Suspension Eibach springs vs TSW springs
First I was wanting the H&R's, then I heard about ride quality, then wanted the mach v's / eibachs for their less agressive drop, but now that i've got my summers back on (18's) I am reminded that my wheel gap really isnt THAT big when compared to the 16's I had on for the winter.
Anyhow, for those with the TSW- the drop seems mild enough that we may be able to get away with oem (sport) rear control arms? I know they have a little play in them to get the camber back close to 0, if not maybe -.5
Also, any needs for cutting bump stops or anything? I've heard some discussions on that from the more aggressive drops...
edit: ah, and yes, I am thinking about/leaning towards TSW's now. in addition, with a less of a drop, there is more stock shock travel, so longer/slower wear =p
Anyhow, for those with the TSW- the drop seems mild enough that we may be able to get away with oem (sport) rear control arms? I know they have a little play in them to get the camber back close to 0, if not maybe -.5
Also, any needs for cutting bump stops or anything? I've heard some discussions on that from the more aggressive drops...
edit: ah, and yes, I am thinking about/leaning towards TSW's now. in addition, with a less of a drop, there is more stock shock travel, so longer/slower wear =p
Make sure to put some fixed camber plates while you're in there. They're 100% worth it.
Anyone with pics on 18's? I'm about to pull the trigger, just really want to see wheel gap change for an 18.
My wheel gap right now stock sport suspen. is probably right around a little less than 2". If I get a drop of 1" i'd be pretty happy, putting me in a <1" gap in New England with these crappy roads and winters, it'd be a good compromise imo.
My wheel gap right now stock sport suspen. is probably right around a little less than 2". If I get a drop of 1" i'd be pretty happy, putting me in a <1" gap in New England with these crappy roads and winters, it'd be a good compromise imo.
i personally say go TSW... for 3 reasons:
1) Suspension geometry: you're not going to get great performance just from slamming your car like honda people. mini's have a very great sweet spot with just a 1 inch drop, after that you start messing with the suspension geometry. sticking with JCW and TSW will give you higher rates with linear set-up and not unnessesary drop.
2)Balance: if you take the ratio ( >1 is front bias, <1 rear bias, 1 is perfect 50/50) the stock springs have a bias of .71 (for an idea, most honda's are 1.6 bias)... the Eibachs at highest rate, not the lower springs, are .72... where as the TSWs are .86... WAAAY better, better balance, better feel... IMO anyway... some people love the tail out action. but with a better balanced car you can dial in and out your tail action by just adjusting the rear sway bar...
3) this is my personal belief, i say if a stock suspension has linear springs then aftermarket should do that too. it keeps the car in a similar feel... on top of that, suspension systems like coilovers mainly have linear springs two... i've seen maybe two with progressive... Koni comes to mind. but if you want the drop of eibachs and like the more cushy ride and stock bias then go for them. i just think with hard pot holes and any sudden changes in the road could make a big problem if you go from soft to hard spring suddenly... once again tho, just mho
hope that helped some!!!
1) Suspension geometry: you're not going to get great performance just from slamming your car like honda people. mini's have a very great sweet spot with just a 1 inch drop, after that you start messing with the suspension geometry. sticking with JCW and TSW will give you higher rates with linear set-up and not unnessesary drop.
2)Balance: if you take the ratio ( >1 is front bias, <1 rear bias, 1 is perfect 50/50) the stock springs have a bias of .71 (for an idea, most honda's are 1.6 bias)... the Eibachs at highest rate, not the lower springs, are .72... where as the TSWs are .86... WAAAY better, better balance, better feel... IMO anyway... some people love the tail out action. but with a better balanced car you can dial in and out your tail action by just adjusting the rear sway bar...
3) this is my personal belief, i say if a stock suspension has linear springs then aftermarket should do that too. it keeps the car in a similar feel... on top of that, suspension systems like coilovers mainly have linear springs two... i've seen maybe two with progressive... Koni comes to mind. but if you want the drop of eibachs and like the more cushy ride and stock bias then go for them. i just think with hard pot holes and any sudden changes in the road could make a big problem if you go from soft to hard spring suddenly... once again tho, just mho
hope that helped some!!!
Banned
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 3,499
Likes: 0
From: Car Nut Since 1987, Owner Since Fall 2005, Vendor Since Fall 2007
about -0.4
After going for a ride in a96's car with TSW springs and IE camber plates, I have gotta say WOOOOW
I AM STUNNED! . Much better handling than my mini with H&Rs. I think I have whiplash from the ride earlier! j/k
btw I couldn't stop thinking all day today how easily your car corners.
I AM STUNNED! . Much better handling than my mini with H&Rs. I think I have whiplash from the ride earlier! j/k
btw I couldn't stop thinking all day today how easily your car corners.
After going for a ride in a96's car with TSW springs and IE camber plates, I have gotta say WOOOOW
I AM STUNNED! . Much better handling than my mini with H&Rs. I think I have whiplash from the ride earlier! j/k
btw I couldn't stop thinking all day today how easily your car corners.
I AM STUNNED! . Much better handling than my mini with H&Rs. I think I have whiplash from the ride earlier! j/k
btw I couldn't stop thinking all day today how easily your car corners.

