Engine problems --> Not use top tier gas
#1
Engine problems --> Not use top tier gas
Hello all,
I have 30k miles on my '08 clubman and yesterday my engine light came on. Today it is still in the shop - engine being taken apart and cleaned. I'm told that it was misfiring and completely "gunked" up due to bad gas and that I should be using top tier gas. Unfortunately I wasn't told that when I drove it off the lot in '08.
Unfortunately, all of the gas stations in a 10 mile radius of my home are not *top tier*. I usually fill up at a Mobil (occasionally Hess or Irving) and when I pass a Shell (top tier) I stop.
Has anyone else run into this problem? I always put in the premium gas but I'm told it's not the octane that makes the difference.
Now - I will go out of my way for top tier gas if it keeps my mini happy!
I have 30k miles on my '08 clubman and yesterday my engine light came on. Today it is still in the shop - engine being taken apart and cleaned. I'm told that it was misfiring and completely "gunked" up due to bad gas and that I should be using top tier gas. Unfortunately I wasn't told that when I drove it off the lot in '08.
Unfortunately, all of the gas stations in a 10 mile radius of my home are not *top tier*. I usually fill up at a Mobil (occasionally Hess or Irving) and when I pass a Shell (top tier) I stop.
Has anyone else run into this problem? I always put in the premium gas but I'm told it's not the octane that makes the difference.
Now - I will go out of my way for top tier gas if it keeps my mini happy!
#2
Bad gas is the easy scapegoat. Sometimes it's the cause, sometimes it is not. The dealer finds it easy to blame the fuel because it is difficult to prove the negative. But the fact remains that too many instances of engine-gunking have been reported for it to be solely a fuel problem.
That said, top tier fuel really is the way to go. Additionally, I try to fuel up only in areas where the higher octane is likely to have a higher turnover rate. To my way of thinking, this minimizes the chance that the fuel has been sitting in the tank for an inordinate amount of time. Gas up in the mddle of nowhere and maybe that 91octane has been in there since the Clinton Administration. Y'know?
That said, top tier fuel really is the way to go. Additionally, I try to fuel up only in areas where the higher octane is likely to have a higher turnover rate. To my way of thinking, this minimizes the chance that the fuel has been sitting in the tank for an inordinate amount of time. Gas up in the mddle of nowhere and maybe that 91octane has been in there since the Clinton Administration. Y'know?
#3
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Daytona Beach, Florida
Posts: 1,390
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I always just run a can of "Rechron"
The C-4 Corvettes always had a serious problem with crap gas. It would cause fuel pump problems as well as cause the fuel gage to stick. The people on my Corvette forum always said to run a can of "Techron" every 1,000 to 1,500 miles and you will never have a problem.
I now have a 2009 JCW and I still use the Techron in it. The "Techron" does not have alcohol in it at all so you don't have to worry about upping the percentage of alcohol in the gasoline. I am now pushing 11,000 miles with narry a problem.
I get 90% of my gas at Sam's Club unless I'm out of town. Then I try to get Chevron,Texaco or Shell.
Ronnie948
I now have a 2009 JCW and I still use the Techron in it. The "Techron" does not have alcohol in it at all so you don't have to worry about upping the percentage of alcohol in the gasoline. I am now pushing 11,000 miles with narry a problem.
I get 90% of my gas at Sam's Club unless I'm out of town. Then I try to get Chevron,Texaco or Shell.
Ronnie948
#4
2 years of owning the car and almost 20,000 miles later, I've always filled at a Shell station. Well, there was this one time when I stopped at a Chevron as I was running low. The MINI dealership didn't tell me anything about top-tier gas either except the MA was really specific about Premium (91 or 92) gas.
#5
Did your dealer happen to elaborate as to what "their managment" considers to be: top tier fuel.
Because at the fuel depot here off the coast various tanker trucks pull up for loading from same tank source and then distribute that same fuel to 90 percent of every name brand station as well as every mom and pop gas station in this area......
And last I checked, the OM says high octane fuel yes ? and does not stipulate as to what brand of fuel we are to patronize.
Are they really taking apart the engine to "clean it" ? Are they removing the upper cylinder head ? Is the warranty covering this ?
Because at the fuel depot here off the coast various tanker trucks pull up for loading from same tank source and then distribute that same fuel to 90 percent of every name brand station as well as every mom and pop gas station in this area......
And last I checked, the OM says high octane fuel yes ? and does not stipulate as to what brand of fuel we are to patronize.
Are they really taking apart the engine to "clean it" ? Are they removing the upper cylinder head ? Is the warranty covering this ?
#7
Top Tier really has two specifications in it...
one is that there be at least 8% but not more than 10% ethanol (thank you corn lobby), and that there be higher levels of detergents than the federally mandated minimum. It's the detergent levels that help.
That said, when one of the bonehead dealers say "you used bad gas" tell them to prove it and that you only get gold-plated ultra-hyped uber-marketed super-gas!
That said, you can add your own detergents like others have mentioned, or do a periodic cleaning like many others do.
