Newbie in the market for a MINI. In everyones opinion, what is the best MINI to get? R53, R56, or F56. I'm talking reliability, performance, tuning capabilities, etc. Thanks!

 

Get a brand new one if its an option.

 

Assuming your seeking a new MINI... MINI is switching over engines from Peugeot engines to BMW. The Clubman and 4-door Cooper have already switched over to the new 3 and 4 cylinder engines. Yes I said 3 cylinder for the non-S and 4 for the S. Test drive one of those and then drive the older N18 engine in the CM/PM to feel the difference. The new engine is expected for 2017 in most of the models.

Personally, avoid the spirit limiting ALL4 unless you are opting for the safety over performance. As the ALL4 second clutch in the rear differential keeps you driving smooth and safe.

The JCW is the identical engine/transmission in the S, except for tuning. You can purchase the JCW tune from S from MINI for much less than a new JCW (yes it will not come with the external trim and larger exhaust tips)

 

Thanks for the replies! I hear the R56's are super unreliable...can this be confirmed? Some good deals out there.

 

If I were looking for a Mini, I'd look for a 2005 or 2006 R53. I've driven R56 (Cooper and a JCW coupe) and F56 (5-door Cooper and 3-door Cooper S) loaner cars and I don't like them nearly as much.

But it's up to personal preference. I don't like the seamless power of the turbo engines. I don't like the steering (though it's better in the F56). I don't like the interiors of the newer cars. I don't like how quiet the newer cars are. I don't like the styling of the new cars, etc. etc.

I suggest driving all three generations and seeing what you think. They are different enough that you're sure to prefer one of them over the others.

And I wouldn't buy any Mini if you're worried about maintenance costs!

 

Best advice I can give is go shopping like a carmax and drive all three versions. You'll find each one is different and all have slightly different soul to them.

 

For outright fun and enjoyment, and to come closest to the Classic Mini in performance, I'd recommend the R53. I have an '04 and it's amazing. Want something newer, maybe a little more refined and comfortable but arguably not as much fun, a 2011 and newer.

Drive Hard. Drive Safe. Keep Grinning.