Drivetrain invidia or magnaflow?
^^ agreed most part, the Magnaflow is really good quality, i had a custom system with the Magnaflow parts prior to my Invidia. Unfortunately at the time, and if i am not mistaking up until now, the Magnaflow catback was not available for 05-06 cars, needed modifications, so did the Invidia. I saw the Invidia at a show, and believe it or not looked prettier and beteer engineered over Magnaflow. On the otherside Magnaflow is louder than Invidia. Performance gains, you made a correct statement, so nothing to add on my end. Finally, guess what system i have on my truck?
Originally Posted by jerjer
well, i'm starting to lean towards the magnaflow. invidia does LOOK awsome, but who will really check out the finish on someone's exhaust. right?
Originally Posted by mdsbrain
Well I guess it comes to how it will last hanging under your car. Also one small thing I consider when buying things is how well respected the part is in the market for resale.
thx guys for the great infos and stuff, i really appreciate it !
i have a magnaflow with a madness header. Still not loud enough for me. Maybe i should take off a muffler or something. The magnaflow is only loud when ya want it to be. When your traveling, just put the car in 6th, you'll be fine.
Originally Posted by saifa
...2 or 3hp difference really while it does add up...is not much. People can fart harder than that!

As a further endorsment for Magnaflow I've got to hand it to them on the service/warranty end of things.
When Magnalfow first sold the Cooper S system it came with a flat-ended canister-like resonator. These units had a tendancy to fail (internal welds came loose) & rattled. When it came time to warranty mine they offered to replace it with an identical unit, but were honest enough to admit that it would likely fail too. They then informed me that they'd have a different part to replace it with, if I were willing to wait. I was in shock! A company willing to admit a problem and offer a REAL solution, instead of another headache (down the road).
A month or so later Magnaflow sent me a new & quite different looking resonator. It incorporated tapered transitions into and out of the resonator - an improvement over the original in a number of ways. Magnaflow paid shipping to and from my place - Cali to Ohio & back (picked up old resonator).
Compared to other warranty claims I've had to place this was painless!
Problems do crop up, even in good companies... how they are remedied makes a huge difference in satisfaction. Magnaflow 'get it' and are about long-term customer satisfaction.
I would consider another Magnaflow system before any other (save Webb) and would reccomend Magnaflow highly to anyone.
now my mind is 95% set, anyone know where i can obtain the magnaflow system for the lowest price possible? on interenet or wherever~
one more thing, will the magnaflow clear the aero kit exhaust opening?
one more thing, will the magnaflow clear the aero kit exhaust opening?
If your in Canada talk to Jay at coopersport.ca. His price on the Magnaflow is actual pretty competitive and the fact that he's a Canuck you won't have to worry about brokerage, duties and all that lovely stuff.
Seann
Seann
Originally Posted by minimc
Where'd you come up with that saifa? (measuring farts in HP?) Is this measure an expression of the energy (combustible gas) portion or some calculation measuring "boost" in PSI, then 'converted' to HP?
As a further endorsment for Magnaflow I've got to hand it to them on the service/warranty end of things.
When Magnalfow first sold the Cooper S system it came with a flat-ended canister-like resonator. These units had a tendancy to fail (internal welds came loose) & rattled. When it came time to warranty mine they offered to replace it with an identical unit, but were honest enough to admit that it would likely fail too. They then informed me that they'd have a different part to replace it with, if I were willing to wait. I was in shock! A company willing to admit a problem and offer a REAL solution, instead of another headache (down the road).
A month or so later Magnaflow sent me a new & quite different looking resonator. It incorporated tapered transitions into and out of the resonator - an improvement over the original in a number of ways. Magnaflow paid shipping to and from my place - Cali to Ohio & back (picked up old resonator).
Compared to other warranty claims I've had to place this was painless!
Problems do crop up, even in good companies... how they are remedied makes a huge difference in satisfaction. Magnaflow 'get it' and are about long-term customer satisfaction.
I would consider another Magnaflow system before any other (save Webb) and would reccomend Magnaflow highly to anyone.

As a further endorsment for Magnaflow I've got to hand it to them on the service/warranty end of things.
When Magnalfow first sold the Cooper S system it came with a flat-ended canister-like resonator. These units had a tendancy to fail (internal welds came loose) & rattled. When it came time to warranty mine they offered to replace it with an identical unit, but were honest enough to admit that it would likely fail too. They then informed me that they'd have a different part to replace it with, if I were willing to wait. I was in shock! A company willing to admit a problem and offer a REAL solution, instead of another headache (down the road).
A month or so later Magnaflow sent me a new & quite different looking resonator. It incorporated tapered transitions into and out of the resonator - an improvement over the original in a number of ways. Magnaflow paid shipping to and from my place - Cali to Ohio & back (picked up old resonator).
Compared to other warranty claims I've had to place this was painless!
Problems do crop up, even in good companies... how they are remedied makes a huge difference in satisfaction. Magnaflow 'get it' and are about long-term customer satisfaction.
I would consider another Magnaflow system before any other (save Webb) and would reccomend Magnaflow highly to anyone.
Same issue. Handled slightly different but I got the same result. Warrantied and replaced with better parts.
Having had stock, Borla Race, JCW , and now an Invidia I feel safe in saying that I like the tone of the Borla the best! I also feel as though the Borla made the most power in MY car. The Invidia has a sweet tone and great build quality but the Borla is calling me back. My Invidia will be for sale as soon as I find a Borla Race in good shape. As far as Magnaflow goes..... I wouldn't compare the sound to either the Borla or Invida. Magnaflow is just that much louder to me. Hope that helps.
i have the invidia. it really is well put together and the welds are nice. tried hanging it on the wall in the living room but the wife didn't go for it.
in any event, for what it's worth, when i took it to a shop to have it installed they quoted me one rate, and then halfed it when i picked the car up. they said it was the easiest aftermarket exhaust install they had done.
my car is an 04, and definitely burbles a lot more. i think it's a good choice. magnaflow is too loud for me, and i don't dig the trumpet tips...
in any event, for what it's worth, when i took it to a shop to have it installed they quoted me one rate, and then halfed it when i picked the car up. they said it was the easiest aftermarket exhaust install they had done.
my car is an 04, and definitely burbles a lot more. i think it's a good choice. magnaflow is too loud for me, and i don't dig the trumpet tips...
Originally Posted by mdsbrain
-Cody
I PM you, you PM back and said you wanted sorry, liked a louder system! Here you go I got the Perfect system for you! Check this out! http://media.putfile.com/jcw-gutted It's for sale on this site by a really cool guy MSFIT. You said "Maybe some idea of deals out there too." I bet he'd make you a Smoking Deal too!
Many out here have been using the magnaflow but cutting off those " trumpets " and going with a more traditioanl tip. The magnaflow resonator has a habit of going bad but the company has stood behind their product and replaced them as necessary.
John
John
Last edited by Coopersport.com; Mar 24, 2006 at 11:26 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
R53UndaPSI
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
4
Sep 21, 2015 09:42 AM
patsum
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
8
Sep 14, 2015 07:15 PM




