R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006) Cooper (R50) and Cooper S (R53) hatchback discussion.

R50/53 No more manual transmissions?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 07:53 AM
  #51  
slickfast's Avatar
slickfast
3rd Gear
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 283
Likes: 1
oh and something else: my buddy told me a story about a european friend he was talking to about AT's.

My buddy asked "do they even have Autos in europe?"

"yeah, the disabled!"
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:08 AM
  #52  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
Originally Posted by slickfast
oh and something else: my buddy told me a story about a european friend he was talking to about AT's.

My buddy asked "do they even have Autos in europe?"

"yeah, the disabled!"
I was just thinking about Europeans. I just spilled coffee all over my pants about 20 minutes ago so I drove home to get new pants (coffee colored), and while driving my MINI, which has a stick, I thought about what Europe would have to say about this. The article in The Economist said that 8 in 10 Europeans take the stick over the auto.

Here's one thing to think about- Could Europe save the MT? It is possible that MTs may be discontinued in the US but you would have to get a European delivery to get the stick. Also, Europe is small and driving is more condusive to cars with a manual transmission. However, much of Europe's population is aging, rapidly in fact. So will the aging population of Europe cause the overall numbers of AT cars to increase? Could this demographic problem be the fate of the manual transmission? Food for thought...
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:14 AM
  #53  
Ancient Mariner's Avatar
Ancient Mariner
6th Gear
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,517
Likes: 3
From: Washington. No, the other one.
Originally Posted by MINIFVR
I honestly believe that they will not completely go away. I threw out the idea that they are like carbs- they are still around because people love them...but Im still deciding whether that is the best comparison. Im trying to think of a technology that may be fading out (or faded out) that has a parallel fate to the stickshift. Any ideas?
One comes to mind (the geek portion of my mind, anyway): keyboards and mice. Touch screens and voice control are starting to come on strong, and will probably be followed by gesture control to spare the wear and tear on our fingertips. But then again, I still remember my first programming classes in the early '80s when the teacher talked about the end of paper. Won't need no stinkin' documents, it'll all be on the huge 6 foot tall, 5 MB hard drive array...
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:19 AM
  #54  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
Originally Posted by Ancient Mariner
One comes to mind (the geek portion of my mind, anyway): keyboards and mice. Touch screens and voice control are starting to come on strong, and will probably be followed by gesture control to spare the wear and tear on our fingertips. But then again, I still remember my first programming classes in the early '80s when the teacher talked about the end of paper. Won't need no stinkin' documents, it'll all be on the huge 6 foot tall, 5 MB hard drive array...
So you're thinking that touch screens and voice control will completely replace keyboards and mice? So ATs will be gone as well?
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:21 AM
  #55  
gokartride's Avatar
gokartride
6th Gear
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 38,578
Likes: 2
I'm sure some form of manual control (whether or not automatic function is also present) will exist for a long, long time.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:35 AM
  #56  
Ancient Mariner's Avatar
Ancient Mariner
6th Gear
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,517
Likes: 3
From: Washington. No, the other one.
Originally Posted by gokartride
I'm sure some form of manual control (whether or not automatic function is also present) will exist for a long, long time.
Yeah, look at the Starship Enterprise. Talk to the ship, tell it what you want (or it anticipates your needs) and it still had levers and buttons all over the place. We are a 'touchy-feely' species, after all.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:43 AM
  #57  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
Originally Posted by gokartride
I'm sure some form of manual control (whether or not automatic function is also present) will exist for a long, long time.
Well its kind of impossible not to have 'manual' control isn't it?
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 08:52 AM
  #58  
Ancient Mariner's Avatar
Ancient Mariner
6th Gear
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,517
Likes: 3
From: Washington. No, the other one.
Originally Posted by MINIFVR
Well its kind of impossible not to have 'manual' control isn't it?
Nope. "Car! Take me home! Wake me when we get there."
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 09:11 AM
  #59  
BlimeyCabrio's Avatar
BlimeyCabrio
6th Gear
iTrader: (5)
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 8,773
Likes: 9
From: Holly Springs, NC
I'm confident that there will be a thriving aftermarket for add-on shifters and pseudo-clutch pedals that connect to the computerized auto-trannies. You know, with force-feedback like good joysticks, etc. So you'll THINK you're driving a manual... for the dinosaurs out there...
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 09:29 AM
  #60  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
Originally Posted by BlimeyCabrio
I'm confident that there will be a thriving aftermarket for add-on shifters and pseudo-clutch pedals that connect to the computerized auto-trannies. You know, with force-feedback like good joysticks, etc. So you'll THINK you're driving a manual... for the dinosaurs out there...
I bet you're right. It will be a few years though before that happens. There could be as many tranny mods as there are engine mods! Imagine that!
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 10:44 AM
  #61  
dustinhxc's Avatar
dustinhxc
6th Gear
iTrader: (10)
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,210
Likes: 0
From: Woodbury, MN
Originally Posted by MINIFVR
If you do have to drive an auto it looks like your dead pedal will be getting a beating!
hahah true that

