R56 '09 S R56 Clutch fail
'09 S R56 Clutch fail
My clutch failed at 66,000 Miles on my '09 Cooper S. It never slipped and the only indication something was awry was a slight groink on occasion when taking off in first gear - had been only occurring for the last five hundred miles.
Failure was as such : slowing down to stop, foot on clutch, light turned green, shift into second, released clutch, hit gas and whirrrrr....... motor revs, no forward motion ! All friction material had spun off the clutch disk into a big smoking birds nest of bad smelling stuff in the bellhousing. There was smoke !
Independent shop cost to repair with LUK replacement kit was 400+800 parts and labor ( US$ ). Flywheel and shift fork was OK. My driving style is spirited, but I don't think I abused it.
I think life was less than expected and I'm miffed that it left me stranded rather than slipping or warning me ahead of time, but I'm glad I didn't get raped by my mechanic. He did complain that book hours (alldata) for this job was less than actual, so perhaps I did get a better deal than I should have.
Just wanted to share so that others pay prompt attention to their funny clutch noises!
Failure was as such : slowing down to stop, foot on clutch, light turned green, shift into second, released clutch, hit gas and whirrrrr....... motor revs, no forward motion ! All friction material had spun off the clutch disk into a big smoking birds nest of bad smelling stuff in the bellhousing. There was smoke !
Independent shop cost to repair with LUK replacement kit was 400+800 parts and labor ( US$ ). Flywheel and shift fork was OK. My driving style is spirited, but I don't think I abused it.
I think life was less than expected and I'm miffed that it left me stranded rather than slipping or warning me ahead of time, but I'm glad I didn't get raped by my mechanic. He did complain that book hours (alldata) for this job was less than actual, so perhaps I did get a better deal than I should have.
Just wanted to share so that others pay prompt attention to their funny clutch noises!
That's go to be the worse looking pressure plate I have seen, I'm used to seeing the pressure plates fiber based material being a shiny surface. You don't have any material, I believe your pressure plate died prematurely do to the material coming off kind of how brake pad material fall apart from the backing. Recently I all my clutch components replaced and my flywheel looks much worse than yours and I still had more life in my clutch parts. I'm at 62,000 miles now and my old clutch could have made it another 25-30k miles.
'09 S R56 Clutch fail
I made it 38 k with no slip no noise even the pedal felt good than I went to shift to third heard a grind wouldn't go into third or any other gear. I fought with my SM and said this is bull 38k just ain't right my VW was 155 k still in factory clutch I mean between me and you more than half dozen autocross events and half dozen 1/4 mile launches on a stage 2+ manic tuned car so it probably got abused pretty good but still never had a warning sign very weird
I made it 38 k with no slip no noise even the pedal felt good than I went to shift to third heard a grind wouldn't go into third or any other gear. I fought with my SM and said this is bull 38k just ain't right my VW was 155 k still in factory clutch I mean between me and you more than half dozen autocross events and half dozen 1/4 mile launches on a stage 2+ manic tuned car so it probably got abused pretty good but still never had a warning sign very weird
'09 S R56 Clutch fail
well see since it went right away I kind of wasn't prepared for it and itbwss a Thursday was going away that weekend and my service manager got it don't by 4pm Friday for me and I paid 0$ so I just went with the oem clutch and new flywheel and all eventually I will just upgrade and order a stage 2-3 clutch from jm not sure if I want to swap to a light weight smf either going to cross that path when I get there
well see since it went right away I kind of wasn't prepared for it and itbwss a Thursday was going away that weekend and my service manager got it don't by 4pm Friday for me and I paid 0$ so I just went with the oem clutch and new flywheel and all eventually I will just upgrade and order a stage 2-3 clutch from jm not sure if I want to swap to a light weight smf either going to cross that path when I get there
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
cornfly888
Stock Problems/Issues
3
Aug 24, 2015 09:57 AM
R50/53 Replacement AC compressor??
PrimePower
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
9
Aug 16, 2015 06:29 PM
marendt428
MINIs & Minis for Sale
0
Aug 8, 2015 04:44 AM