Izzy's right, but CO's are overkill for a daily driver, IMO. I went back and forth about them for a couple months before I decided that TSW's were the way to go. And personally, I like the stance more than that of the H&R's. It gives the car more a "sleeper" look. Not to mention that actually bottom out on the roads LESS than what I used to on the stock springs.
Also, there are a few CO's that use progressive springs... boo.
Also, there are a few CO's that use progressive springs... boo.
I'd like to point out that it's not at all a bad thing that linear springs remain constant. Because they remain constant, your car's handling will be much more predictable than with a progressive rate.
The theory behind progressive springs seems sound; less stiffening for when you don't need it(straight line more comfort) and more stiffening when you do need it(at turns). Some issues encountered however are the springs losing the soft rate before the hard rate, and handling being unpredictable.
Frankly, I would like to see(or best case scenario design my own) CO system that adjusts automatically(user presets the different points) depending on the road and maneuver. I believe Mercedes was boasting about a similar design they have on their new smaller SUV.
Note: Sorry for going off topic. :X
Frankly, I would like to see(or best case scenario design my own) CO system that adjusts automatically(user presets the different points) depending on the road and maneuver. I believe Mercedes was boasting about a similar design they have on their new smaller SUV.
Note: Sorry for going off topic. :X
After going for a ride in a96's car with TSW springs and IE camber plates, I have gotta say WOOOOW
I AM STUNNED! . Much better handling than my mini with H&Rs. I think I have whiplash from the ride earlier! j/k
btw I couldn't stop thinking all day today how easily your car corners.
I AM STUNNED! . Much better handling than my mini with H&Rs. I think I have whiplash from the ride earlier! j/k
btw I couldn't stop thinking all day today how easily your car corners.

no problem. The car is 100% neutral, and very easy to drive and scare passengers. I'm still tempted to do the cross coilovers as I sometimes start having some body roll issues (both inside tires screaming for dear life) when I push the car way too hard. That or maybe a 22mm IE bar, not sure yet.
no problem. The car is 100% neutral, and very easy to drive and scare passengers. I'm still tempted to do the cross coilovers as I sometimes start having some body roll issues (both inside tires screaming for dear life) when I push the car way too hard. That or maybe a 22mm IE bar, not sure yet.
I'm trying to decide weather or not to skip the springs and go with coilovers. How hard is way too hard in your opinion. Of course, if I don't really notice a whole lot of roll (I do, but it isn't completely unbearable), I probably am not pushing as hard as you.
In that case, I may just save the dough and get the TSW springs.btw i have the stock sport suspension plus a 19mm alta rear sway, and a m7 front strut brace.
Also, what kind of driving do you usually do? Daily driving that is. Most of my daily drive is highway. I have held off on the camber plates for fear of accelerated tire wear. What is your experience with this?
Thanks.
How hard are we talking here?
I'm trying to decide weather or not to skip the springs and go with coilovers. How hard is way too hard in your opinion. Of course, if I don't really notice a whole lot of roll (I do, but it isn't completely unbearable), I probably am not pushing as hard as you.
In that case, I may just save the dough and get the TSW springs.
btw i have the stock sport suspension plus a 19mm alta rear sway, and a m7 front strut brace.
Also, what kind of driving do you usually do? Daily driving that is. Most of my daily drive is highway. I have held off on the camber plates for fear of accelerated tire wear. What is your experience with this?
Thanks.

I'm trying to decide weather or not to skip the springs and go with coilovers. How hard is way too hard in your opinion. Of course, if I don't really notice a whole lot of roll (I do, but it isn't completely unbearable), I probably am not pushing as hard as you.
In that case, I may just save the dough and get the TSW springs.btw i have the stock sport suspension plus a 19mm alta rear sway, and a m7 front strut brace.
Also, what kind of driving do you usually do? Daily driving that is. Most of my daily drive is highway. I have held off on the camber plates for fear of accelerated tire wear. What is your experience with this?
Thanks.



