Issue after a puddle of water
#1
Issue after a puddle of water
Yesterday was a very rainy day and after passing through a puddle of water too fast in my R56 justa (35 mph) and a few blocks later, the car began to shut down when I released the accelerator (below 1K RPM).
I stopped the car and spent almost 1 hour looking for where water might have entered, but the engine was totally dry, up and down. There was no sign of being wet.
After more than 1 hour (turned off), the car began to function normally.
Obviously, the warm engine helped to dry something.
I don't like things to be solved by themselves without even suspecting where the problem could be.
Anyone know what the critical points to check in a MINI engine bay or chassis when this problem occurs? (go through large amounts of water).
I stopped the car and spent almost 1 hour looking for where water might have entered, but the engine was totally dry, up and down. There was no sign of being wet.
After more than 1 hour (turned off), the car began to function normally.
Obviously, the warm engine helped to dry something.
I don't like things to be solved by themselves without even suspecting where the problem could be.
Anyone know what the critical points to check in a MINI engine bay or chassis when this problem occurs? (go through large amounts of water).
#2
One can hydro-lock an engine with just 1/2 cup of water...something to think about when approaching a flooded area. And even under normal operation, any water splashed up to side of engine/cover would probably just evaporate somewhat quickly due to engine surface temps.
Since there is basically not much of a splash shield on right side of engine, I'm inclined to thinking the water did something to the alternator and/or accessory crank belt could have been slipping....just a guess cause some folks "puddles" are deeper than others.
And if this was a one time situation, dont over think it.
Motor on !
Since there is basically not much of a splash shield on right side of engine, I'm inclined to thinking the water did something to the alternator and/or accessory crank belt could have been slipping....just a guess cause some folks "puddles" are deeper than others.
And if this was a one time situation, dont over think it.
Motor on !
The following users liked this post:
miniuy (07-07-2017)
#3
once I parked in an area of some deep wet grass (at church)
when I left, about 5 minutes down the road the car went into limp mode. I got home and shut the car off and planned to head to the dealer the next day.
after a few hours, started the car and everything was normal and the problem never came back.
all I could figure was either by sitting in the wet dampened something, or starting up sucked in just enuf from below that it impacted a sensor.
so I agree ... if the problem stays gone don't sweat it.
(btw the horns are mounted really low and a deep puddle can drown those. I'd check em a few times and don't be surprised if they fail as they don't like baths. I've replaced a few sets ....)
when I left, about 5 minutes down the road the car went into limp mode. I got home and shut the car off and planned to head to the dealer the next day.
after a few hours, started the car and everything was normal and the problem never came back.
all I could figure was either by sitting in the wet dampened something, or starting up sucked in just enuf from below that it impacted a sensor.
so I agree ... if the problem stays gone don't sweat it.
(btw the horns are mounted really low and a deep puddle can drown those. I'd check em a few times and don't be surprised if they fail as they don't like baths. I've replaced a few sets ....)
The following users liked this post:
miniuy (07-07-2017)
#4
One can hydro-lock an engine with just 1/2 cup of water...something to think about when approaching a flooded area. And even under normal operation, any water splashed up to side of engine/cover would probably just evaporate somewhat quickly due to engine surface temps.
Since there is basically not much of a splash shield on right side of engine, I'm inclined to thinking the water did something to the alternator and/or accessory crank belt could have been slipping....just a guess cause some folks "puddles" are deeper than others.
And if this was a one time situation, dont over think it.
Motor on !
Since there is basically not much of a splash shield on right side of engine, I'm inclined to thinking the water did something to the alternator and/or accessory crank belt could have been slipping....just a guess cause some folks "puddles" are deeper than others.
And if this was a one time situation, dont over think it.
Motor on !
I was with this situation on my mind all the day.
You are talking about the engine right side and I passed the "puddle" with the right wheels!
It can not be a coincidence.
I'm going to inspect the parts you mentioned just to try to find something.
Thank you again
#5
once I parked in an area of some deep wet grass (at church)
when I left, about 5 minutes down the road the car went into limp mode. I got home and shut the car off and planned to head to the dealer the next day.
after a few hours, started the car and everything was normal and the problem never came back.
all I could figure was either by sitting in the wet dampened something, or starting up sucked in just enuf from below that it impacted a sensor.
so I agree ... if the problem stays gone don't sweat it.
(btw the horns are mounted really low and a deep puddle can drown those. I'd check em a few times and don't be surprised if they fail as they don't like baths. I've replaced a few sets ....)
when I left, about 5 minutes down the road the car went into limp mode. I got home and shut the car off and planned to head to the dealer the next day.
after a few hours, started the car and everything was normal and the problem never came back.
all I could figure was either by sitting in the wet dampened something, or starting up sucked in just enuf from below that it impacted a sensor.
so I agree ... if the problem stays gone don't sweat it.
(btw the horns are mounted really low and a deep puddle can drown those. I'd check em a few times and don't be surprised if they fail as they don't like baths. I've replaced a few sets ....)
Thank you very much for the comment and the suggestion.
#6
#7
Yesterday was a very rainy day and after passing through a puddle of water too fast in my R56 justa (35 mph) and a few blocks later, the car began to shut down when I released the accelerator (below 1K RPM).
I stopped the car and spent almost 1 hour looking for where water might have entered, but the engine was totally dry, up and down. There was no sign of being wet.
After more than 1 hour (turned off), the car began to function normally.
Obviously, the warm engine helped to dry something.
I don't like things to be solved by themselves without even suspecting where the problem could be.
Anyone know what the critical points to check in a MINI engine bay or chassis when this problem occurs? (go through large amounts of water).
I stopped the car and spent almost 1 hour looking for where water might have entered, but the engine was totally dry, up and down. There was no sign of being wet.
After more than 1 hour (turned off), the car began to function normally.
Obviously, the warm engine helped to dry something.
I don't like things to be solved by themselves without even suspecting where the problem could be.
Anyone know what the critical points to check in a MINI engine bay or chassis when this problem occurs? (go through large amounts of water).
Trending Topics
#8
On the way into work this morning (heavy rain in Northern Illinois) I didn't see the water on the road until it was too late. Apparently the car that had it's 4-ways on didn't clue me in but in my defense I didn't have any coffee yet. Luckily I didn't have any problems but I will tell you it made me nervous for a little while.
Those water on the road are very treacherous
#9
I usually avoid water (even when I had my Explorer) and find a different way but like I said, it was early, dark (no street lights there) & raining so I didn't see it until I was in the middle of it.