I think I had the "Death Rattle" - now my Mini S is dead. :(
I might do a How-To writeup when I'm done, but we'll see how I feel after the labor. It doesn't look like it'll be too much work and I can probably get a lot of other things done while I'm at it (doing timing chain, head gasket, and valve/intake manifold cleaning).
The regular tools that you'll need on a Mini that you didn't need on an Evo are a 14mm deep 12pt spark plug socket, 16mm, 18mm, Torx and possibly e-Torx sets. You'll also want a torque angle protractor.
Approximate parts cost to do the timing chain is $300. Add another $300 to do the head gasket (not including inspection or machining) and another $50 each if you want to drop the oil pan or replace the valve cover gasket.
Last edited by golgo13; Jan 18, 2013 at 05:45 PM.
... So, the oil was in fact low when I checked it this morning.
This seems rather strange, since I added a quart just about a month ago due to the low oil pressure warning showing up more and more on hills and when turning. Today I just added two quarts and the rattle (which was just valve train noise?) is somewhat gone. It was going away once warm before I added the oil, which makes it seem like the EXACT problem outlined in this thread...
This seems rather strange, since I added a quart just about a month ago due to the low oil pressure warning showing up more and more on hills and when turning. Today I just added two quarts and the rattle (which was just valve train noise?) is somewhat gone. It was going away once warm before I added the oil, which makes it seem like the EXACT problem outlined in this thread...
In more serious cases, the tensioner itself is the culprit; it fails to tension properly, and the chain gets slack, stretches, breaks -- generally bad stuff happens. Or the tensioner bolt backs out, and all the oil comes out of the engine -- again, generally bad stuff happens...

I've heard some opine that all BMW engines develop an oil consumption issue as they age; but so far, I've not seen it (knock wood)...
Last edited by golgo13; Jan 18, 2013 at 05:45 PM.
**** usually cars get better as the models get newer, like many know i have over 200K on my 02 mini and it still drives strong and no oil burning.
it seems to have been a very simple car, and less tech in the engine but it also seems more reliable than the newer 07 to 10 motors.
maybe downgrade to a later model, parts are cheaper two from what i hear.
ive spent 800 on mine to change the clutch at 180K miles but otherwise i havent had any failure on any mechanical part on the car, same timing chain as well.
good luck on your fix! from what i remember they updated the part your fixing i think it shouldent fail again.
it seems to have been a very simple car, and less tech in the engine but it also seems more reliable than the newer 07 to 10 motors.
maybe downgrade to a later model, parts are cheaper two from what i hear.
ive spent 800 on mine to change the clutch at 180K miles but otherwise i havent had any failure on any mechanical part on the car, same timing chain as well.
good luck on your fix! from what i remember they updated the part your fixing i think it shouldent fail again.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
lalroma
1st Gen Countryman (R60) Talk (2010-2015)
20
Apr 2, 2022 06:19 PM
ECSTuning
Drivetrain Products
0
Aug 10, 2015 01:59 PM



