When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
General MINI TalkShared experiences, motoring minutes, and other general MINI-related discussion that applies to all MINIs, regardless of model, year or trim.
2005 -2008 is the R52 MINI Cooper , 2009-2010 Cooper ( n12engine ), 2009-2010 Cooper S ( N14) , 2011+ Cooper is N16 engine, 2011+ Cooper S is N18 engine.
The later 2011+ Convertible or the 2005-2008 is the R52 which is what i have and like. 261K+ on mine.
Best convertible years, '05 to '07. The R52 S came with the W11 lump and the 6 speed Getrag gear box, both bullet proof. Also, while searching look for a wind deflector. The only other thing to look for are the twisty roads to nowhere.
The gen1 s has a supercharger.....IMO the whine is intoxicating.....pretty simple, iron block, well know motor...
The gen 2 has a turbo...stick to the later ones with the n18 motor IMO....most of the timing chain issues were kinda reduced, as was the carbon issues....
Drive one of each....the character of the cars are VERY different...
Gen1 more raw IMO...more of a driver's car...the gen2 more plush, more refined, bigger by a bit.
Each as their own + and -
Gotta try them...hopefully in quick succession...
Definitely the supercharger!
Whichever one you do get include taking real good care of the canvas in your routine. The preferred products for this, Ragg Topp or 303 aerospace protectant. If the scissor joints start to squeak, a shot of Liquid Wrench dry lube works fine. Don't use WD-40 for that.