R50/53 Service Dept driving my car on a road trip ?
So let me get this straight.
A guy from the MINI/BMW dealer is going to pull up to your house in a 7 series give you the keys and take your MINI back for service, leaving you the BMW as a loaner while your MINI is gone and you are worried about how he might treat your car? Or he comes with a flatbed to take it away you’ll not let it go?
I would have no trouble giving my keys to that person at all, but I’m not ****. I just put gas in my MCS with no routine.
Now if the guy showed up in a GEO… Dream on dealer.
A guy from the MINI/BMW dealer is going to pull up to your house in a 7 series give you the keys and take your MINI back for service, leaving you the BMW as a loaner while your MINI is gone and you are worried about how he might treat your car? Or he comes with a flatbed to take it away you’ll not let it go?
I would have no trouble giving my keys to that person at all, but I’m not ****. I just put gas in my MCS with no routine.
Now if the guy showed up in a GEO… Dream on dealer.
Originally Posted by Xman
I feel the same! For the time being, as soon as I hear the auto lock, I reach the toggle switch and unlock everything, this way the gas cap and boot are also unlocked...
Originally Posted by lot15
Besides someone running up to your car and opening the door and dragging you out,why would you want the doors to autolock?Kids in the car maybe,but they are as likely to pull it twice,as much as they are once.


But while on the subject I don't like the idea that if you lock the doors via the console switch you can't unlock with the door handle. Now I don't know if this is true either - one of those things I planned to verify but the thought was lost as soon as I started driving the car!
It's a safety thing, Lot.
1. A locked door is supposedly less likely to fly open in an accident (or be accidentally
opened in transit.)
2. In a carjacking scenario, if someone tried to open your door, they couldn't. I realize they don't even have real cities in Canada
, and minimal crime (everyone has what they need, right?) but elsewhere it's a concern for some people.
Ran, likely you have the 'auto unlock on engine off' set as well. You can unlock the door in any scenario. The first pull unlocks it, the second opens it.
Back on topic, Xman, glad to hear you're getting a home grown remedy!
1. A locked door is supposedly less likely to fly open in an accident (or be accidentally
opened in transit.)2. In a carjacking scenario, if someone tried to open your door, they couldn't. I realize they don't even have real cities in Canada
, and minimal crime (everyone has what they need, right?) but elsewhere it's a concern for some people.Ran, likely you have the 'auto unlock on engine off' set as well. You can unlock the door in any scenario. The first pull unlocks it, the second opens it.
Back on topic, Xman, glad to hear you're getting a home grown remedy!
Originally Posted by Eric_Rowland
It's a safety thing, Lot.
1. A locked door is supposedly less likely to fly open in an accident (or be accidentally
opened in transit.)
2. In a carjacking scenario, if someone tried to open your door, they couldn't. I realize they don't even have real cities in Canada
, and minimal crime (everyone has what they need, right?) but elsewhere it's a concern for some people.
Ran, likely you have the 'auto unlock on engine off' set as well. You can unlock the door in any scenario. The first pull unlocks it, the second opens it.
Back on topic, Xman, glad to hear you're getting a home grown remedy!
1. A locked door is supposedly less likely to fly open in an accident (or be accidentally
opened in transit.)2. In a carjacking scenario, if someone tried to open your door, they couldn't. I realize they don't even have real cities in Canada
, and minimal crime (everyone has what they need, right?) but elsewhere it's a concern for some people.Ran, likely you have the 'auto unlock on engine off' set as well. You can unlock the door in any scenario. The first pull unlocks it, the second opens it.
Back on topic, Xman, glad to hear you're getting a home grown remedy!
Originally Posted by Eric_Rowland
It's a safety thing, Lot.
1. A locked door is supposedly less likely to fly open in an accident (or be accidentally
opened in transit.)
1. A locked door is supposedly less likely to fly open in an accident (or be accidentally
opened in transit.)
Originally Posted by Eric_Rowland
Back on topic, Xman, glad to hear you're getting a home grown remedy!
Originally Posted by Xman
Thanks for all the feedback.
Everybody pretty much confirmed what I was thinking.
Since there's no flatbed involved, I called them to tell them "thanks, but no thanks". As a compromise, they will send me a new fog light assembly (should be a pretty simple DIY job). As far as the automatic door lock screwup -which drives me nuts- I'll have to live with it until next time I'm around a MINI dealer...
Everybody pretty much confirmed what I was thinking.
Since there's no flatbed involved, I called them to tell them "thanks, but no thanks". As a compromise, they will send me a new fog light assembly (should be a pretty simple DIY job). As far as the automatic door lock screwup -which drives me nuts- I'll have to live with it until next time I'm around a MINI dealer...
Great to hear you have found a solution (sort of).
Tell them to build a MINI dealership in your town/area.
Having a mishap would be the last thing you or the dealership wants.
I would be a very bad day if your MINI looked like this-