its funny because my first 2 cars were auto and then my friend got me to drive his 5 speed gti all the time and i fell in love with stick shift and now if i ever get in an auto i always hit the break with my left foot like woops ****. haha
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 10:45 AM
  #62  
2xMini's Avatar
2xMini
6th Gear
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 1
I'm with you Blimey and AM, a few years down the road electric motor hybrids with fully engaged 1sp electric motors and gas motors to just recharge batteries are going to be here to stay. Several companies got that technology in testing right now, can't wait for BMW starting to incorporate it into the MINI.

Btw, before anyone scoffs hybrids, the ones made today (called parallel hybrids) are not performance oriented. The companies Blimey mentioned make very quick electric cars... with a small gas motor to recharge batteries, you get the best of all worlds, performance AND range AND great mileage. That's what's called a series hybrid, and I think it's really the way cars will be powered in the future. Modern locomotives have been using this technology for years, and they're actually among the most efficient "road engines" today.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 10:48 AM
  #63  
2xMini's Avatar
2xMini
6th Gear
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 1
Btw, which vendor on here is now selling the paddleshifter for the manuals? I remember seeing a youtube link a little while ago. Now that's a great alternative imo to a fully manual tranny, because you eliminate missed shifts and still manually work the clutch.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 10:58 AM
  #64  
Xymox's Avatar
Xymox
5th Gear
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 793
Likes: 0
From: Harrisburg, PA
Originally Posted by 2xMini
Btw, which vendor on here is now selling the paddleshifter for the manuals? I remember seeing a youtube link a little while ago.
See post #8. https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...29&postcount=8
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 12:21 PM
  #65  
2xMini's Avatar
2xMini
6th Gear
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 1
D'oh! Thanks for the link, missed that post somehow.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 12:39 PM
  #66  
AlabamaNightfire's Avatar
AlabamaNightfire
1st Gear
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 40
Likes: 0
Considering that many of the advanced automatic transmissions now have five, six, (even eight) forward gears and are computer controlled -- there are certain vehicles in which the automatic achieves slightly better than the same car equipped with a stick shift. From personal experience, I think I typically leave the shifter in first gear longer than an automatic might (and second, and third, etc.). I guess it's reasonable that an automatic might get the same or better mileage than a stick.

But!!! Pure and simple economy aside....It's almost sinful to consider driving certain vehicles with anything other than a manual transmission. Just doesn't seem natural.

A sad thing, though, is the generation of young people who have never learned to drive a stick....experience the thrill of being in total control of a well built performance car --- like, say....a MINI. (Of course - what are they going to learn on?? If you drive down the street and pass a dozen homes - there's a good chance that none of the twelve will have a stick shift in the garage!)
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 12:53 PM
  #67  
tony1athome's Avatar
tony1athome
3rd Gear
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 288
Likes: 0
From: Silicon Valley, CA
Originally Posted by 2xMini
Btw, before anyone scoffs hybrids, the ones made today (called parallel hybrids) are not performance oriented. The companies Blimey mentioned make very quick electric cars... with a small gas motor to recharge batteries, you get the best of all worlds, performance AND range AND great mileage.

Yup, gimme a Tesla in a Mini body, please.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 12:56 PM
  #68  
eR1c's Avatar
eR1c
5th Gear
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 942
Likes: 0
From: Nor-Cal
I also remember hearing that in the future we'd not even have steering wheels, our cars would all be controlled by road sensors ...we'd just touch our GPS navigation and tell the car where we wanted to go. This was like 20 years ago, and the future is now.

