What the heck is Mini thinking?
#1
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What the heck is Mini thinking?
The Countryman was one thing. But I just got an email from Atlantic British telling me about the Mini Minor?!
---------------------------------------
After the larger-scale Countryman and possibly Beachcomber, could MINI be going “city-scale” with a 3-cylinder alternative to the Smart Car?
The new MINI Minor, as rumor has it, would actually have a footprint not unlike the original MINI Cooper, and would use traditional technology (not say, like carbon fiber bodywork).
Talk about line extension! This thing would have one of BMW’s new 3-cylinder engines, which the company is hoping to produce en masse to promote economies of scale, and a city-friendly attitude to attract car buyers away from the Smart Fortwo and Toyota iQ avenue runners.
The MINI Minor, eh? Stay tuned…
------------------------------
In my opinion, Mini should sell Minis. Not ugly cars with a MINI logo. Degradation of brand appeal at it's best.
---------------------------------------
After the larger-scale Countryman and possibly Beachcomber, could MINI be going “city-scale” with a 3-cylinder alternative to the Smart Car?
The new MINI Minor, as rumor has it, would actually have a footprint not unlike the original MINI Cooper, and would use traditional technology (not say, like carbon fiber bodywork).
Talk about line extension! This thing would have one of BMW’s new 3-cylinder engines, which the company is hoping to produce en masse to promote economies of scale, and a city-friendly attitude to attract car buyers away from the Smart Fortwo and Toyota iQ avenue runners.
The MINI Minor, eh? Stay tuned…
------------------------------
In my opinion, Mini should sell Minis. Not ugly cars with a MINI logo. Degradation of brand appeal at it's best.
#2
#3
Oh... emm.... eff.... gee... that is completely horrifying. It looks even worse than that Chinese Lifan ripoff of the MINI.
My eyes are burning. Make it stop!
Maybe this is a MINI ploy to make ppl LIKE the Countryman more? Show them something that will make them barf then ask them again if they like the Countryman?
My eyes are burning. Make it stop!
Maybe this is a MINI ploy to make ppl LIKE the Countryman more? Show them something that will make them barf then ask them again if they like the Countryman?
#4
Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Never said I liked those either. To be honest, I can't even stand the Clubman. Sorry Clubbie owners. Mini Should be Mini, not SUV, Stationwagon, or even Geo Metro-Esque. The "looks to be" high center of gravity will be interesting when a Countryman drives past it and flips it over.
#5
I agree that they may need--or, at least, could use--such vehicles, I disagree that they should make them so ugly-looking. Ppl still want to take pride in their investments--even at this lowest price-point. Even in today's "sophisticated" market, ppl still don't want to be seen in an ugly car, much less pay their hard-earned (hard-borrowed) money for one. [Recall the failure that was the Edsel, or more recently, the Pontiac Aztec.]
PS: These don't even look like MINIs!
PS: These don't even look like MINIs!
#7
Minis should look like Minis, eh?
In the original classic Mini line so beloved by all you had Travelers, (Clubman) Moke, (Beachcomber) Pickup trucks for god's sake, (not yet) and many more, including the square nosed coupes called Clubmans!
How are they straying from their roots by building the current offerings?
I like what they are doing, although someone on another board suggested they name the new city cars "Isetta's", and since they have a similar look to the 50's and 60's cars of that name (also built by BMW) I agree with that. That would be a simple way to distinguish the MINI line from the city car line and give MINI dealers a wider range of competetive products to sell under the same roof without diluting the MINI brand.
In the original classic Mini line so beloved by all you had Travelers, (Clubman) Moke, (Beachcomber) Pickup trucks for god's sake, (not yet) and many more, including the square nosed coupes called Clubmans!
How are they straying from their roots by building the current offerings?
I like what they are doing, although someone on another board suggested they name the new city cars "Isetta's", and since they have a similar look to the 50's and 60's cars of that name (also built by BMW) I agree with that. That would be a simple way to distinguish the MINI line from the city car line and give MINI dealers a wider range of competetive products to sell under the same roof without diluting the MINI brand.
