R50/53 MCS vs GTI
My wife had a Jetta 1.8T, sorry to say, but it is faster-drag, it is quicker than the MCS, chip the thing and it is no contest.
But this isn't a drag racer so who the hell cares, otherwise you would have bought a mustang or something. Sometimes I even get stuck into looking at 0-60 times and 1/4 times and I don't own a drag car (Nissan 350Z, Honda Pilot, MCS).
But this isn't a drag racer so who the hell cares, otherwise you would have bought a mustang or something. Sometimes I even get stuck into looking at 0-60 times and 1/4 times and I don't own a drag car (Nissan 350Z, Honda Pilot, MCS).
MINI Cooper S (R53)
0-60 mph.........7.1 sec.
1/4 Mile...........15.2 sec. @ 92.4 mph
Slalom.............61.6 mph (700 ft.)
Skidpad...........0.87 g (200 ft.)
60-0 Braking.....123 ft.
Volkswagen MKV GTI
0-60 mph.........6.9 sec.(manual), 6.7 sec.(DSG)
1/4 Mile...........15.1 sec @ 92.1 mph (manual)
Slalom.............61.8 mph (700 ft.)
Skidpad...........0.84 g (200 ft.)
60-0 Braking.....129 ft.
http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/...omparison_test
0-60 mph.........7.1 sec.
1/4 Mile...........15.2 sec. @ 92.4 mph
Slalom.............61.6 mph (700 ft.)
Skidpad...........0.87 g (200 ft.)
60-0 Braking.....123 ft.
Volkswagen MKV GTI
0-60 mph.........6.9 sec.(manual), 6.7 sec.(DSG)
1/4 Mile...........15.1 sec @ 92.1 mph (manual)
Slalom.............61.8 mph (700 ft.)
Skidpad...........0.84 g (200 ft.)
60-0 Braking.....129 ft.
http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/...omparison_test
Last edited by Xymox; Jul 21, 2008 at 08:01 AM.
This thread is nearly a year & a 1/2 old, for those that hadn't noticed. Anyway, I've kept pace for a 1/4 mile with my stock pullied 2004 MCS with a new MkV GTI. For comparison purposes only, of course. IMO, driver ability and reaction time will have a more pronounced effect on a straightline race than any significant difference between the cars themselves...
^^^ hahahahha... a 1.5 year old thread... it liiiiives!!
fwiw, we have a mk5 gti with giac software and my 06 mcs with giac software and hands down, mk5 is faster. he has cai, rear sway, lowered... i have pulley w/ no cai, but lowered as well.
although, neither of us have done auto-x yet... hopefully in september so i can beat him at that...
fwiw, we have a mk5 gti with giac software and my 06 mcs with giac software and hands down, mk5 is faster. he has cai, rear sway, lowered... i have pulley w/ no cai, but lowered as well.
although, neither of us have done auto-x yet... hopefully in september so i can beat him at that...
since you got the revised gearbox on the 05+ R53, i think you cant
loose.
on the pre-05 gearbox your destiny was determined when you engaged
the clutch in 1st from a standstill. there was no way to recover if you
under rev'ed and engaged due to the tall 1st gear.
loose.
on the pre-05 gearbox your destiny was determined when you engaged
the clutch in 1st from a standstill. there was no way to recover if you
under rev'ed and engaged due to the tall 1st gear.
I actually was on the "back straight" of a track and took an 08 GTI from 55 MPH and by the time we were in triple digits I was around 3-4 car lenghts ahead and pulling away. This is with Pulley, CAI, Headers, Cat-Back,Head, and a RMW Tune...
Absolutely makes sense. Not sure what year your MCS is, but the mods you listed on a '05/'06 should make approx 200hp & 185 ft.lbs at the wheel in a car thats 2700lbs +/-. The GTI has a wide power band, but unless it's chipped it can't match the power and it weighs about 500lbs more. And I can't help but think about how many GTI's I've seen with big, heavy 18" wheels. Those things gotta weigh more than S-lights, which means I'm saving 10lbs a corner with my 15lb Rotas.
I've done worse to the old R32's... Damn are those things heavy and slow...It's a shame VW put's a VR6 and not a hopped up 1.8t with around 275hp... Now your talking about a Evo killer...They would have top do something about the handling issue though.(Can you say Lean to the left-Lean to the right)
With all those mods that is predictable/expectable
My wife's 03 MCS, is modded modestly with CAI, Exhaust, 15% pulley, 2% crank pulley, and only three stickers. My FJ Cruiser has the TRD CAI and exhaust and the 4.0 with at least nine stickers and she beats me all the time...looks like I need more stickers and badges.
Seriously though, throug my work I was sent to a few driving/off road/stunt/PSD/Rally/racing schools. Those schools made a big difference, especially if I were to get serious in the realm of AutoX. E-braking and lite foot braking big and small cars, big and heavy trucks into a 90 degree stop into a box takes some getting use to.
Seriously though, throug my work I was sent to a few driving/off road/stunt/PSD/Rally/racing schools. Those schools made a big difference, especially if I were to get serious in the realm of AutoX. E-braking and lite foot braking big and small cars, big and heavy trucks into a 90 degree stop into a box takes some getting use to.
Last edited by Jim&Tammy; Jul 25, 2008 at 02:18 PM.
driving school
My wife's 03 MCS, is modded modestly with CAI, Exhaust, 15% pulley, 2% crank pulley, and only three stickers. My FJ Cruiser has the TRD CAI and exhaust and the 4.0 with at least nine stickers and she beats me all the time...looks like I need more stickers and badges.
Seriously though, throug my work I was sent to a few driving/off road/stunt/PSD/Rally/racing schools. Those schools made a big difference, especially if I were to get serious in the realm of AutoX. E-braking and lite foot braking big and small cars, big and heavy trucks into a 90 degree stop into a box takes some getting use to.
Seriously though, throug my work I was sent to a few driving/off road/stunt/PSD/Rally/racing schools. Those schools made a big difference, especially if I were to get serious in the realm of AutoX. E-braking and lite foot braking big and small cars, big and heavy trucks into a 90 degree stop into a box takes some getting use to.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
wildwestrider
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
13
Dec 27, 2015 08:20 PM
wildwestrider
Detailing 101
1
Sep 11, 2015 08:15 AM




