F55/F56 Complexity: Battery replacement division
I haven't paid any attention to it either, but nothing would surprise me.
Back in the day, BMW used to make wipers easy by using Bosch blades that were refillable by changing just the rubber insert. Cheap. Easy. Quick. You could buy those refills lots of places for <$5 each. And, even better they were long enough to fit all applications so you could buy just one part number and cut to fit. (Porsche used the same wiper which was a nice bonus) This was the time when BMW was interested primarily in performance and Gee-Whiz idiotic 'features' were nowhere in sight. Something happened (Chris Bangle?) around the early 2000s that changed this, starting with one of the worst ideas I've ever seen in a car -- idrive. OMG, it was horrible beyond words. That's when I gave up on BMW. They simply lost the plot.
Back in the day, BMW used to make wipers easy by using Bosch blades that were refillable by changing just the rubber insert. Cheap. Easy. Quick. You could buy those refills lots of places for <$5 each. And, even better they were long enough to fit all applications so you could buy just one part number and cut to fit. (Porsche used the same wiper which was a nice bonus) This was the time when BMW was interested primarily in performance and Gee-Whiz idiotic 'features' were nowhere in sight. Something happened (Chris Bangle?) around the early 2000s that changed this, starting with one of the worst ideas I've ever seen in a car -- idrive. OMG, it was horrible beyond words. That's when I gave up on BMW. They simply lost the plot.
I searched and found this tread. My Diehard battery was beginning to become weak since it's winter. Went to Sears, found it had 10 days left on the warrantee. That's the good part.
So they tested it. Which seemed to have killed the battery. Using their jump-start machine, it would turn over, but not catch and run. Then they found there wasn't a replacement in stock (seriously?), but got one in today. They called me to ask if I had another key, no. I asked why, they said it won't start.
So I see some people had to get the dealer to reset the car? But some didn't. When I got this Diehard, I didn't. Now it seems like I have to?
So they tested it. Which seemed to have killed the battery. Using their jump-start machine, it would turn over, but not catch and run. Then they found there wasn't a replacement in stock (seriously?), but got one in today. They called me to ask if I had another key, no. I asked why, they said it won't start.
So I see some people had to get the dealer to reset the car? But some didn't. When I got this Diehard, I didn't. Now it seems like I have to?
I searched and found this tread. My Diehard battery was beginning to become weak since it's winter. Went to Sears, found it had 10 days left on the warrantee. That's the good part.
So they tested it. Which seemed to have killed the battery. Using their jump-start machine, it would turn over, but not catch and run. Then they found there wasn't a replacement in stock (seriously?), but got one in today. They called me to ask if I had another key, no. I asked why, they said it won't start.
So I see some people had to get the dealer to reset the car? But some didn't. When I got this Diehard, I didn't. Now it seems like I have to?
So they tested it. Which seemed to have killed the battery. Using their jump-start machine, it would turn over, but not catch and run. Then they found there wasn't a replacement in stock (seriously?), but got one in today. They called me to ask if I had another key, no. I asked why, they said it won't start.
So I see some people had to get the dealer to reset the car? But some didn't. When I got this Diehard, I didn't. Now it seems like I have to?
just want to add my .02 but bmw has been doing this for a few years now. All you need to do is find one of them tech savvy people that does coding and you can do it without going to the dealer and for MUCH less $. If anyone needs coding, gps map updates, or this in the Austin, TX area just hit me up.
^did you have to take it to the dealer or code in the new battery or just plug n play? I had the 21lb braille in my 135i back in the day and never had any issues either. I have been running 17 lb motorcycle batteries in my Porsche for years now lol. Can you post a pic of how you mounted it? I plan on going lighter in my f56 as well.
^did you have to take it to the dealer or code in the new battery or just plug n play? I had the 21lb braille in my 135i back in the day and never had any issues either. I have been running 17 lb motorcycle batteries in my Porsche for years now lol. Can you post a pic of how you mounted it? I plan on going lighter in my f56 as well.
intelligent battery sensor or IBS will have a thicker cable that looks like it has module w=attached near the end of the terminal. In most cases when you change a battery with that the car will need flashed for a new battery.
__________________

MINI Guru/ MINI Owner Since 2004 | NEW Lifetime Part Replacement | Local Pickup
Milltek | Genuine MINI | Forge Motorsport | NM Engineering | ECS Performance | M7 Speed
Customer Service Hours: 8am-8pm EST|Sales Team Hours: 8am-11pm | SAT 10am-7pm 800.924.5172

MINI Guru/ MINI Owner Since 2004 | NEW Lifetime Part Replacement | Local Pickup
Milltek | Genuine MINI | Forge Motorsport | NM Engineering | ECS Performance | M7 Speed
Customer Service Hours: 8am-8pm EST|Sales Team Hours: 8am-11pm | SAT 10am-7pm 800.924.5172
Ah, any more info.
__________________

MINI Guru/ MINI Owner Since 2004 | NEW Lifetime Part Replacement | Local Pickup
Milltek | Genuine MINI | Forge Motorsport | NM Engineering | ECS Performance | M7 Speed
Customer Service Hours: 8am-8pm EST|Sales Team Hours: 8am-11pm | SAT 10am-7pm 800.924.5172