Trending Topics
#8
None of you follow MotoringFile? It's probably where Atlantic British picked up the story.
http://www.motoringfile.com/
Personally, I'm all for MINI coming out with this car.
http://www.motoringfile.com/
Personally, I'm all for MINI coming out with this car.
#12
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Your Worst Nightmare :)
Posts: 3,880
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
The 3 cylinder motor will be part of the 3rd gen car. word is this much lighter motor will produce more HP and torque, and be more fuel efficient, than the current Prince engine
And for those of you that think MINI should stay in its original, 3-door hatchback coupe form, well you better brush up on your Mini history. I believe that from 1959 to 2000 there were more than 300 variants on the original car.
And for those of you that think MINI should stay in its original, 3-door hatchback coupe form, well you better brush up on your Mini history. I believe that from 1959 to 2000 there were more than 300 variants on the original car.
#14
You know, those pictures are rather old (like someone said, from the 90s..) so they're probably really outdated looks-wise. I would be curious to see what they'd be doing with this idea. The four-door looks kinda silly, but with some body and appearance changes to the 2 door, it might be pretty cool looking.
#15
#17
#21
Minis should look like Minis, eh?
In the original classic Mini line so beloved by all you had Travelers, (Clubman) Moke, (Beachcomber) Pickup trucks for god's sake, (not yet) and many more, including the square nosed coupes called Clubmans!
How are they straying from their roots by building the current offerings?
I like what they are doing, although someone on another board suggested they name the new city cars "Isetta's", and since they have a similar look to the 50's and 60's cars of that name (also built by BMW) I agree with that. That would be a simple way to distinguish the MINI line from the city car line and give MINI dealers a wider range of competetive products to sell under the same roof without diluting the MINI brand.
In the original classic Mini line so beloved by all you had Travelers, (Clubman) Moke, (Beachcomber) Pickup trucks for god's sake, (not yet) and many more, including the square nosed coupes called Clubmans!
How are they straying from their roots by building the current offerings?
I like what they are doing, although someone on another board suggested they name the new city cars "Isetta's", and since they have a similar look to the 50's and 60's cars of that name (also built by BMW) I agree with that. That would be a simple way to distinguish the MINI line from the city car line and give MINI dealers a wider range of competetive products to sell under the same roof without diluting the MINI brand.
#23
Never said I liked those either. To be honest, I can't even stand the Clubman. Sorry Clubbie owners. Mini Should be Mini, not SUV, Stationwagon, or even Geo Metro-Esque. The "looks to be" high center of gravity will be interesting when a Countryman drives past it and flips it over.
BMW is doing exactly what any healthy, smart-thinking company should be doing -- looking to expand its presence in the market. Can't do that by continuing to play to one tiny segment. It's far better to be the first to market with new ideas that will appeal to a broader audience while keeping true to the spirit of the brand -- and that even includes this latest duck egg on wheels -- before somebody else beats them to it.
And by the way, we just picked up a new Clubbie S for the wife, and it's a damn neat little ride in its own right. You don't have to like it, but she's pretty happy they decided to build it.
#24
http://www.aronline.co.uk/index.htm?r50storyf.htm
Alright everyone scroll about halfway down this page. And don't get your panties in a bunch.
Alright everyone scroll about halfway down this page. And don't get your panties in a bunch.
Let's see, ...it was concieved and partly developed by Rover in England, styled by an American BMW employee, packaged by a British engineer, originally developed to use a small-displacement Japanese (Kei) engine...then a BMW motorcycle engine, finally ending up with a German-developed engine of American origin (Chrysler) which itself was built in Brazil, originally using a British Midlands transmission and Rover-derived steering. At times the development was done entirely by BMW in Germany, then abandoned by them and taken over in England, only to be re-taken over in the end by BMW for final development! The car was first shown in Paris France, sitting on an Italian Fiat Punto chassis. The car is built in Oxford England, and now the second gen version's "Prince" engine is of French Peugot origin.
Did I leave anyone out?
#25