R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006) Cooper (R50) and Cooper S (R53) hatchback discussion.

R50/53 British or German ?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 05:26 AM
  #126  
vladimir's Avatar
vladimir
3rd Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 175
Likes: 0
From: Fairfield County, CT
I should have added to my earlier post, the parts may come from a zillion countries, but over 50% are British. Adding assembled in UK, I just consider it British. As for the next generation... ?
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 05:29 AM
  #127  
SpiderX's Avatar
SpiderX
6th Gear
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 5,149
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by british kompressor
I will agree with you that BMW speaks and advertizes MINI as a brand, becasue as a brand it is worth $$$ on the market.

The fact still remains that they took a car model from rover and made it a BMW brand (MINI).

After all this debate, probably the best argument is that the car is made in a BMW factory (does it really matter what soil it's on) and is sold by BMW, and is serviced in BMW dealers.

I understand everyone debating that it's a british car becasue they think it has this huge heritage bla bla bla bla....

That's exacly what BMW wanted consumers to feel, and it was used as a very strategic marketing methode.
Total agreement
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 07:35 AM
  #128  
gokartride's Avatar
gokartride
6th Gear
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 38,578
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by hutto
without BMWs help...just my opinion...it would not be as close to perfect as it is.
I agree!!
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 01:31 PM
  #129  
J0kER's Avatar
J0kER
6th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,546
Likes: 0
From: EastSide .: =0)
are u guys talkin' about early MINI's or all MINI's cuz it was to my understandin' that the mini car is not a BMW, not till 05 when BMW took over the group.

if u look at the guts of the motor it has a slew of crysler products on it and not all BMW components!!
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 01:42 PM
  #130  
DustinDallas's Avatar
DustinDallas
6th Gear
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,798
Likes: 0
From: DFW, TX
Originally Posted by joker
are u guys talkin' about early MINI's or all MINI's cuz it was to my understandin' that the mini car is not a BMW, not till 05 when BMW took over the group.

if u look at the guts of the motor it has a slew of crysler products on it and not all BMW components!!
MINI ('02-'06) is, and has always been owned and run by BMW. The Cooper is a BMW product. The engine is a BMW-Chrysler joint project, but the rest of the car is all BMW.

I'm not sure where you heard they took over in 2005? That's incorrect.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:11 PM
  #131  
J0kER's Avatar
J0kER
6th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,546
Likes: 0
From: EastSide .: =0)
well i got it from a few service advisors after complainin' over noises and such they told me "this is not a BMW so its not going to run solid like a BMW"

so i looked into it and found out that there are a few chrysler components on this small wonder...
and as far as the BMW takin' over the whole project in 05 i read it in motoringfile.com thats why the new body change due to renault power plant.
it doent bother me at all but sure wish the facts about this kool car where clearer????
Originally Posted by KRGMini05
MINI ('02-'06) is, and has always been owned and run by BMW. The Cooper is a BMW product. The engine is a BMW-Chrysler joint project, but the rest of the car is all BMW.

I'm not sure where you heard they took over in 2005? That's incorrect.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:21 PM
  #132  
gokartride's Avatar
gokartride
6th Gear
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 38,578
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by joker
noises and such
See it IS a British car!!!

Originally Posted by joker
the new body change due to renault power plant.
Be sure to continue your research...this ain't so.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:22 PM
  #133  
DustinDallas's Avatar
DustinDallas
6th Gear
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,798
Likes: 0
From: DFW, TX
Originally Posted by joker
well i got it from a few service advisors after complainin' over noises and such they told me "this is not a BMW so its not going to run solid like a BMW"

so i looked into it and found out that there are a few chrysler components on this small wonder...
and as far as the BMW takin' over the whole project in 05 i read it in minicooperfile.com thats why the new body change due to renault power plant.
it doent bother me at all but sure wish the facts about this kool car where clearer????
BMW has always owned MINI. BMW basically designed, and marketed the MINI brand. They didn't buy it once the car was develped.

The engine in the '02-'06 Cooper is a Chrysler engine built in Brazil. Next year, the car gets a BMW-PSA engine, to replace the current Chrysler engine.
Reguardless of engine, the MINI "brand" was created by BMW, they didn't buy it.

This is only relating to the current "new" MINI (all caps). The old Minis were not BMWs.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:34 PM
  #134  
J0kER's Avatar
J0kER
6th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,546
Likes: 0
From: EastSide .: =0)
have to agree w/it beign a british car, those darn noises
Originally Posted by gokartride
See it IS a British car!!!