Yet we still have steering wheels?

I think, what these predictions usually forget to take into account is the "people factor" ..that is people enjoy doing things that aren't always the most logical or most efficient. Getting rid of the stick may turn many car buyers away from a potential sale, thus I feel that dealers will continue to offer a variety to customers as long as there is a desire for that variety. ...i.e. $$$ talks. As long as they're making $$$ on it, they'll sell it.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 01:16 PM
  #69  
KittyMini's Avatar
KittyMini
3rd Gear
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 247
Likes: 0
First MT

My Mini is the first manual transmission car I've ever owned.
Now, I can't imagine owning a sporty car without a manual transmission.
I think it has made me a more aware driver, also.
So I think I will always buy a car with MT from now on, even with the increasing options.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 01:27 PM
  #70  
eR1c's Avatar
eR1c
5th Gear
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 942
Likes: 0
From: Nor-Cal
Now, I can't imagine owning a sporty car without a manual transmission.
exactly!
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 01:35 PM
  #71  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
I definitely see electric, not necessarily hybrid cars as future sports cars. As I posted earlier, there are already people who are getting electric cars in the 12 sec 1/4 mi range.

As for why cars aren't being driven via road sensors and GPS as predicted some years ago- its too hard to make any sort of switch in technology that most of the world depends on that fast. And as eR1c said, if companies can still sell gas powered cars they will still sell them. There is no incentive to build completely new factories and invest in new infrastructure just to be green. GM is shutting down 3 SUV plants last I heard (thank God) because they aren't selling well due to high gas prices. This type of trend will likely continue I'd bet, but it will be slow as it has been. As we have seen it has taken a lot to get people to switch to hybrids (and there aren't that many on the road).

I don't think we'll be seeing any highways like in "The Minority Report" anytime soon!
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 01:37 PM
  #72  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
Originally Posted by AlabamaNightfire
Considering that many of the advanced automatic transmissions now have five, six, (even eight) forward gears and are computer controlled -- there are certain vehicles in which the automatic achieves slightly better than the same car equipped with a stick shift. From personal experience, I think I typically leave the shifter in first gear longer than an automatic might (and second, and third, etc.). I guess it's reasonable that an automatic might get the same or better mileage than a stick.

But!!! Pure and simple economy aside....It's almost sinful to consider driving certain vehicles with anything other than a manual transmission. Just doesn't seem natural.

A sad thing, though, is the generation of young people who have never learned to drive a stick....experience the thrill of being in total control of a well built performance car --- like, say....a MINI. (Of course - what are they going to learn on?? If you drive down the street and pass a dozen homes - there's a good chance that none of the twelve will have a stick shift in the garage!)
Speaking of that generation, or my generation that is- I feel like almost no one knows how to drive a stick! With people using their cellphones while driving (the list goes on) no one really wants to worry about shifting each gear. The Acura TL my family owns is an auto. The manual trans version of the car comes with an LSD and Brembos and the price was the same or less!
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 01:43 PM
  #73  
AlabamaNightfire's Avatar
AlabamaNightfire
1st Gear
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 40
Likes: 0
A mom told me that she was going to make sure her son's first vehicle is a straight shift. Her reasoning: One hand on the wheel, one hand on the gearshift - no hands left for a cell phone.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 01:44 PM
  #74  
MINIFVR's Avatar
MINIFVR
Thread Starter
|
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: Outside of Phila, PA
Originally Posted by AlabamaNightfire
A mom told me that she was going to make sure her son's first vehicle is a straight shift. Her reasoning: One hand on the wheel, one hand on the gearshift - no hands left for a cell phone.
+1000

Thats how it should be. Not to mention even ear pieces are illegal in NJ alone.
 
Reply
Old Jun 13, 2008 | 03:25 PM
  #75  
07BPB's Avatar
07BPB
5th Gear
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 680
Likes: 1
From: Brisbane, Australia
If you have seen "What Happens in Vegas" you may have picked this up.

As Jack hops into a car, Dave the Bear says "Do you even know how to drive an automatic?"
 
Reply



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 06:18 AM.