R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006) Cooper (R50) and Cooper S (R53) hatchback discussion.

R50/53 What would you buy instead of a mini?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 10:59 PM
  #126  
Skiploder's Avatar
Skiploder
Banned
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,328
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by meanboy
These are trade in values? I did a KBB on my MCS and it was 20400 trade (gd condition) with a msrp of 24k. The evo RS with the same miles was 21k Sticker on the RS though was closer to 28k new. reguluar EVO sticker stickered over 30k new and trade in was $23,435. So just from my rough numbers, my mcs is 85% after 2 years, RS 75%, and Evo was 78%.

edit: MR was not available until 05
Also the yardstick they measure lease residuals by. Without quibbling over what you can actually get for your MCS, the general picture is that the Evos tend to hold their value pretty well.

Minis are a dime a dozen here in the Bay Area and with the R56 coming out, I would not be surprised to see the resale values adjusting down.

The next Evo (X) is over a year away and is rumored to be taking the car into a different direction.

The Evos were not made in large numbers in this country and with the rate that the under 24 crowd is destroying them, they might end up holding their values pretty well.
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:08 PM
  #127  
Skiploder's Avatar
Skiploder
Banned
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,328
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by meanboy
My friend purchased his at the end of 05. We have tight streets here and he has to back up on streets that he would normally be able to make in other cars. Pure anecdotal, YMMV.

Have the DSM guys cleaned up their financial picture yet? I haven't been looking or researching the EVO in a while. It just wasn't what the wife wanted.

And speaking of older men, I saw one middle age man driving a MR and a senior driving a Evo. It's definitely not only for the young.
A lot is going to depend on the next Endeavor/Outlander/Lancer Models being released next year.

I read in either the latest issue of MT or RT that the new Outlander is outselling the RAV4 and CRV in Japan.

The car magazines seem to be talking as if they have turned some corner - but time will tell.

In the meantime, the accolades and hype you hear about the Evo is real - I can't recommend enough getting the chance to take one out for a spin. They are projecting no 9s on the lots past this October.
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:18 PM
  #128  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by Skiploder
Also the yardstick they measure lease residuals by. Without quibbling over what you can actually get for your MCS, the general picture is that the Evos tend to hold their value pretty well.

Minis are a dime a dozen here in the Bay Area and with the R56 coming out, I would not be surprised to see the resale values adjusting down.

The next Evo (X) is over a year away and is rumored to be taking the car into a different direction.

The Evos were not made in large numbers in this country and with the rate that the under 24 crowd is destroying them, they might end up holding their values pretty well.
No disagreement about the EVO holding value but the I think the RS and EVO are not special in that regard because they can be had for a significant amount under MSRP during sales. MINIs, while a dime a dozen, aren't discounted at the dealer.

EVOs are just as prevalent here in the BA. I see as many or more EVOS than MINIS everyday in SF.

They just release the IX and they are going to X so soon?

As long as they keep producing them, and making better models, the older ones, as with the MINIs, will keep depreciating. These are mass produced cars. They aren't porsche 993s.
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:21 PM
  #129  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by Skiploder
A lot is going to depend on the next Endeavor/Outlander/Lancer Models being released next year.

I read in either the latest issue of MT or RT that the new Outlander is outselling the RAV4 and CRV in Japan.

The car magazines seem to be talking as if they have turned some corner - but time will tell.

In the meantime, the accolades and hype you hear about the Evo is real - I can't recommend enough getting the chance to take one out for a spin. They are projecting no 9s on the lots past this October.
The 9 just came out. Is the X that different?

I have no doubt about the potential of the EVOS. It's just not right for me at this time. I am more of the luxury GT kind of guy a the moment..IE E46 M3, or E90 M3 or 997 GT3 if I hit the lottery. Then again, if I hit the lottery I can have more than one toy.
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:25 PM
  #130  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
BTW, you won't see me disregarding the potential of the EVO. If you want to discuss the merits with a hater, see RR|Suki. He'll tell you all about the vices of the EVO.
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:42 PM
  #131  
mini2di4's Avatar
mini2di4
2nd Gear
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
From: Denver, CO
Any other car than my mini? I'll take the bus!! Seriously..an Acura, Honda or Toyota are the only other cars I would consider.
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:57 PM
  #132  
Guest's Avatar
Guest
6th Gear
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 3,902
Likes: 2
From: SoCaL (Agoura Hills)
The percentages are the same, but the actual money figures aren't. losing 50% of your 24k dollar Mini is 12k, losing 50% of your 36k dollar Evo, is 18k :-\.

That being said, Most of the Mini's being sold in Southern California are selling for a grand or two under the MSRP as used cars, I bought my 2004 for 22,500, I could have gotten a new one for 25 :-\. granted, it wouldn't have had 16k in engine mods done to it, but the owner knew he wasn't going to make a dime on those, nor would I have paid any more to get them.

