My JCW HT just got pushed back to week 37. I now have been looking at the JCW Clubman and I am sort of smitten by it.

I would like to know what you see as the pros and cons for each.

I understand it is a bit slower but may have a better ride.

 

i too had a tough time deciding. went back and forth for months, finally brought my kids to the dealer and made up my mind ................ clubman. just for the ease of getting the kids in and out of, and the cool suicide door. then i needed to decide betw/ clubman s and jcw. the evil child in me decided.....JCW.
good luck.

 

I decided it's cheaper to give the kids coffee and stunt their growth than to get the Clubman

Joking Joking...

I got the HardTop because I want to SCCA, and it will turn in better due to it's smaller wheelbase. If you want practicality get a Clubman. If you want as much cornering as possible, get the hardtop.