JCW jcw pro/performance exhaust
#1
01-08-2019, 07:39 AM
#5
01-08-2019, 12:36 PM
Are you sure about that price? MSRP is over $2k, I thought. And it's maybe a 2 hour install at a shop, with the wiring and everything.
If it's really $1,400, that seems like a steal. However, if you have a JCW, you're not getting the benefit of the tune that comes with it. So for similar $, you could get the Remus. It also has a remote, and people seem to like it better. It's louder (probably because 2nd cat is eliminated), and there are 4 modes, not just open / closed. The JCW Pro is maybe a little quieter than the OEM JCW when closed. I can barely hear the pops on mine. I'd do Remus next time =)
If it's really $1,400, that seems like a steal. However, if you have a JCW, you're not getting the benefit of the tune that comes with it. So for similar $, you could get the Remus. It also has a remote, and people seem to like it better. It's louder (probably because 2nd cat is eliminated), and there are 4 modes, not just open / closed. The JCW Pro is maybe a little quieter than the OEM JCW when closed. I can barely hear the pops on mine. I'd do Remus next time =)
#8
01-08-2019, 01:59 PM
OVERDRIVE
#9
01-08-2019, 05:48 PM
The stock exhaust is just fine with me. If I want more noise I'll replace the entire system with stainless steel & maximum diameter. I've never been a fan of the JCW Pro Exhaust setup......one tail pipe tip is black with the flap open, and I still say their is a power loss with the flap closed since all the exhaust is forced through a single pipe, although no biggie either way. Then there's the problem (sometimes) with the bluetooth control.
#10
01-08-2019, 05:50 PM
#13
01-08-2019, 08:41 PM
#14
01-09-2019, 12:22 PM
5th Gear
I wanted my JCW to sound a bit louder & lower, so I paid a visit to my local exhaust & muffler shop. The hooked me up with a Magnaflow repo/copy (muffler only) that sounds great and cost me all of $130 out the door. The $1400 - $1800 I saved vs. Remus or the JCW Pro went a long way towards many other goodies for my MINI.
#15
01-09-2019, 12:40 PM
OVERDRIVE
#16
01-09-2019, 12:50 PM
Newt- odd question, but how's the "quality" of the pops after tune? With my Pro exhaust open, the smaller/faster pops sound great. Like a can of rocks. But sometimes it comes out as 1-2 gunshots. Not such a fan of that. Just wondering if the increased pops with tune affects it either way.
#18
01-10-2019, 01:34 PM
OVERDRIVE
Newt- odd question, but how's the "quality" of the pops after tune? With my Pro exhaust open, the smaller/faster pops sound great. Like a can of rocks. But sometimes it comes out as 1-2 gunshots. Not such a fan of that. Just wondering if the increased pops with tune affects it either way.
The following users liked this post:
J_L (01-11-2019)
#19
01-10-2019, 01:55 PM
Since you have a JCW for the cost I would also recommend going with the Remus as it is is much lighter than the JCW and more functions with the flap. Also it's carbon tips are awesome
https://www.waymotorworks.com/remus-...-cooper-s.html
https://www.waymotorworks.com/remus-...-cooper-s.html
#20
01-11-2019, 04:54 PM
As you can see in my sig, I have a ‘16 f56 JCW. I also had the JCW Pro exhaust installed, as well as my new tires, wheels, spacers, and extended bolts. All while taking delivery. I absolutely love the sound of my exhaust. Before I drove off the lot my “Genious” showed me how to do a “Bluetooth delete”, so both my flaps are open all the time. Now with that being said, I kind of wish I went with the Remus. No big deal though. I get a great sound, lots of pops, and it’s all going to get better after I install Mario’s downpipe, and his flash tune.
Mike
Mike
#21
01-11-2019, 07:26 PM
I have the pro exhaust on my JCW and I have a couple thoughts. First, I became so frustrated with the flap closing uncommanded I unplugged the connector and locked it in the open position for full time track mode. So now you essentially have an $1800 exhaust that could could replicate for $150 by cutting off the muffler and welding in a section of straight pipe, because that’s all track mode is - a straight pipe. My next problem is I find the closed flap position way too quiet. The only place this would be helpful is for cold starts, which are now very loud.
My personal opinion is it’s too quiet with the flap closed and too loud with it open. I live in a densely populated suburb and the gunshots that come out the back sometimes probably freak people out. I’m actually thinking about pulling the system off and installing the AWE touring system. No flaps, no b.s., plus as others have mentioned, since I run flap open one pipe is black and the other clean. If I keep the system I will probably paint the inside of the tips black so I’m not having to clean every day.
I will say the JCW pro seems to be the most beloved f56 exhaust out there, maybe neck and neck with the Remus. If I lived in a more remote area the loudness probably wouldn’t be an issue (and it does sound very good). That damn Bluetooth flap just kills me.
My personal opinion is it’s too quiet with the flap closed and too loud with it open. I live in a densely populated suburb and the gunshots that come out the back sometimes probably freak people out. I’m actually thinking about pulling the system off and installing the AWE touring system. No flaps, no b.s., plus as others have mentioned, since I run flap open one pipe is black and the other clean. If I keep the system I will probably paint the inside of the tips black so I’m not having to clean every day.
I will say the JCW pro seems to be the most beloved f56 exhaust out there, maybe neck and neck with the Remus. If I lived in a more remote area the loudness probably wouldn’t be an issue (and it does sound very good). That damn Bluetooth flap just kills me.
#22
01-12-2019, 06:28 PM
3rd Gear
#23
01-12-2019, 06:50 PM
5th Gear
JCW Pro Exhaust
I have the Pro exhaust on my I/O JCW ( bought it off the lot inventory). I like it when I am in manual sport mode driving the winding foothills in California's Gold Country. I love the sound, but when cruising at low rpms (1800-), it's a little drony. If I were ordering a JCW, I don't think I would spend the money for the Pro exhaust. If I were ordering an"S", I would definitely order the JCW Pro exhaust because it includes the tune that adds more performance. Also, it's lot cheaper to order the pro exhaust than to have the dealer install it( $1000 plus cheaper).
Last edited by dpcompt; 01-12-2019 at 06:53 PM. Reason: change
#24
01-12-2019, 07:08 PM
5th Gear
I had an authorized BMW shop install the JCW PRO exhaust for me and after 35,000 + miles it has been stellar with no issues. The install price was considerably less than the mini dealership. It produces 8 more horsepower with it open than closed. I was not aware of the Remus exhaust when I had it done or I might have gone with them, but I have no regrets with the mini exhaust.
The following users liked this post:
vetsvette (01-12-2019)
#25
01-12-2019, 07:54 PM
I have the exhaust along with a Bytetronik tune and I get the occasional "gunshot" too, especially with the catless DP. I had a NC State Trooper pull up next to me at a light and ask if my little car was making all that noise. As I reached down to close the flap I told him, "Yes Sir, it does that sometimes for some reason". Then I quietly motored away with the muffler engaged. I also had the "cold start" mode removed so it is quieter when first started with a cold motor.