Be sure to continue your research...this ain't so.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:35 PM
  #135  
J0kER's Avatar
J0kER
6th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,546
Likes: 0
From: EastSide .: =0)
kool..

Originally Posted by KRGMini05
BMW has always owned MINI. BMW basically designed, and marketed the MINI brand. They didn't buy it once the car was develped.

The engine in the '02-'06 Cooper is a Chrysler engine built in Brazil. Next year, the car gets a BMW-PSA engine, to replace the current Chrysler engine.
Reguardless of engine, the MINI "brand" was created by BMW, they didn't buy it.

This is only relating to the current "new" MINI (all caps). The old Minis were not BMWs.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:43 PM
  #136  
camelpilot's Avatar
camelpilot
Banned
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,848
Likes: 1
From: City of Angels, Cali
Originally Posted by british kompressor
Are you saying the UK factory is not a BMW factory??? well the BBC seems to think the exact oposite:


...and here is its successor at BMW's assembly line in Oxford.



URL: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/1342234.stm



once again, I think this settles it. WE ALL DRIVE SMALL BMW's accept it!
lol, the BBC wrote that.. but thats not what a BMW spokesperson quoted.

This from BBC, same article:

"Mr Bickmann also insists that the Mini is not a small BMW."

Mr Bickmann is assembly director of BMW Group in Oxford.

Soooo... if you want a small BMW, get a 1 series.

As for the MINI driving like a BMW, that is horsesh*t. There is not a single BMW out there that drives like the MINI.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:51 PM
  #137  
camelpilot's Avatar
camelpilot
Banned
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,848
Likes: 1
From: City of Angels, Cali
Originally Posted by british kompressor

All of the names here are CAR MANUFACTURERS which got baught out by some larger manufacturer, Exept Mini. Mini is car model, not manufacturer.
You need to call some BMW executives so that they can set you straight, because you definitely aren't listening to anyone here.

The MINI definitely is a brand (you probably will not ever believe this, even if the BMW execs told you so). Cooper is the Model.

You've got it all wrong, and yet refuse to receive help or enlightment from anyone.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 02:57 PM
  #138  
camelpilot's Avatar
camelpilot
Banned
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,848
Likes: 1
From: City of Angels, Cali
Originally Posted by british kompressor

After all this debate, probably the best argument is that the car is made in a BMW factory (does it really matter what soil it's on) and is sold by BMW, and is serviced in BMW dealers.
Lol, first of all, if the factory is a BMW factory, then thats only because BMW own it.

The Oxford plant used to make Classic Minis. When BMW bought the Rover group, they got all the factories and what not. When they divided it up, and kept Mini, they subsequently kept the Mini factories. The oxford one was then converted to make the new car. The one they call the MINI.

I believe the owner of the factory is insignificant. The factory is in England. You have real English people putting the bits together. English Car. English Factory. English name.


TO be really honest about it, I think the MINI is a British built, German engineered car. So it's German as much as it is English.

But to say that it is NOT English is just dumb. To say it is not German might be ok though - wrong, but ok.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 03:24 PM
  #139  
lisdexic driver's Avatar
lisdexic driver
3rd Gear
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
From: Eagle Rock, Calif
I'll have to go with world citizen, with distinct British accent.
Built in UK, with German Designwork and an engine from brazil Built through a combined effort with Chrysler., Yup world citzen.

I had a Jeep Rangler, from a company owned by the gremans and built 100% in Canada.
Welcom to the new world order.
Ever try and find a pair of shoes not made in China?
But I degress....
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 03:30 PM
  #140  
hutto's Avatar
hutto
2nd Gear
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
From: houston
Originally Posted by camelpilot
I believe the owner of the factory is insignificant. The factory is in England. You have real English people putting the bits together. English Car. English Factory. English name.


TO be really honest about it, I think the MINI is a British built, German engineered car. So it's German as much as it is English.

But to say that it is NOT English is just dumb. To say it is not German might be ok though - wrong, but ok.

Completely agree
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 08:13 PM
  #141  
lotsie's Avatar
lotsie
Banned
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 15,382
Likes: 0
Who really cares? I don't . I've owned my MC for over 2 years now.Have put over 57K miles on it. It belongs to me now, no matter where it came from.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 09:20 PM
  #142  
J0kER's Avatar
J0kER
6th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,546
Likes: 0
From: EastSide .: =0)
yipes...

