Suspension Chassis stiffness same with rear seats down?
Having removed, installed, and removed my rear seats multiple times before finally selling them, I can honestly say that I can't imagine them aiding in rigidity one bit, and I certainly never felt such a difference...
For some photos of what it looks like, here is a thread over on MINI2:
http://www.mini2.com/forum/showthrea...deck+hatchback
For some photos of what it looks like, here is a thread over on MINI2:
http://www.mini2.com/forum/showthrea...deck+hatchback
Read grassroots motorsports cooper s project car
Weight:
"The interior of the Cooper S has now been completely stripped of all door panels, carpeting, headliner and the stereo system. We removed a total of 157 lbs from the Cooper, bringing the weight from 2619 to 2463 (full tank of gas). The weight loss has helped the 0-60 times, dropping them from the low sevens to the mid 6's. Some of that weight will be returning in the form of a welded-in rollcage, which will be built early next week."
http://www.grmotorsports.com/minicoopers.html
Discussion on rear braces on bimmerfest and fold down rear seats effecting it. Apparently, the poster stated that the cars with fold down rear seats have less rigidity then rears seats with fixed seatbacks.
"The E46 with and without fold down seats is what I would base this on (from BMW):
Sedan (w/o folding seats): 18000Nm/deg of torsion
Sedan (w/folding seats): 13000Nm
There seems to be a significant decrease in rigidity by removing the structure to enable fold-down seats. I would venture that ANYTHING put in this space will further reinforce it. How you choose to reinforce it, X it diagonally, across, etc. will vary the amount of rigidity you add, but I would say it adds a whole lot more in the rear (with a wide open hole) than it would in front.
Now if you don't have fold-down seats, I would say the change will probably be small. But on the E46 coupe, which has mandatory fold-downs, I think the improvement should be significant."
http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/arc...p/t-64927.html
"The interior of the Cooper S has now been completely stripped of all door panels, carpeting, headliner and the stereo system. We removed a total of 157 lbs from the Cooper, bringing the weight from 2619 to 2463 (full tank of gas). The weight loss has helped the 0-60 times, dropping them from the low sevens to the mid 6's. Some of that weight will be returning in the form of a welded-in rollcage, which will be built early next week."
http://www.grmotorsports.com/minicoopers.html
Discussion on rear braces on bimmerfest and fold down rear seats effecting it. Apparently, the poster stated that the cars with fold down rear seats have less rigidity then rears seats with fixed seatbacks.
"The E46 with and without fold down seats is what I would base this on (from BMW):
Sedan (w/o folding seats): 18000Nm/deg of torsion
Sedan (w/folding seats): 13000Nm
There seems to be a significant decrease in rigidity by removing the structure to enable fold-down seats. I would venture that ANYTHING put in this space will further reinforce it. How you choose to reinforce it, X it diagonally, across, etc. will vary the amount of rigidity you add, but I would say it adds a whole lot more in the rear (with a wide open hole) than it would in front.
Now if you don't have fold-down seats, I would say the change will probably be small. But on the E46 coupe, which has mandatory fold-downs, I think the improvement should be significant."
http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/arc...p/t-64927.html
Originally Posted by Ryephile
I dunno about you John, but I have the Williams/BMW Formula One team fly over every morning and corner weight my MINI before I drive to work; wallet, cell phone, and sunglasses in-place, of course.


Originally Posted by meanboy
Weight:
"The interior of the Cooper S has now been completely stripped of all door panels, carpeting, headliner and the stereo system. We removed a total of 157 lbs from the Cooper, bringing the weight from 2619 to 2463 (full tank of gas). The weight loss has helped the 0-60 times, dropping them from the low sevens to the mid 6's. Some of that weight will be returning in the form of a welded-in rollcage, which will be built early next week."
http://www.grmotorsports.com/minicoopers.html
Discussion on rear braces on bimmerfest and fold down rear seats effecting it. Apparently, the poster stated that the cars with fold down rear seats have less rigidity then rears seats with fixed seatbacks.
"The E46 with and without fold down seats is what I would base this on (from BMW):
Sedan (w/o folding seats): 18000Nm/deg of torsion
Sedan (w/folding seats): 13000Nm
There seems to be a significant decrease in rigidity by removing the structure to enable fold-down seats. I would venture that ANYTHING put in this space will further reinforce it. How you choose to reinforce it, X it diagonally, across, etc. will vary the amount of rigidity you add, but I would say it adds a whole lot more in the rear (with a wide open hole) than it would in front.
Now if you don't have fold-down seats, I would say the change will probably be small. But on the E46 coupe, which has mandatory fold-downs, I think the improvement should be significant."
http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/arc...p/t-64927.html
"The interior of the Cooper S has now been completely stripped of all door panels, carpeting, headliner and the stereo system. We removed a total of 157 lbs from the Cooper, bringing the weight from 2619 to 2463 (full tank of gas). The weight loss has helped the 0-60 times, dropping them from the low sevens to the mid 6's. Some of that weight will be returning in the form of a welded-in rollcage, which will be built early next week."
http://www.grmotorsports.com/minicoopers.html
Discussion on rear braces on bimmerfest and fold down rear seats effecting it. Apparently, the poster stated that the cars with fold down rear seats have less rigidity then rears seats with fixed seatbacks.
"The E46 with and without fold down seats is what I would base this on (from BMW):
Sedan (w/o folding seats): 18000Nm/deg of torsion
Sedan (w/folding seats): 13000Nm
There seems to be a significant decrease in rigidity by removing the structure to enable fold-down seats. I would venture that ANYTHING put in this space will further reinforce it. How you choose to reinforce it, X it diagonally, across, etc. will vary the amount of rigidity you add, but I would say it adds a whole lot more in the rear (with a wide open hole) than it would in front.
Now if you don't have fold-down seats, I would say the change will probably be small. But on the E46 coupe, which has mandatory fold-downs, I think the improvement should be significant."
http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/arc...p/t-64927.html
Originally Posted by jlm
my car rattles more with the seats down
There's one easy way to find out ... buy yourself one of these: http://outmotoring.com/pilo_racing_r...tress_bar.html and see if your car stops creaking. If it does, good
... if it doesn't, remember your car is a lot stiffer
...maybe.
... if it doesn't, remember your car is a lot stiffer
...maybe.
Originally Posted by kapps
There's one easy way to find out ... buy yourself one of these: http://outmotoring.com/pilo_racing_r...tress_bar.html and see if your car stops creaking. If it does, good
... if it doesn't, remember your car is a lot stiffer
...maybe.
... if it doesn't, remember your car is a lot stiffer
...maybe.
I had a good long talk with Randy last week, and a very small part of that conversation was about the stiffeness back there. He believes that there is very little more that one can do to make things more rigid; minus the incoroporation of a full roll cage - which he has done
His reasoning is that the ridge separating the lower battery box area from the rear seats is designed quite well. It ties into the rear shock area in such a way that makes it very strong. Seats, up, down or removed are a non-issue for us.
Knowing how Randy has been through our MINI, I'll take his word on this topic.
His reasoning is that the ridge separating the lower battery box area from the rear seats is designed quite well. It ties into the rear shock area in such a way that makes it very strong. Seats, up, down or removed are a non-issue for us.
Knowing how Randy has been through our MINI, I'll take his word on this topic.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
igzekyativ
MINIs & Minis for Sale
34
Jul 16, 2020 12:54 PM



Nope. I've just been looking into it for future use. I plan on removing the rear seats as I have no use for them and I want to get something to stiffen it up a bit. 