Statistics are great looking at the US as a whole, but i'd have a hard time believing that you could find a 2004 Mini Cooper S in good condition selling for $18k in Southern California (32% depreciation on a $26k car = 8,320 - $26k = $17,680k). Multiple contacts who go to regular car auctions have told me that the Cooper S is going through auctions higher than that . If you can buy it for MSRP here, it's almost a better deal than going used. The majority of the dealers are still getting anywhere from 2000-4000 markup above and beyond the MSRP for these cars.

Originally Posted by Skiploder
Slightly off topic with the Evos here:

http://money.cnn.com/pf/features/pop...1.exclude.html

Guess which car the Evo is tied for resale value with?
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:58 PM
  #133  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by Skiploder
Also the yardstick they measure lease residuals by. Without quibbling over what you can actually get for your MCS, the general picture is that the Evos tend to hold their value pretty well.

Minis are a dime a dozen here in the Bay Area and with the R56 coming out, I would not be surprised to see the resale values adjusting down.

The next Evo (X) is over a year away and is rumored to be taking the car into a different direction.

The Evos were not made in large numbers in this country and with the rate that the under 24 crowd is destroying them, they might end up holding their values pretty well.
I found something about the 04 residuals.

http://money.cnn.com/2003/11/10/pf/a...alue/index.htm
 
Reply
Old Aug 22, 2006 | 11:59 PM
  #134  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by mini2di4
Any other car than my mini? I'll take the bus!! Seriously..an Acura, Honda or Toyota are the only other cars I would consider.
what color bus? Just kidding.
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 12:03 AM
  #135  
mini2di4's Avatar
mini2di4
2nd Gear
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
From: Denver, CO
What color is the "short bus"???
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 12:06 AM
  #136  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Local dealer auction. Only regular coopers sold. 03 w/33k miles wholesaled at 16k. 06 wholesaled with 3k miles sold for 22750. What the heck?!?

http://www.elimidealer.com/prices.htm

http://www.elimidealer.com/prices.pdf
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 12:08 AM
  #137  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by mini2di4
What color is the "short bus"???
It's got to be LY! My fav color!
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 12:10 AM
  #138  
mini2di4's Avatar
mini2di4
2nd Gear
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
From: Denver, CO
Ok..guess I do belong on the "short bus"..what color is LY????
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 12:28 AM
  #139  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Liquid Yellow...former color of the former short bus
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 12:35 AM
  #140  
Guest's Avatar
Guest
6th Gear
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 3,902
Likes: 2
From: SoCaL (Agoura Hills)
Regular Coopers, not the Cooper S. The one that sold for 16k had nothing in it at all, and both were Automatics (). I'll take a Cooper S over a Lancer any day! If only because it doesn't look like a 9k dollar econo sedan .

Originally Posted by meanboy
Local dealer auction. Only regular coopers sold. 03 w/33k miles wholesaled at 16k. 06 wholesaled with 3k miles sold for 22750. What the heck?!?

http://www.elimidealer.com/prices.htm

http://www.elimidealer.com/prices.pdf
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 05:37 AM
  #141  
Skiploder's Avatar
Skiploder
Banned
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,328
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by meanboy
No disagreement about the EVO holding value but the I think the RS and EVO are not special in that regard because they can be had for a significant amount under MSRP during sales. MINIs, while a dime a dozen, aren't discounted at the dealer.

EVOs are just as prevalent here in the BA. I see as many or more EVOS than MINIS everyday in SF.

They just release the IX and they are going to X so soon?

As long as they keep producing them, and making better models, the older ones, as with the MINIs, will keep depreciating. These are mass produced cars. They aren't porsche 993s.
I'm in the BA also and travel quite a bit during my day - I really don't see many Evos...........compared to the Mini - they just don't produce near as many. I have gone two days or so without seeing any and the ones I do are usually the same handful of cars.
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 05:41 AM
  #142  
Skiploder's Avatar
Skiploder
Banned
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,328
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by rustyboy155
Regular Coopers, not the Cooper S. The one that sold for 16k had nothing in it at all, and both were Automatics (). I'll take a Cooper S over a Lancer any day! If only because it doesn't look like a 9k dollar econo sedan .
You have a point - it looks like a $9K econo hatchback.

Seriously, while there is no denying that the Evo is roughly based on the Lancer, it is built in an entirely different factory. It shares only one body panel (trunk), incorporates and integrated roll bar and chassis bracing, and is only one of two production cars that is seam-welded. It literally has nothing in common with the Lancer mechanically.

The chassis, with the inclusion of the floorpan, is different. None of the key Evo parts bolt onto a Lancer or vice-versa.

Look, I can't deny that the Evo is a bit ugly. But driving the car transforms your perception of it. Literally every automotive publication has showered the car with accolades. Interestingly enough, if you visit other performance car forums, they give the Evo it's due. Sure they'll harp on the looks, but anyone who has driven one at the track, feels the power, the communicative steering, the excellent brakes and the phenominal handling of the car comes away impressed.

