R56 So many problems with 07 MCS
I lurk on this forum, the Rennlist Forum for my Porsche 993 and the E60 Forum for my BMW 530I. As RASTVEN stated, these Internet forums amplify problems. Folks always post problems and concerns. Problem free driving is rarely posted.
Don’t be concerned with problem postings. These are cars and there will be problems. Just not to the degree that these forums would lead you to believe.
Don’t be concerned with problem postings. These are cars and there will be problems. Just not to the degree that these forums would lead you to believe.
Love it!
I can't remember when I picked up my car! Time flys when you're having FUN! Guess it was late April/early May?
I had a tiny cosmetic interior issue that had nothing to do with the car's build, but it's handling AFTER completion, possibly even after delivery to the dealer. Car is terrific!
I had a tiny cosmetic interior issue that had nothing to do with the car's build, but it's handling AFTER completion, possibly even after delivery to the dealer. Car is terrific!
Last edited by surfblue; Sep 3, 2007 at 10:15 AM. Reason: p/u date mention
Picked it up in March .. 7,800 miles .. No problems
I've been on this '07 Mini Cooper forum since last year and have seen very few problems pop up, at least on cars delivered here in the U.S. Why such a negatively worded post? Where are all these problems you mention? Are you talking about that very few that keep popping up over and over again for some interesting reason or other? This kind of situation brings to memory past years in school or work where suddenly all kinds of things are coming up stolen making it seem like the place has turned into a den of thieves. But then, in the end, it turns out to be one individual who's been the culprit all along.
I've been on this '07 Mini Cooper forum since last year and have seen very few problems pop up, at least on cars delivered here in the U.S. Why such a negatively worded post? Where are all these problems you mention? Are you talking about that very few that keep popping up over and over again for some interesting reason or other? This kind of situation brings to memory past years in school or work where suddenly all kinds of things are coming up stolen making it seem like the place has turned into a den of thieves. But then, in the end, it turns out to be one individual who's been the culprit all along.
What an absolute joy this car has been so far! T-Bone Scooter - built in July- has so far provided me with 3,600 fun-filled problem-free miles. There are a few quirky and/or semi-annoying things that I wish were different, but that's for a another discussion.
Why are there so many problems with the 07's? I was reading thru all the problems people are having, reading all that makes me not want the car anymore, do you think if they spend a little more time building the cars, it would elimate alot of problems? I mean after it's built it goes thru another check when it gets to us shores right? And they still can't see anything wrong? How many of you owners with 07's have not had 1 thing go wrong with your car?
Same thing happens with other cars and same with the 2002 MINI when introduced in the US.
My 2003 MCS was not trouble free but most things got fixed. The option is to wait. 2005 and 2006 were much better. I didn't want to wait.
I got the 1991 Dodge Caravan first year it was redesigned, lots of problems.
I got the 2001 Honda Odyssey EX first year it was redesigned, lots of problems.
I got the 2007 Honda Fit Sport first year it was introduced, some problems- not too horrible but it's close to the new MINI.
Overall I think the 2007 MINI R56 is coming along and not overly problematic. Could be more trouble free. It's an English car you know!
That takes alot of stress off my mind, knowing alot of you owner are trouble free, but one thing I would like to know if, how in the world do some of you have 10k plus miles and have the car for 4-5 months, WOW!! good job guys/gals!!!!

Driving is funnnn
Got mine in March. drove from FW to the Dragon and back and 300+ miles back and forth to work every week. Throw in some weekend play and 8700 miles, just like that.
Received the car in mid-April and now have 5700 trouble free miles. (although there is a minor buzzing rattle from the dash just left of center that comes and goes) All-in-all, no complaints and have enjoyed every minute behind the wheel.
Last edited by MINIclo; Sep 3, 2007 at 11:42 PM.
Both England and Germany have good beer; I think the BMW/Mini engineers over indulge.
Japanese and Korean beer sucks; their cars are more reliable.
Watch out for Mexico; their beer really sucks.
It takes a keen eye like mine to spot these relationships.
Japanese and Korean beer sucks; their cars are more reliable.
Watch out for Mexico; their beer really sucks.
It takes a keen eye like mine to spot these relationships.
Lots of problems with mine:
- Abnormal tire wear (combined with loud screeching noises) on front tires
- Driver apparently stuck in car; wife cannot get him out
- Gas mileage "only" 31 mpg because of lead-footing

Seriously, though, no problems, 3500 miles, six months owned.
--Dan
Mach V
FastMINI.net
- Abnormal tire wear (combined with loud screeching noises) on front tires
- Driver apparently stuck in car; wife cannot get him out
- Gas mileage "only" 31 mpg because of lead-footing

Seriously, though, no problems, 3500 miles, six months owned.
--Dan
Mach V
FastMINI.net




Well said.