R56 Whistling mini
Whistling mini
Hi everyone,
I have a 2010S with 35,000 miles. In the past month I have noticed a whistling while letting off the gas.
When I was at the dealer they were not able to duplicate the issue. It only happens some of the time.
Any ideas on what that is?
Thanks for any help
I have a 2010S with 35,000 miles. In the past month I have noticed a whistling while letting off the gas.
When I was at the dealer they were not able to duplicate the issue. It only happens some of the time.
Any ideas on what that is?
Thanks for any help
It sounds like a leak between the throttle body and engine. When you let off of the throttle, the engine pulls a vacuum in the intake manifold because the throttle is closed and the engine can't in suck air.
Could you record the sound for the dealer?
Dave
Could you record the sound for the dealer?
Dave
My guess would also be a vac leak of some-sort. I had issues with a throttle sensor in the manifold. No noise, but mine froze and split causing massive power loss, maybe urs is having an issue fully closing.
As far a BOV goes, there isnt one on the S. It uses a recirculator valve taking all excess boost and pushing it through the intake manifold. There is no venting to the atmosphere. The recirc valve does produce a noise close to that of a bov, but if your using the factory intake you wont hear any of it without trying and windows down. Its just the pfffsh not a whistle.
As far a BOV goes, there isnt one on the S. It uses a recirculator valve taking all excess boost and pushing it through the intake manifold. There is no venting to the atmosphere. The recirc valve does produce a noise close to that of a bov, but if your using the factory intake you wont hear any of it without trying and windows down. Its just the pfffsh not a whistle.
Recirc as well. Try replacing the spring with a forge spring. Very cheap and may prolong the life of the existing valve. Careful not to tear the diaphragm.
Trending Topics
I noticed a whistle (2013 Coupe S , Automatic) the last couple days. Came here to search and found this thread 
I Had my window down a little while driving under an over pass at highway speed, that's when I heard it. I can't hear it when driving out in the open, I guess the sound just bounces back from the overpass. I tried removing the radio antenna - still whistling. Throttle on or off, doesn't make a difference, the whistle is a constant pitch at speed. So i'm thinking it might be wind related. i did a larger FMIC and a license plate relocate bracket - maybe the bracket.
I will try taping off the a-pillars first. eliminating one possibility at a time.

I Had my window down a little while driving under an over pass at highway speed, that's when I heard it. I can't hear it when driving out in the open, I guess the sound just bounces back from the overpass. I tried removing the radio antenna - still whistling. Throttle on or off, doesn't make a difference, the whistle is a constant pitch at speed. So i'm thinking it might be wind related. i did a larger FMIC and a license plate relocate bracket - maybe the bracket.
I will try taping off the a-pillars first. eliminating one possibility at a time.
Last edited by sbninja; Mar 17, 2014 at 07:15 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
igzekyativ
MINIs & Minis for Sale
28
Dec 23, 2015 10:36 AM
ECSTuning
Vendor Classifieds
0
Aug 7, 2015 05:55 AM





