Drivetrain Intercooler Cooling Tests
enough!!! stop it!!! you're starting to sound like m7. the next thing you'll be saying is that it's "delicious."
My little dose of LITHIUM
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,435
Likes: 2
From: Albuquerque New Mexico
Will we hear something on Friday in Dallas?
That would be cool...
That would be cool...
This is all true...
I was watching one of those truck mod shows on TV's and the subject changed to ICs. They stated that an A-to-A could bring temps to ambient but that a W-to-A could not - hence why most ICs are A-to-A today. They also raised expense differences as well as reliability. A-to-A for the lack of any moving parts was most reliable.
just thought I would share.
just thought I would share.
Matt
But we're all forgetting or ignoring that the stock location for the IC on the R53 sucks. I mean it really, really blows. So this is why a few years of Subies came with factory water injection, and why a good W2A is a winner on the R53. Top mount with a scoop like what we and the subies use isn't any good for peak performance. There's no getting around that fact.
Matt
Matt
As always...
it's gonna be a price vs performance deal. All the W2As are much more expensive than the A2A solutions going. Heck, at the price point of the W2As out there, one stands a good chance of building all the parts for a Tuls like A2A and having some money left in your pocket.
Anyway, I'm watching with interest here, as I can't wait to see the details of these systems as they unfold....
Matt
Anyway, I'm watching with interest here, as I can't wait to see the details of these systems as they unfold....
Matt
it's gonna be a price vs performance deal. All the W2As are much more expensive than the A2A solutions going. Heck, at the price point of the W2As out there, one stands a good chance of building all the parts for a Tuls like A2A and having some money left in your pocket.
Anyway, I'm watching with interest here, as I can't wait to see the details of these systems as they unfold....
Matt
Anyway, I'm watching with interest here, as I can't wait to see the details of these systems as they unfold....
Matt
Longboard
here are some data logs of the new system..........
notice the blower temp over 300degF
the pink is ambient and the blue line is your intake temps
enjoy................................
notice the blower temp over 300degF
the pink is ambient and the blue line is your intake temps
enjoy................................
Last edited by Revolution Mini Works; Jan 5, 2009 at 04:13 PM.
black=RPM
dark blue= blower temp
green = after stock intercooler
pink=ambient temp
the RMW SOLUTION ...........light blue = final inlet temp
More effective A2A set-up?
I had the idea for an exit scoop almost since I got my MINI but never wanted to buy another hood to make one, I was about to scan my sketches of it, but I checked the M7 site for the price on a ram scoop, and I found this, haha. I guess they beat me to it!
http://www.m7tuning.com/parts/produc...roducts_id=130
http://www.tunerschoice.com/xq/aspx/...qx/Product.htm
I had the idea for an exit scoop almost since I got my MINI but never wanted to buy another hood to make one, I was about to scan my sketches of it, but I checked the M7 site for the price on a ram scoop, and I found this, haha. I guess they beat me to it!
http://www.m7tuning.com/parts/produc...roducts_id=130
http://www.tunerschoice.com/xq/aspx/...qx/Product.htm
More effective A2A set-up?
I had the idea for an exit scoop almost since I got my MINI but never wanted to buy another hood to make one, I was about to scan my sketches of it, but I checked the M7 site for the price on a ram scoop, and I found this, haha. I guess they beat me to it!
http://www.m7tuning.com/parts/produc...roducts_id=130
http://www.tunerschoice.com/xq/aspx/...qx/Product.htm
I had the idea for an exit scoop almost since I got my MINI but never wanted to buy another hood to make one, I was about to scan my sketches of it, but I checked the M7 site for the price on a ram scoop, and I found this, haha. I guess they beat me to it!
http://www.m7tuning.com/parts/produc...roducts_id=130
http://www.tunerschoice.com/xq/aspx/...qx/Product.htm
that setup won't even get close to this...............there is NO OTHER SYSTEM on the MINI market that will get you inlet temps like the ones I posted above
btw.... the graphs above were with your STOCK intercooler
Some thoughts on the posted data...
For the first graph, you're showing intake temps below ambient. What was the water temp? I'd guess this data was from a very hot day when the reseviour had just been filled, or the car just not having been run that long to get everything in equilbrium.
To make this stuff clear to the masses (and me as well) dump it into excel, drop the lines that don't matter, and label the remaining lines with names that make some sense. I couldn't get anything of the second posts without getting a headache! If you're going to take the time to dump it into a word doc, might as well put some text explaining what's going on.
Matt
To make this stuff clear to the masses (and me as well) dump it into excel, drop the lines that don't matter, and label the remaining lines with names that make some sense. I couldn't get anything of the second posts without getting a headache! If you're going to take the time to dump it into a word doc, might as well put some text explaining what's going on.
Matt
For the first graph, you're showing intake temps below ambient. What was the water temp? I'd guess this data was from a very hot day when the reseviour had just been filled, or the car just not having been run that long to get everything in equilbrium.
To make this stuff clear to the masses (and me as well) dump it into excel, drop the lines that don't matter, and label the remaining lines with names that make some sense. I couldn't get anything of the second posts without getting a headache! If you're going to take the time to dump it into a word doc, might as well put some text explaining what's going on.
Matt
To make this stuff clear to the masses (and me as well) dump it into excel, drop the lines that don't matter, and label the remaining lines with names that make some sense. I couldn't get anything of the second posts without getting a headache! If you're going to take the time to dump it into a word doc, might as well put some text explaining what's going on.
Matt
Jan...
that's all fine and dandy. But you say pink is ambient tems, listed as about 100 degrees. And you say light blue is outlet temps with the W2A, which is below ambient. That begs the question of how that happens.
This isn't directed at you, but these posts sure could benefit from it....
When showing data. Take some time to label the data and provide a semi-detailed explanation of what was measured and how it was performed. Include some description of test conditions, and data aquisition methods.
In the world of peer-review (while this isn't it, stuff here gets picked over for sure), the standard is to provide enough information so that someone who wanted to could replicate the measurement.
While this sounds like a PITA, it takes less time than explaining all the stuff that you'll get asked afterwords....
I get that the stocker shows efficiencies from about 65% to 50%, but the W2A is showing greater than 100% up toll the end of the data log.....
Some other open issues...
1) Was the car being driven, if so at what speed?
2) If it's on a dyno, how was the A2A cooled?
I'm not trying to bust your ***** here... This is, in general, what I expect to see from a good W2A system. It's just I don't know how to interpret this particular data set cause I don't know anything about the test conditions!
Matt
This isn't directed at you, but these posts sure could benefit from it....
When showing data. Take some time to label the data and provide a semi-detailed explanation of what was measured and how it was performed. Include some description of test conditions, and data aquisition methods.
In the world of peer-review (while this isn't it, stuff here gets picked over for sure), the standard is to provide enough information so that someone who wanted to could replicate the measurement.
While this sounds like a PITA, it takes less time than explaining all the stuff that you'll get asked afterwords....
I get that the stocker shows efficiencies from about 65% to 50%, but the W2A is showing greater than 100% up toll the end of the data log.....
Some other open issues...
1) Was the car being driven, if so at what speed?
2) If it's on a dyno, how was the A2A cooled?
I'm not trying to bust your ***** here... This is, in general, what I expect to see from a good W2A system. It's just I don't know how to interpret this particular data set cause I don't know anything about the test conditions!
Matt
looks like your Stanford PhD is starting to pay off

How good will this be when I put it on my NEW W2a?

btw... I am showing the data.........this is much more than anyone else has ever shown



Do tell.