or this-

Why is she smiling?
Cause it's not her car!
I wonder what it might have sounded like in the boat?
Originally Posted by tradiuz
I love auto lock/unlock. I also have had a good friend carjacked in a 'safe' neighborhood by someone who pulled open the door and threw them to the ground. 

!!!I just don't like the car doing things I can do myself, that's the reason I don't like that automatic feature (or any other "Nanny" features)...and besides, I can do the same job myself with a really cool toggle switch
Originally Posted by Xman
I always thought it was safer to have a door unlock in case of an accident, to avoid any jamming and therefor being trapped...
Speaking of damages done at a dealership, check out: http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eB...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1
abstract:
"This was a customers car that was damaged on a road test by a technician. The car runs and drives.The car has serious body damage on the drivers side and a few scratches and dings on the passanger side. This car is being sold as is."
Originally Posted by Eric_Rowland
Yes, but the MINI automatically unlocks the doors when the airbags go off (IIRC), just for that reason. :smile:
(Still don't like the nanny auto lock though
)
Originally Posted by Eric_Rowland
Speaking of damages done at a dealership, check out: http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eB...MEWA%3AIT&rd=1
abstract:
"This was a customers car that was damaged on a road test by a technician. The car runs and drives.The car has serious body damage on the drivers side and a few scratches and dings on the passanger side. This car is being sold as is."
abstract:
"This was a customers car that was damaged on a road test by a technician. The car runs and drives.The car has serious body damage on the drivers side and a few scratches and dings on the passanger side. This car is being sold as is."
It's a nice way to get a brand new MINI though
eventhough I would miss my 03' steering wheel...
Originally Posted by Xman
That is just terrible
!!!
I just don't like the car doing things I can do myself, that's the reason I don't like that automatic feature (or any other "Nanny" features)...and besides, I can do the same job myself with a really cool toggle switch
!!!I just don't like the car doing things I can do myself, that's the reason I don't like that automatic feature (or any other "Nanny" features)...and besides, I can do the same job myself with a really cool toggle switch

Maybe you should go back to the days of having a hole in the radiator so that you could hand crank the engine and wouldn’t have to rely on a “Nanny” electric starter!
Originally Posted by Eric_Rowland
That's it, soundwave - you just cost yourself your membership card in the **** MINI Owners Club (AMOC)!

Originally Posted by Nick_T.
Sounds like a “young person’s” perspective to me! When I was a kid many cars had two levers behind the steering wheel - where today’s cars have the turn signal and wiper stalks now - and they controlled the fuel mixture and spark advance. I heard many “old timers” complain that they could do it better. When I learned to drive all cars had manual chokes, and when automatic chokes started appearing many complained that they could do it better. Same thing for many other features.
Maybe you should go back to the days of having a hole in the radiator so that you could hand crank the engine and wouldn’t have to rely on a “Nanny” electric starter!
Maybe you should go back to the days of having a hole in the radiator so that you could hand crank the engine and wouldn’t have to rely on a “Nanny” electric starter!
That's not what I meant by Nanny items.
For example: I like an elcetric window over a manual window, but I still like to decide when the window goes up and down. Same thing for the wipers, I don't like rain sensor devices (but that's just me).
In a word, I don't mind devices that help me do something, I just mind when they decide when to do it for me...
And of course, it only applies to simple items, I don't intent on doing the ECU's job myself...
Why would you want to put that kind of mileage on your vehicle for such a minor problem? If they intend to flatbed it, OK, but this just doesn't seem worth it, you are running down the mileage on your warranty for this. I agree, take an IOU or change out that bulb yourself and see if they will spot you on the cost...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post






