been? I just moved to Sac and haven't had to see them yet... I'm hoping they treat you good? Offer loaners?
Also... even more off-topic (Sorry!), can you reccomend a DIY car-wash place in Sacramento (around Natomas would be great)? I just want to be able to use a pressure washer, then just scrub down the bugs from the bumper (etc), then take her home for a wax. sorry for thread jack.
Also... even more off-topic (Sorry!), can you reccomend a DIY car-wash place in Sacramento (around Natomas would be great)? I just want to be able to use a pressure washer, then just scrub down the bugs from the bumper (etc), then take her home for a wax. sorry for thread jack.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Navigation & Audio HK Replacement With New Components
Filmy
Navigation & Audio
15
Jun 6, 2023 06:27 AM
patsum
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
26
May 29, 2021 06:29 PM



