I just bought a set of used 18" wheels for my 2009 MCS. They're in pretty good condition and I'm contemplating whether or not I should refinish them in silver or black.
I've done a mock-up in MS Paint of a couple pictures and I can't decide.

Opinions???

Thanks guys

 

They both look good. I like the silver more as the wheel pops and is much more visible.

 

I like the black wheels. Would the silver match the chrome on the car? Chrome looks good, but only if it matches the other chrome on the car.

 

I like the black. Of course one of the reasons i like them is my wife's VW GTI was a pain with the original polished wheels and i changed them to black wheels. now when she hits the curb it only takes a minute to touch up. All kidding aside many people gave her the thumps up on the black wheels. I alo have the black on my Spice Orange Cooper S and i think they look great.

 

Black... looks sinister..

 

Refinish in chrome, then PlatiDip in black.
If not happy with black, just back to chrome

 

I'm old school, I hate black wheels on everything. Go with the silver.

 

Both look good, I like the black with that whee style though.

 

Black...and its not even close.

 

IMHO the silver wheels look better. Black wheels just "disappear" against the body.