From Edmunds:

"It's about a completely unfiltered driving experience that sucks you in and never lets you go. Every shift of the five-speed gearbox feels like you're hand-feeding torque to all four wheels. Every hard turn feels like you have three friends, Suspension, Steering and Brakes, and they're telling you all their secrets. And every second you spend in the Recaro seats? That's a lasting embrace from the one that got away."

"If you want to fall in love with an Evo, take it to the curviest road you can find and make about 20 laps. It's not just about how quick the steering is, how deftly the suspension manages changing loads, or how well those differentials stir up the power when you're exiting corners, although these traits will undoubtedly impress you. This car talks to you. You feel it reaching out to you through the steering wheel, the driver seat and the pedals, and you do what it tells you. You feel like a pro."

From the Robb Report:

"If its (Evo) not on your ten all-time best enthusiast cars list, then your list is incomplete"

Hell, it ran an 8.11 at the Ring (in the damp). That's right up there with the big boys.

It isn't my job to sell Evos to the masses. Just my opinions and perception. Now I better quit before C4 crashes the party and tells me what a pile of crap every other car but the Mini is..........
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 05:44 AM
  #143  
Skiploder's Avatar
Skiploder
Banned
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,328
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by meanboy
BTW, you won't see me disregarding the potential of the EVO. If you want to discuss the merits with a hater, see RR|Suki. He'll tell you all about the vices of the EVO.
I'm really not interested in bashing either car. To each his own right?

If you are interested, head up to San Rafael and ask to test drive the owner's 2006 MR that they use for a demo.
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 09:05 AM
  #144  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by Skiploder
I'm in the BA also and travel quite a bit during my day - I really don't see many Evos...........compared to the Mini - they just don't produce near as many. I have gone two days or so without seeing any and the ones I do are usually the same handful of cars.
There are a lot of evos in SF. That's where I saw the middle age man and the senior citizen driving their MR and EVO. But to get back to the number of evos on the road, there may not be as many on the road as the MINI but is because its market is so specialized that they don't sell many? At least here, and you shuold know this, buying a MINI off of the showroom floor at MSRP is not all that common. Being able to buy a RS or a EVO on sale or off of the showroom floor isn't uncommon. The MR is different and may skew the numbers. I went to the dealership in serramonte and look at the EVO last year. I came back a week later and the same ones were there. They aren't exactly flying out of the showroom.

I think an EVO is a great buy, even better than a MINI because of it's features, and the fact it can be had for under MSRP. But I give the MINI credit as well. How many mass produced cars can retain hold it's value over the years like it?
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 09:07 AM
  #145  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by Skiploder
I'm really not interested in bashing either car. To each his own right?

If you are interested, head up to San Rafael and ask to test drive the owner's 2006 MR that they use for a demo.
Great suggestion. When I go to the mitsu dealer here they pretty much ignore me even though showed up in a BMW and I am in my forties.
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 09:08 AM
  #146  
meanboy's Avatar
meanboy
6th Gear
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 1
From: the great country of california
Originally Posted by Skiploder
It isn't my job to sell Evos to the masses. Just my opinions and perception. Now I better quit before C4 crashes the party and tells me what a pile of crap every other car but the Mini is..........
yea, you better quit before he gets wind of this because there is no other car better than the MINI!
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 09:40 AM
  #147  
RafterManFMJ's Avatar
RafterManFMJ
2nd Gear
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 66
Likes: 0
From: Butler, PA
Originally Posted by zfxr
Kinda depends, but I've considered-

Golf R32, Subie WRX wagon, Golf TDI, Infiniti G35 coupe
Great Choices!
I've test driven the Golf R32, owned both the WRX wagon and Jetta TDI...damn, you're not female and available, are you?
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 10:24 AM
  #148  
HHFD633's Avatar
HHFD633
4th Gear
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 493
Likes: 1
From: Coventry, RI
2006 vw gti white
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 03:34 PM
  #149  
Skiploder's Avatar
Skiploder
Banned
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 1,328
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by meanboy
Great suggestion. When I go to the mitsu dealer here they pretty much ignore me even though showed up in a BMW and I am in my forties.
Seriously - ask for Snorre or Eric (co-owners - Snorre is an ex-rally car driver). SRM is one of the few dealers that will let you test drive an Evo without giving up a kidney. His test drives give Webb's a run for the money.

Next door is their in-house tuning shop which houses Paul Fischer (Evo Tuner Savant from Down Under) and Beau Kelly (Dr. Evo). They run a full race prep dyno/shop owned by SR Mitsubishi.

Great people and atmosphere - it gives you an alternate look at the other types of gents who drive Evos.
 
Reply
Old Aug 23, 2006 | 03:48 PM
  #150  
chows4us's Avatar
chows4us
6th Gear
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 15,478
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by Skiploder
... Now I better quit before C4 crashes the party and tells me what a pile of crap every other car but the Mini is..........
 
Reply



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:19 AM.