What Makes a MINI Click? Broken Selector Shaft?
#101
No. We have had the click occur on BOTH the driver's side and the passenger side. Had 2 half-shafts replaced on the driver's side, solved the click both times...for a few weeks. So far after the last half-shaft replacement, the driver's side has not clicked anymore. On the passenger side, we have never had anything replaced. I simply re-torqued the nut and so far...so good (only been 4 or 5 days).
-Dave & Stacy
http://www.smsrallysport.com/
-Dave & Stacy
http://www.smsrallysport.com/
#103
Originally Posted by Dave&Stacy
No. We have had the click occur on BOTH the driver's side and the passenger side. Had 2 half-shafts replaced on the driver's side, solved the click both times...for a few weeks. So far after the last half-shaft replacement, the driver's side has not clicked anymore. On the passenger side, we have never had anything replaced. I simply re-torqued the nut and so far...so good (only been 4 or 5 days).
-Dave & Stacy
http://www.smsrallysport.com/
-Dave & Stacy
http://www.smsrallysport.com/
How's six days?
I just retrieved a message from my friendly SA. They're skipping the flywheel and going for the half-axle and bearings. Seems Tech Help has been at work with them.
#104
Click, click, click as the speed increases, 1st, 2nd...
Originally Posted by PARTSMAN109
Is everyone's car clicking on the drivers side?
I have a rotational click, but it's coming from the passenger side.
I have a rotational click, but it's coming from the passenger side.
I didn't have the time to argue it then but I'll be back.
Then we will have a little session in trouble shooting.
My complaint is on the record as are his comments, so we shall see.
#105
#106
#107
Originally Posted by jwardell
It will be interesting to see if the axlen-nut-retourque-only fix or the driveshaft replacement fix will fix things permanently. Still no clicks returned here, after 8 autocross runs this weekend.
I Really hope it does the trick, josh. However, if it does, it would effect my anticipation of MINIUSA knowing what's going on. They handed a list of TRY THISs to my service guys, and at the top of the list was a wheel bearing/driveaxle replacement. I hope there's a new design on the driveaxle for the number of times it has definitely worked for Dave&Stacey (0). Because that's an expensive replacement compared to a simple axle-nut-retourque that at least one dealer knows about...
#108
Ok well just got My Mini back this evening and they re-torqued the axle nut again!! My tech supervisor said that if it happens again they will write up what he said is a "Puma"(I believe that's correct) report to send to Mini and start an investigation. So far the pop and click is gone again for I guess another week.
#110
Gone on left - starting on right :(
The silence on the left axle has brought my attention to the heretofore only suspected click on the right. The dealership is VERY backed up. I will give them time to clear it up as this click evolves from detectable to constant.
The left axle has remained silent since i picked che up on saturday.
Dave and Stacy, I hope you are in the clear!
The left axle has remained silent since i picked che up on saturday.
Dave and Stacy, I hope you are in the clear!
#113
#114
Originally Posted by tontobird
Similar clicking here, just noticed it a couple of months ago on my 03 MCS. Seems to be just on the drivers side, though it's difficult to tell. At first I thought suspension, then I thought clutch or transmission. This thread isn't helping too much. Will bring it in.
what're you talkin about, michelle? We've all but arrived at a conclusive solution to the wheel click. Axle-nut retorque, baby! see first post... cheap and easy.
#116
#118
#121
#123
#125