Matt
That said, when one of the bonehead dealers say "you used bad gas" tell them to prove it and that you only get gold-plated ultra-hyped uber-marketed super-gas!
That said, you can add your own detergents like others have mentioned, or do a periodic cleaning like many others do.
Matt
Trending Topics
#8
#11
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Daytona Beach, Florida
Posts: 1,390
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I do not think gas is the problem at all (EVER)
If there is so much bad gas out there why is it only the Mini Coopers have a problem. I can see alcohol may cause fuel pump problems on older cars. Mini Coopers made after 2004 should never have that problem because all of the car company's were informed about the USA going ethonal 10%. Maybe this Toyota thing will light a fire under all of these car company's to start taking care of customer problems instead of blaming everything but themselves on their problems.
I have had no problems at all with my car but if I did end up with a fuel pump problem and the dealer said it was due to bad gas I would probably go to jail for choking the idiot and destroying their whole showroom.
Ronnie948
I have had no problems at all with my car but if I did end up with a fuel pump problem and the dealer said it was due to bad gas I would probably go to jail for choking the idiot and destroying their whole showroom.
Ronnie948
#12
More dealer B.S. Have them explain, in writing, exactly how the so-called "bad gas" caused the conditions they discovered in your engine.
"Top Tier" is a gasoline marketing association, and the participating brands pay a fee to be labelled "Top Tier". Is a Top Tier brand better than a non-Top Tier brand? Only a chemical engineer would know for sure.
"Top Tier" is a gasoline marketing association, and the participating brands pay a fee to be labelled "Top Tier". Is a Top Tier brand better than a non-Top Tier brand? Only a chemical engineer would know for sure.
#14
Find out exactly what area of the engine has a build-up of "gunk".
If it is a build-up in the cylinder chamber, it could be due to less than top quality gas.
If it is on the back of the intake valves, then the "bad gas" claim is pure BS. This is a direct injection engine and no gas passes over the back of the intake valves. So, they cannot be cleaned by the detergent in the gas.
More traditional engine designs have the air/fuel mixture flowing through the valves. This exposes the back of the valves with the cleaning agents in the gas. With a MINI, only the air, and fumes from the PCV system flow through the valves. Gas is injected directly into the cylinder chamber.
The design of the MINI engine (and many other recent direct injection engines) do not have any means for cleaning the PCV fume deposits off the back of the valves.
This is an engine design problem, not a bad gas problem.
If it is a build-up in the cylinder chamber, it could be due to less than top quality gas.
If it is on the back of the intake valves, then the "bad gas" claim is pure BS. This is a direct injection engine and no gas passes over the back of the intake valves. So, they cannot be cleaned by the detergent in the gas.
More traditional engine designs have the air/fuel mixture flowing through the valves. This exposes the back of the valves with the cleaning agents in the gas. With a MINI, only the air, and fumes from the PCV system flow through the valves. Gas is injected directly into the cylinder chamber.
The design of the MINI engine (and many other recent direct injection engines) do not have any means for cleaning the PCV fume deposits off the back of the valves.
This is an engine design problem, not a bad gas problem.
Last edited by Robin Casady; 02-25-2010 at 11:56 AM.
#15
Find out exactly what area of the engine has a build-up of "gunk".
If it is a build-up in the cylinder chamber, it could be due to less than top quality gas.
If it is on the back of the valves, then the "bad gas" claim is pure BS. This is a direct injection engine and no gas passes over the back of the valves. So, they cannot be cleaned by the detergent in the gas.
More traditional engine designs have the air/fuel mixture flowing through the valves. This exposes the back of the valves with the cleaning agents in the gas. With a MINI, only the air, and fumes from the PCV system flow through the valves. Gas is injected directly into the cylinder chamber.
The design of the MINI engine (and many other recent direct injection engines) do not have any means for cleaning the PCV fume deposits off the back of the valves.
This is an engine design problem, not a bad gas problem.
If it is a build-up in the cylinder chamber, it could be due to less than top quality gas.
If it is on the back of the valves, then the "bad gas" claim is pure BS. This is a direct injection engine and no gas passes over the back of the valves. So, they cannot be cleaned by the detergent in the gas.
More traditional engine designs have the air/fuel mixture flowing through the valves. This exposes the back of the valves with the cleaning agents in the gas. With a MINI, only the air, and fumes from the PCV system flow through the valves. Gas is injected directly into the cylinder chamber.
The design of the MINI engine (and many other recent direct injection engines) do not have any means for cleaning the PCV fume deposits off the back of the valves.
This is an engine design problem, not a bad gas problem.
#16
When I took delivery of my MINI, my MA took me to get a complimentary fill up. The station that we went to across the street from the dealership sells low cost, Brand X gas. The gas was put on the dealership's account.
I was advised to put Premium in, which I do.
I sometimes go to Shell, but usually fill up at a local low cost station.
I don't believe this "bad gas" hype for a minute.
There is an awful lot of it reported here and many threads about it.
