GTI mk5 test drive
Originally Posted by MINIotaple
It looks like a normal interior? I don't see how the interiors in our cars are any better. There's a crapload of shiny plastic.
That steering wheel on the GTi is cool, but it should be smaller with a flatter bottom. And why does it not have climate control? From the pictures it looks like it has a normal air conditioning system...
And another thing, why is it that if I want leather, I have to pay $3k+ for a package on the GTi... otherwise you have to keep the cloth and I don't know where I stand with the cloth yet...
That steering wheel on the GTi is cool, but it should be smaller with a flatter bottom. And why does it not have climate control? From the pictures it looks like it has a normal air conditioning system...
And another thing, why is it that if I want leather, I have to pay $3k+ for a package on the GTi... otherwise you have to keep the cloth and I don't know where I stand with the cloth yet...
Originally Posted by ScuderiaMini
so much language.... Slow down... I had an 05 MCS with all kinds of mods, and had to be in service every month for bunch of reasons. The new generation GTI is far superior than the old one. Just accept the fact that GTI is a nice vehicle, completely different than the MCS, and btw, your motor is made by Chrysler which makes Neons, and all other crap.... Have a little tolarence, and 07 will not eat nothing, unless they put a bigger motor than 1.6, which won't even happen in your dreams. Enough boy talk, both cars are wonderful, both have different personalities, and finally you are not acting different than those hard headed guys on VW forums, making a fool out of yourself.
Originally Posted by Mineon
Wow, you're acusing others of being intolerant and foolish, yet you're doing the same thing you're accusing others of. I can only hope my Mini is as reliable as my Neon was. I've owned two Neons, the first one gave me 9 1/2 trouble free years (115,000 miles), and was heavily modified as well. The Neons were definitely more reliable than the five VW's my wife and I have owned (including a GTI). I haven't had my MC long enough to form an opinion of its long term reliability. My GTI, Neons, and Mini all have had good and bad qualities. The new GTI does appear to be a nice vehicle overall, its just not for me (it weighs about 1000 lbs more than my old GTI did.....no thanks). Also, don't pass judgement on the '07 Mini yet (at least not until it is released) it makes you look a little foolish. Great things can be done with small displacement.

Originally Posted by MINISPIDER
Not true....that's a web site's choice....the dealer is willing to work with you on the leather seats and the radio....you do not have to have satellite if you don't want and you don't have to any of those packages on their web site, the are willing to split them up according to the dealer I went last sunday here in Miami.
Why do you all hate VW? Is it because you're driving a BMW?!
I have never look at JD reports when I buy a car. If you shop for a car base on that you will end up getting a corolla or a civic at the end.
I have more problems on my MINI than all of my VW and AUDI combined and I have never hated my MINI.
I don't understand why it is a big deal with 1000lbs lighter. Although, JCW MCS has 1000lbs lighter and same 200hp, but it's still runs the same 0-60 and same speed around the track.
Chip your MINI and get 10hp vs. 40hp on the GTI. If you buy a car to mod a GTI is the one to get.
I'm not a big fan of the new GTI body design, but MY FAST told me that I need one in black.
I would take a GTI for everyday driving and take a MINI for a weekend.
I have never look at JD reports when I buy a car. If you shop for a car base on that you will end up getting a corolla or a civic at the end.
I have more problems on my MINI than all of my VW and AUDI combined and I have never hated my MINI.
I don't understand why it is a big deal with 1000lbs lighter. Although, JCW MCS has 1000lbs lighter and same 200hp, but it's still runs the same 0-60 and same speed around the track.
Chip your MINI and get 10hp vs. 40hp on the GTI. If you buy a car to mod a GTI is the one to get.
I'm not a big fan of the new GTI body design, but MY FAST told me that I need one in black.

I would take a GTI for everyday driving and take a MINI for a weekend.
You are funny
First of all, all cars are human made, go to technical threads here and see how many problems ppl have on their Minis. There is no problem free car. My wife drives a 2004 TDI with close to 25K, not a single problem, I owned several GTIs including highly modified VR6, did I have problems, yes, absolutely, did those problems stop me from enjoying my ride? Nope. I love Mini Coopers to death, that is the reason we are buying one for my wife, so I can get the cravings taken care of, when needed. I am not defending one over another, I am presenting the differences to those who really care, not for those including yourself that only speculate.
First of all, all cars are human made, go to technical threads here and see how many problems ppl have on their Minis. There is no problem free car. My wife drives a 2004 TDI with close to 25K, not a single problem, I owned several GTIs including highly modified VR6, did I have problems, yes, absolutely, did those problems stop me from enjoying my ride? Nope. I love Mini Coopers to death, that is the reason we are buying one for my wife, so I can get the cravings taken care of, when needed. I am not defending one over another, I am presenting the differences to those who really care, not for those including yourself that only speculate.
Originally Posted by Mineon
Wow, you're acusing others of being intolerant and foolish, yet you're doing the same thing you're accusing others of. I can only hope my Mini is as reliable as my Neon was. I've owned two Neons, the first one gave me 9 1/2 trouble free years (115,000 miles), and was heavily modified as well. The Neons were definitely more reliable than the five VW's my wife and I have owned (including a GTI). I haven't had my MC long enough to form an opinion of its long term reliability. My GTI, Neons, and Mini all have had good and bad qualities. The new GTI does appear to be a nice vehicle overall, its just not for me (it weighs about 1000 lbs more than my old GTI did.....no thanks). Also, don't pass judgement on the '07 Mini yet (at least not until it is released) it makes you look a little foolish. Great things can be done with small displacement.
cool. i don't want to spend too much on this commuter im
picturing... although i usually end up spending more than i usually
plan.. hahaha.
so the regular non-GTi 5door vs the Maz3 wagon...that would be a good/fair
comparison?
picturing... although i usually end up spending more than i usually
plan.. hahaha.
so the regular non-GTi 5door vs the Maz3 wagon...that would be a good/fair
comparison?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



