Power Steering Pump Removal Permanently?
#51
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: a canyon, south Bay Area
Posts: 3,957
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Input #2:
I didn't found what was the issue, but I suspect that some crap got into the rack since nothing was contacting the steering joint. When I got into the car this morning, I forced the steering a bit and it went over whatever was blocking. So the lock-to-lock thingy was just a weird result from the bypass.
As for the steering in general driving, I couldn't get used to how stiff it was. Someone that like it could probably live with it. After driving it some more, I thought that there was no way I'd drive the car on the track like this (I usually go to the local track at least once a month during the season). So all in all, it wasn't my cup of tea I stayed after work and replaced the leaking rack with the reman one. Almost 6 hours later (the bolts that hold the rack were all seized and one broke), I'm back with the good ol' power steering!
I didn't found what was the issue, but I suspect that some crap got into the rack since nothing was contacting the steering joint. When I got into the car this morning, I forced the steering a bit and it went over whatever was blocking. So the lock-to-lock thingy was just a weird result from the bypass.
As for the steering in general driving, I couldn't get used to how stiff it was. Someone that like it could probably live with it. After driving it some more, I thought that there was no way I'd drive the car on the track like this (I usually go to the local track at least once a month during the season). So all in all, it wasn't my cup of tea I stayed after work and replaced the leaking rack with the reman one. Almost 6 hours later (the bolts that hold the rack were all seized and one broke), I'm back with the good ol' power steering!
Interesting... If indeed there was something in the rack, it's still there, just not obstructing as much as before. I wonder if it's possible that you did not get a true assessment of how good it might be. Wishful thinking I suppose...
From what you explain, I can't imagine anyone liking it that tough to steer. Unless there is something markedly different about our rack, it should be a desirable option on a small, light car without huge (wide) tires. That all said, this is my first FWD car, and that is seemingly not in our favor - that we need to control the power and notably torque in our hands, with no power assist.
Are there FWD cars that have PS delete options working well for them? If so, I'd venture to guess that their engines are not all that fat on torque. Hondas come-to-mind...
#52
#53
#54
Oops, I did it again. Yes, yes, I know, make up your mind, yadayadayada I had to work on the Mini to un-bolt the passenger side rack mount in order to properly install the boot that was secured just enough in the way of the mount to prevent it from sitting perfectly straight... You get what you pay for I guess. Since I only had 5 hours at work to do it and had to deal with seized bolts and a broken one, I had to get everything bolted back together so I could gtfo.
It was bothering me enough that I tried it again... This time, I made sure that there was nothing, or almost nothing, remaining in the rack. One hand on the brake disc and the other on the tie-rod end and I turned lock-to-lock until no more fluid was coming out. Same banjo fittings, same AN line, but I pulled the connector on the pump since the car was on stands and that I could reach it. Went for a road test and it's not as bad as my initial try, I'll have to drive some more to really give you an honest opinion. I then decided to plug back the pump and remove the 100amp fuse under the fuse box to prevent crap and water from getting in the connector while I make up my mind if it goes back factory or the pump goes in the "may never get used again" plastic container.
It was bothering me enough that I tried it again... This time, I made sure that there was nothing, or almost nothing, remaining in the rack. One hand on the brake disc and the other on the tie-rod end and I turned lock-to-lock until no more fluid was coming out. Same banjo fittings, same AN line, but I pulled the connector on the pump since the car was on stands and that I could reach it. Went for a road test and it's not as bad as my initial try, I'll have to drive some more to really give you an honest opinion. I then decided to plug back the pump and remove the 100amp fuse under the fuse box to prevent crap and water from getting in the connector while I make up my mind if it goes back factory or the pump goes in the "may never get used again" plastic container.
#56
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: a canyon, south Bay Area
Posts: 3,957
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
While I remain optimistic and hopeful, what little I read on this working well on FWD cars is when they were quite light, like 2,000 pounds or less...
#57
#58
I switched back to stock, once again. It's driveable, but you lose too much of what makes a Mini, a Mini. It's not that bad in parking lots, but driving around still require too much input for my liking. Someone that has a dead pump and can't afford to fix it right now could drive it safely, just need to get used to it in the mean time.
It all depends on what you're doing with your car, I'm not sure I'd recommend this for someone that takes his/her Mini to the track.
It all depends on what you're doing with your car, I'm not sure I'd recommend this for someone that takes his/her Mini to the track.
#59
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: a canyon, south Bay Area
Posts: 3,957
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Fingers crossed...
#63
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: a canyon, south Bay Area
Posts: 3,957
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Is there any reason to believe that the kit will be more drivable than Ghost's banjo & AN experimentation? Wondering if this approach has made for accurate representations of what the kit affords...
minisanity, anything more with respect to status? I'm guessing not as you would most likely shared...
minisanity, anything more with respect to status? I'm guessing not as you would most likely shared...
#64
#67
#69
Yup, having almost all the fluid out & a shorter loop would remove significant amount of steering resistance. W/ the delete, as Ghost tried, it will be between having a dead & a working pump.
#71
It's already figured out! When I tried it the second time, I drained all the fluid out and it was probably in-between. It just wasn't for me, not to mention that I take the car to the track once in a while and it wouldn't be the best idea.
#72
Seeing the SneedSpeed build thread reminded me of browsing their website... and to remember that they offer a mechanical power steering pump that use the A/C spot for mounting. So if you don't have A/C and don't mind losing 3 HP (as stated on their site), it's a good alternative to keep the power steering, but ditch the electrical pump.
http://www.sneed4speed.com/products/...-pump-kit.html
http://www.sneed4speed.com/products/...-pump-kit.html
#75
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: a canyon, south Bay Area
Posts: 3,957
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Thanks Ghost. Interesting option. I've had the dummy pulley as I plan to remove the A/C...
I'm starting to be a bit less optimistic that our MINI w/o power steering will be desirable. I've checked a few MINI race cars and current race builds, and I'm not seeing where these guys decided to ditch the stock set-up. Shedding what is probably 10 to 15 pounds, especially off the front of the car, is quite desirable. If the steering is too heavy though, making the change would not be advisable...
I'm going to ask around some more...
I'm starting to be a bit less optimistic that our MINI w/o power steering will be desirable. I've checked a few MINI race cars and current race builds, and I'm not seeing where these guys decided to ditch the stock set-up. Shedding what is probably 10 to 15 pounds, especially off the front of the car, is quite desirable. If the steering is too heavy though, making the change would not be advisable...
I'm going to ask around some more...