I agree with miniclubman.
Get them to write a letter stating that "bad gas" is the cause of your engine's problem.
What reason could they have to refuse, since this is what they are telling you?
Make sure to cc it to the station that you frequent the most.
Follow up with the company that you buy your gas from and ask them to respond to the accusation that they sell inferior gas that damages engines.
I suggest a cc to your lawyer as well.
Remain calm and polite throughout this reasonable scenario.
I also hope, along with ronnie948, that the Toyota debacle is causing the entire auto industry to take a good hard look at their product and their responsibility to their customers. I'm afraid that I am too cynical to think that it will matter though.
Good luck!
I was advised to put Premium in, which I do.
I sometimes go to Shell, but usually fill up at a local low cost station.
I don't believe this "bad gas" hype for a minute.
There is an awful lot of it reported here and many threads about it.
I agree with miniclubman.
Get them to write a letter stating that "bad gas" is the cause of your engine's problem.
What reason could they have to refuse, since this is what they are telling you?
Make sure to cc it to the station that you frequent the most.
Follow up with the company that you buy your gas from and ask them to respond to the accusation that they sell inferior gas that damages engines.
I suggest a cc to your lawyer as well.
Remain calm and polite throughout this reasonable scenario.
I also hope, along with ronnie948, that the Toyota debacle is causing the entire auto industry to take a good hard look at their product and their responsibility to their customers. I'm afraid that I am too cynical to think that it will matter though.
Good luck!
#17
6th Gear
iTrader: (26)
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Santa Cruz County Jail
Posts: 3,716
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I only put 91 Chevron/Texaco or on rare occasional Shell always.
I will stick in some 97 Sunoco or 100 VP Racing Fuel for track days.
And a small bottle of Techron 1 or 2 times a month.
I have only put CHEAP gas 3 times, all 3 times were an almost outta gas emergency and I only put $5 bucks in until I could make it to the next Chevron/Texaco. I also use Sunoco 93 which is not Top Tier but good gas nevertheless.
1. Outside Chicago traveling across US
2. At the Dragon
3. In Utah traveling across US
I will stick in some 97 Sunoco or 100 VP Racing Fuel for track days.
And a small bottle of Techron 1 or 2 times a month.
I have only put CHEAP gas 3 times, all 3 times were an almost outta gas emergency and I only put $5 bucks in until I could make it to the next Chevron/Texaco. I also use Sunoco 93 which is not Top Tier but good gas nevertheless.
1. Outside Chicago traveling across US
2. At the Dragon
3. In Utah traveling across US
Last edited by howsoonisnow1985; 02-25-2010 at 11:39 AM. Reason: Bad Gas to Cheap Gas
#19
I am glad that the gas station paid in your case.
That is why I think that whenever bad gas is diagnosed as the cause of a problem, the gas station should be involved as well.
Really, there should be no such thing as bad gas from any licensed station that has passed regulation requirements.
In your case, did the station correct the problem that caused them to be selling bad gas?
I don't know what constitutes Top-Tier either.
I do know that my dealer uses low cost gas in the cars that they sell.
No one told me that the brand of gas mattered, only that I should use premium.
#20
Find out exactly what area of the engine has a build-up of "gunk".
If it is a build-up in the cylinder chamber, it could be due to less than top quality gas.
If it is on the back of the valves, then the "bad gas" claim is pure BS. This is a direct injection engine and no gas passes over the back of the valves. So, they cannot be cleaned by the detergent in the gas.
More traditional engine designs have the air/fuel mixture flowing through the valves. This exposes the back of the valves with the cleaning agents in the gas. With a MINI, only the air, and fumes from the PCV system flow through the valves. Gas is injected directly into the cylinder chamber.
The design of the MINI engine (and many other recent direct injection engines) do not have any means for cleaning the PCV fume deposits off the back of the valves.
This is an engine design problem, not a bad gas problem.
If it is a build-up in the cylinder chamber, it could be due to less than top quality gas.
If it is on the back of the valves, then the "bad gas" claim is pure BS. This is a direct injection engine and no gas passes over the back of the valves. So, they cannot be cleaned by the detergent in the gas.
More traditional engine designs have the air/fuel mixture flowing through the valves. This exposes the back of the valves with the cleaning agents in the gas. With a MINI, only the air, and fumes from the PCV system flow through the valves. Gas is injected directly into the cylinder chamber.
The design of the MINI engine (and many other recent direct injection engines) do not have any means for cleaning the PCV fume deposits off the back of the valves.
This is an engine design problem, not a bad gas problem.
#22
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Your Worst Nightmare :)
Posts: 3,880
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
#23
It makes a case that many here also support.
I am very ignorant of automobile engines and how they work, but am trying to learn.
I really appreciate the patient education that many here are willing to provide.
I only have one problem with the document that you sited.
Who produced it?
Perhaps I missed it, but I can't find a reference citing the source of the website.
I am not disputing the information, but I am curious as to who posted it on the internet.
#24
#25