MINI Guru/ MINI Owner Since 2004 | NEW Lifetime Part Replacement | Local Pickup
Milltek | Genuine MINI | Forge Motorsport | NM Engineering | ECS Performance | M7 Speed
Customer Service Hours: 8am-8pm EST|Sales Team Hours: 8am-11pm | SAT 10am-7pm 800.924.5172
I see you have a Volcanic Orange, my loaner was that color, love it.
I went to PepBoys and picked up a perfectly matching "Made in Germany" replacement battery and VROOM just like in old days!
In case (which probably is true) the car has some kind of memory that keeps track of how much capacity the battery can hold, it may not be ideal if you simply replaced the battery without doing the proper coding or whatever it involves. I wish there were more information on this.
In case (which probably is true) the car has some kind of memory that keeps track of how much capacity the battery can hold, it may not be ideal if you simply replaced the battery without doing the proper coding or whatever it involves. I wish there were more information on this.
Do you have any specifics on this battery?
This is what I got.
https://www.pepboys.com/product/details/838838/00880
The dimension/shape is EXACTLY as same as that of the original F56 battery. I'm thinking they might be the same battery and just in different color and packaging/label.
So far no check engine light, no code, no unusual symptoms, etc., after driving 200+miles. My Mini starts/runs perfectly just like with the original factory that came with.
I was a bit surprised this PepBoys battery came with FREE REPLACEMENT warranty instead of their typical prorated program. I went to AutoZone as well and they do have also for F56 at $209, but their warranty is only 36-month (not sure if free replacement or prorated) and it is DuraLast brand (not sure where it is actually made nor if it is a rebadged other brand battery). I tried CostCo too but they don't have AGM battery for F56. Any nearby Mini dealers's parts department was closed on Sunday.
https://www.pepboys.com/product/details/838838/00880
The dimension/shape is EXACTLY as same as that of the original F56 battery. I'm thinking they might be the same battery and just in different color and packaging/label.
So far no check engine light, no code, no unusual symptoms, etc., after driving 200+miles. My Mini starts/runs perfectly just like with the original factory that came with.
I was a bit surprised this PepBoys battery came with FREE REPLACEMENT warranty instead of their typical prorated program. I went to AutoZone as well and they do have also for F56 at $209, but their warranty is only 36-month (not sure if free replacement or prorated) and it is DuraLast brand (not sure where it is actually made nor if it is a rebadged other brand battery). I tried CostCo too but they don't have AGM battery for F56. Any nearby Mini dealers's parts department was closed on Sunday.
In case (which probably is true) the car has some kind of memory that keeps track of how much capacity the battery can hold, it may not be ideal if you simply replaced the battery without doing the proper coding or whatever it involves. I wish there were more information on this.
I don't have any experience with replacing the battery on my 2015 F56, so I'm just speaking out of my ***, lol.
Good for you!
Now you know what to do and what to expect when the time comes for you to replace one.
I just couldn't understand how a less than 3-yr old battery could die, especially on a car that's driven almost daily. I've owned 12+ new cars in my life and this was the SHORTEST lived battery ever. It's quite disappointing to see the label on this short lived battery saying "Made in Germany" with the BMW logo on the top - who claims to make the Ultimate Driving Machine with German engineering?!
Even my POS Dodge truck's battery lasted 9 years.
Good for you! 
Now you know what to do and what to expect when the time comes for you to replace one.
I just couldn't understand how a less than 3-yr old battery could die, especially on a car that's driven almost daily. I've owned 12+ new cars in my life and this was the SHORTEST lived battery ever. It's quite disappointing to see the label on this short lived battery saying "Made in Germany" with the BMW logo on the top - who claims to make the Ultimate Driving Machine with German engineering?!
Even my POS Dodge truck's battery lasted 9 years.
Now you know what to do and what to expect when the time comes for you to replace one.
I just couldn't understand how a less than 3-yr old battery could die, especially on a car that's driven almost daily. I've owned 12+ new cars in my life and this was the SHORTEST lived battery ever. It's quite disappointing to see the label on this short lived battery saying "Made in Germany" with the BMW logo on the top - who claims to make the Ultimate Driving Machine with German engineering?!
Even my POS Dodge truck's battery lasted 9 years.
While we are speaking about the battery, this battery specifically says "to not charge with over 14.8V even when it's low on battery, and do not use rapid charging programs". I found this in the Rheingold manual somewhere.
I never charged the battery using ANY charger.
It's very strange that my dead battery lived a perfectly easy life and still died at such young age:
> Driven almost daily about 60 miles a day. Now has 66000 miles.
> Never accidentally drained it, like by leaving light on over night.
> Never jumped to itself or other (dead) battery.
> Never lived in a harsh climate like too cold or too hot.
> Never taken out of the car for any reason.
> Never had to power any additional/aftermarket electronics (100% stock!).
I checked charging voltage of the alternator it ranged between 13.0 and 14. volts depending on rpm. So, car's charging system is OK.
I don't think I've ever had an OEM battery last more than 3 years. I had an '02 MINI Cooper S back before the large-scale BMWification of the brand. The battery was in the proper spot (the boot) and when I needed a new one, I bought an Optima that did last 6 years and needed no programming. My '14 VW Golf battery died last year (3 years...) and I was surprised to see the radio didn't even lose its stations for the couple minutes the battery was disconnected. Stuff like this is making it very hard to come back to the MINI brand.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
stevepsd
1st Gen Countryman (R60) Talk (2010-2015)
35
Dec 6, 2022 03:22 PM
polotska
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
4
Aug 23, 2015 03:03 PM







