Hault and Catch Fire
Joined: Jul 2021
Posts: 2,431
Likes: 1,505
From: Anywhere but here
Hault and Catch Fire
Q: What would cause an alternator to catch fire?
I'm looking at maybe, purchasing a 2012 Clubman that sustained some "minor"(?) fire damage.
The owner stated that when they had brought the car in for a battery replacement at their mechanic's garage; right after replacing the battery and starting the car - the alternator immediately caught fire.
Although there was definite signs of soot and evidence a small blaze had occurred, I tried to inspect the wiring the best that I could see but couldn't really determine how much wiring had been melted.
The owner had the car towed home and hasn't driven the car in 6months or had made any further investigation or repairs to the cause or replaced parts. "They've put enough into the car and just as soon sell it".
I've never had an experience where replacing a battery would cause the alternator to catch fire...
Anyone care to guess?
Thanks!
I'm looking at maybe, purchasing a 2012 Clubman that sustained some "minor"(?) fire damage.
The owner stated that when they had brought the car in for a battery replacement at their mechanic's garage; right after replacing the battery and starting the car - the alternator immediately caught fire.
Although there was definite signs of soot and evidence a small blaze had occurred, I tried to inspect the wiring the best that I could see but couldn't really determine how much wiring had been melted.
The owner had the car towed home and hasn't driven the car in 6months or had made any further investigation or repairs to the cause or replaced parts. "They've put enough into the car and just as soon sell it".
I've never had an experience where replacing a battery would cause the alternator to catch fire...
Anyone care to guess?
Thanks!
Joined: Jul 2021
Posts: 2,431
Likes: 1,505
From: Anywhere but here
Thanks for the quick response and advice!
As much as I've been wanting a Clubman for a long time, this one (although not an S), looks (externally) to be extremely well cared for. The price is "seemingly" at a bargain. However, after grappling with it internally and not knowing enough about these models as well as its maintenance history with their non exclusive Mini mechanic - pretty much is a telltale sign that their chosen mechanic may also be somewhat questionable.
With that being said; Sad as it may be - I have to agree with your advice and grab my running shoes.
Bummer - I was hoping this might be the one.
Thanks
As much as I've been wanting a Clubman for a long time, this one (although not an S), looks (externally) to be extremely well cared for. The price is "seemingly" at a bargain. However, after grappling with it internally and not knowing enough about these models as well as its maintenance history with their non exclusive Mini mechanic - pretty much is a telltale sign that their chosen mechanic may also be somewhat questionable.
With that being said; Sad as it may be - I have to agree with your advice and grab my running shoes.
Bummer - I was hoping this might be the one.
Thanks
Joined: Jul 2021
Posts: 2,431
Likes: 1,505
From: Anywhere but here

let's just say I'm a bit frugal.
@140k mi for less than $3k seemed like something I would've been very interested in. But....
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
khnitz
Stock Problems/Issues
3
Oct 28, 2021 08:36 PM
rkj__
R60/R61 Stock Problems/Issues
6
Oct 15, 2019 07:11 AM
owl
Stock Problems/Issues
5
Apr 8, 2009 05:06 PM









