View Poll Results: Please have your name on the list of day that you are planning to participate
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 16. You may not vote on this poll
DC Auto Show?
The 135i high up was kinda disappointing, I really wanted to check that car out.
Also, no WRX STi at the auto show...why? seems they are selling too fast & local dealers didnt have any in stock to send to the auto show :impatient
Also, no WRX STi at the auto show...why? seems they are selling too fast & local dealers didnt have any in stock to send to the auto show :impatient
The auto show was fun, went yesterday. Sorry I missed everyone. The MINI Clubman seemed pretty cool. I hopped in the Cooper S version and sat in back to see how much space there was. Lots of room for a MINI! We'll have to see how quick it is vs. the regular S. Of course the real reason I went was to see the 128 and 135i BMWs. Imagine my surprise when I found no 128is and only one pedestal mounted 135i! Heck, people were climbing all over a $110,000 M6 cabrio, why was the 135i not open so we could see inside? At least MINI let folks jump in and climb around the MINIs. Overall, I really like the 1 series. I may have to get one when they finally come out... preferably a cabrio.
i was disappointed about that as well. but i believe the reason for that is the 1 series is just coming out and there are a limited number of those here on this soil now. VS, the M6 cab has been out for awhile so they don't have to worry about it getting "messed" up so to speak.
hopefully by one of the next auto shows, they will have it out in the open. NY maybe.
hopefully by one of the next auto shows, they will have it out in the open. NY maybe.
i did see the clubman, but i walked behind the S. i came from the back of the BMW area and the clubman in back was the first thing i saw. i got in the back and said, hey, i can actually sit back here, thats new.
anyway, i was also surprised at the lack of the STI and that the WRX was out of reach. Mitsubishi had the evo just sitting out there (albeit locked) so where was the STI? i also thought it was strange that the evo was just out on the floor, while the lancer gts was the focal point of the whole display. it wasnt even the ralliart which is supposed to come out soon, just the GTS.
anyway, i was also surprised at the lack of the STI and that the WRX was out of reach. Mitsubishi had the evo just sitting out there (albeit locked) so where was the STI? i also thought it was strange that the evo was just out on the floor, while the lancer gts was the focal point of the whole display. it wasnt even the ralliart which is supposed to come out soon, just the GTS.
I was impressed with the Clubman. After all the ups and downs and varying opinions I've been reading here on NAM, my final personal opinion is that I am satisfied. I think MINI accomplished what they intended with the Clubman which was to provide two full rear seats and some additional cargo capacity. Some additional points I walked away with:
1. It's still a MINI! By this I mean, only necessary changes towards the accomplishment of the above mentioned goal were made.
2. The rear seats are roomy and comfortable.
3. Those LONG rear windows are kinda cool and provide great visibility.
4. The rear doors work well.
5. The storage space in the boot seems like it just keeps going.
As for motoring, well, that's still a wait & see. I suspect they'll sell fairly well though and I'll have no problem welcoming them at future events
Final thought, I really wish it said "Clubman or "Clubman S" on the back instead of Cooper....
Edit: technically, it should say "CLUBMAN" or CLUBMAN S" since the emblem is all upper-case.
1. It's still a MINI! By this I mean, only necessary changes towards the accomplishment of the above mentioned goal were made.
2. The rear seats are roomy and comfortable.
3. Those LONG rear windows are kinda cool and provide great visibility.
4. The rear doors work well.
5. The storage space in the boot seems like it just keeps going.
As for motoring, well, that's still a wait & see. I suspect they'll sell fairly well though and I'll have no problem welcoming them at future events

Final thought, I really wish it said "Clubman or "Clubman S" on the back instead of Cooper....

Edit: technically, it should say "CLUBMAN" or CLUBMAN S" since the emblem is all upper-case.
Last edited by Scavenger; Jan 28, 2008 at 12:37 PM. Reason: note on case
I was there from about 11-1:30 on Saturday. The clubman was cool, but there were too many people. I thought Rose from MoT was there at the mini desk, but that was seeing her head from behind. It was some lady from MoS, I think. I didn't recognize anyone, but I'm terrible with names/faces. Except for the Opel* and Mini displays, I was pretty disappointed in the show. I get really tired of GM's "look at all of our environmentally friendly cars which you cannot buy for at least three years" show.
*It's about time the Astra comes to the US...I seriously might have bought a 3 door Astra instead of a mini if it had been available in '06.
*It's about time the Astra comes to the US...I seriously might have bought a 3 door Astra instead of a mini if it had been available in '06.
i did see the clubman, but i walked behind the S. i came from the back of the BMW area and the clubman in back was the first thing i saw. i got in the back and said, hey, i can actually sit back here, thats new.
anyway, i was also surprised at the lack of the STI and that the WRX was out of reach. Mitsubishi had the evo just sitting out there (albeit locked) so where was the STI? i also thought it was strange that the evo was just out on the floor, while the lancer gts was the focal point of the whole display. it wasnt even the ralliart which is supposed to come out soon, just the GTS.
anyway, i was also surprised at the lack of the STI and that the WRX was out of reach. Mitsubishi had the evo just sitting out there (albeit locked) so where was the STI? i also thought it was strange that the evo was just out on the floor, while the lancer gts was the focal point of the whole display. it wasnt even the ralliart which is supposed to come out soon, just the GTS.

i think i agree with you. however, the STI is not its former self either. they are both trying to be something they arent, and i cant forsee them being successful at it. but then again, i dont make cars for a living, so well see.
The Subaru WRX STi is very underwhelming in it's neutered state - however I heard Subaru is giving you a set of STi gonads on a key chain with every new STi. :-)

I agree with everything else you said - especially the badging. They should have dropped Cooper from the name completely. "MINI" is the brand name, "Cooper" is the model... and the Clubman is a different model than the Cooper or Cooper S! Well, that's my opinion.
I guess if you look at it a different way, the Clubman is the "stationwagon" version of the same car, so maybe Cooper should stay in the name, in that case... but I still don't like it that way.
for anyone interested here are my pics from the show.
http://s40.photobucket.com/albums/e2...20Show%202008/
http://s40.photobucket.com/albums/e2...20Show%202008/
MINI One
MINI D
MINI Cooper
MINI Cooper S
In the cabrio they call them
MINI One Cabrio
MINI Cooper Cabrio
MINI Cooper S Cabrio
In the Clubman you've got...
MINI D Clubman
MINI Cooper Clubman
MINI Cooper S Clubman
So at least they're consistent. But most of us are used to Chevy Impala SS. Brand, Model, then Trim. They're listing brand, trim, then model sort of. Except that if it's not a cabrio or clubman you're left with just MINI for both brand and model.
I guess I'm just backwards and indeed D, One, Cooper and Cooper S are models. It just doesn't taste that way to me. I'm used to it so that when there's one car,one unibody with four different engine and suspension levels that is what is usually called four levels of one model. Chevy does't make a model called the SS and offer it in Malibu, Cobalt, HHR, and Tahoe. Just the other way around. OK, now I made my head hurt.
So I guess as they release new 'models' they'll just add the modifier to the end.
MINI Cooper SUV
MINI Cooper Pickup
Truimph Cooper S Cabrio?
Last edited by mmatarella; Jan 29, 2008 at 07:37 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
patsum
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
26
May 29, 2021 06:29 PM





