Originally Posted by lot15
Who really cares? I don't . I've owned my MC for over 2 years now.Have put over 57K miles on it. It belongs to me now, no matter where it came from.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 09:38 PM
  #143  
STLMINI's Avatar
STLMINI
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 2,405
Likes: 0
From: St. Louis
Originally Posted by vladimir
I should have added to my earlier post, the parts may come from a zillion countries, but over 50% are British. Adding assembled in UK, I just consider it British. As for the next generation... ?
this reminds me... on my recent trip to the oxford plant, i was told that BMW plans to continue to increase the number of parts of the MINI that are made in England.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 10:36 PM
  #144  
BlueBonnet's Avatar
BlueBonnet
6th Gear
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 1,188
Likes: 0
From: Chico, CA
Nationalism

I have the same problem with my own heritage . . . and as much as I'd like to understand electricity I'm afraid I've got the Lucas gene from my mother. I'm completely in the dark as to what I may mean!

I play a lot of soccer and although I'd like to think I've got the mental dicipline of the German game, in fact, a Scot sperm or two apparently dashed over the wall . . . I'm just not at all apologetic to my opponent . . . (why doesn't he just get up?) Despite my heritage, thank God for a Sicilian wife so I don't have to eat either English or German food.

I've yet to understand the character of my Mini. Two thousand miles only so far. It has British logic to its switches and gauges . . . (naturally you expect to pull the handle twice for the door to open). It certainly drives like a BMW and not the Morris Minor which I first threw in gear (and in fact could get through all four gears before crossing the intersection). Hollywood British . . . no worries about oil dripping onto your sock from the pressure gauge fitting or complete lack of visability in the rain because, of course, an authentic British car shouldn't get wet.

The true test: I find my self drinking English stout after a drive.
 
Reply
Old Oct 10, 2005 | 11:12 PM
  #145  
MGear's Avatar
MGear
5th Gear
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 785
Likes: 0
In concept the Mini maybe British but in execution it is clearly German. And one could argue that even in conept there is a bit of German in there. Don't forget the Germans had the small car idea way before the Brits did with the Isetta and the bug.
 
Reply
Old Oct 11, 2005 | 05:59 AM
  #146  
SpiderX's Avatar
SpiderX
6th Gear
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 5,149
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by MGear
In concept the Mini maybe British but in execution it is clearly German. And one could argue that even in conept there is a bit of German in there. Don't forget the Germans had the small car idea way before the Brits did with the Isetta and the bug.
If you really want some good info on the subject....chapter 2 in the well researched book The New MINI by Paternie is excellent.

I don't type fast enough to do all the quotes but the original Mini was conceived as a "defense" against the "bubble cars from Germany."
Rover had already started on the development of the new MINI when they were sold...... (interesting)... who knows how much of the Rover design was used or incorporated? There are some nice quotes (from ranking officers of the BMW corp) from Dr. Norbert Reithofer, member of the board of production and management "The MINI Cooper is a genuine Mini, not a BMW. It was a way for BMW to tap the entry level luxury market." Stephenson himself is quoted as saying " For the brand's (note the use of the word "brand") new products, our mission was to combine the emotional power of the original model with the technology of the future." (which was the reason he was hired bt Ferrari)

It really is good reading and like I said well researched
 
Reply
Old Oct 11, 2005 | 08:40 AM
  #147  
SpiderX's Avatar
SpiderX
6th Gear
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 5,149
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by SpiderX
If you really want some good info on the subject....chapter 2 in the well researched book The New MINI by Paternie is excellent.

I don't type fast enough to do all the quotes but the original Mini was conceived as a "defense" against the "bubble cars from Germany."
Rover had already started on the development of the new MINI when they were sold...... (interesting)... who knows how much of the Rover design was used or incorporated? There are some nice quotes (from ranking officers of the BMW corp) from Dr. Norbert Reithofer, member of the board of production and management "The MINI Cooper is a genuine Mini, not a BMW. It was a way for BMW to tap the entry level luxury market." Stephenson himself is quoted as saying " For the brand's (note the use of the word "brand") new products, our mission was to combine the emotional power of the original model with the technology of the future." (which was the reason he was hired by Ferrari)

It really is good reading and like I said well researched
new
 
Reply
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
coachvminis
Stock Problems/Issues
19
Jan 30, 2016 08:51 PM
BenjiFace
MINIs & Minis for Sale
2
Dec 20, 2015 06:56 AM
MCarrera9
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
7
Sep 22, 2015 09:42 PM
midnightblackjcw
JCW Garage
0
Sep 21, 2015 10:58 AM
HJCPmeek
1st Gen Countryman (R60) Talk (2010-2015)
5
Sep 15, 2015 01:59 PM




All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:26 PM.