North American Motoring

North American Motoring (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/)
-   F55/F56 :: Hatch Talk (2014+) (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/f55-f56-hatch-talk-2014-428/)
-   -   F55/F56 Looked into Retrofitting Rear Fogs (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/f55-f56-hatch-talk-2014/274615-looked-into-retrofitting-rear-fogs.html)

glucklich21 07-28-2014 05:22 PM

Looked into Retrofitting Rear Fogs
 
5 Attachment(s)
In my previous car (BMW E90), to retrofit rear fog lights was just a matter of replacing the switch for a european spec one or "enabling" the button with an exacto knife, a spring from an old pen, and a straw. Hoping for something similar on the Mini, I took the lower panel off to see what's what.

My Mini did not have the rear fogs option ticked, something that comes with buying off the lot and me being a little impatient to order. Anywho, with the panel off, I first looked at the wiring. The connector has 3 pins, a ground, a signal wire, and a wire for illumination (guessing here). There is a 4th hole in the connector for another wire that's absent. Can factory rear fog owners check and see if this is occupied? This is a generic connector 4 pin connector BMW has used since the 90's so I may just be paranoid.

Attachment 149341



Here's the backside of the switch.



Attachment 149342



I took apart the switch that's held together with a series of clips for a peek inside.


Attachment 149343


Front:

Attachment 149344

Back:

Attachment 149345


As you can see bits are actually missing from the circuit board, so looks like it's a no go for the spring and straw method. I'm just curious how many fractions of pennies did they save by doing this. They did splurge on bulbs in the rear foglights however. :roll:


So it looks like I'll be ordering a new switch and see where that gets me.

MarcoPolo 07-29-2014 09:40 AM

subscribed.
i was considered not even bothering to use it as a fog as i don't see that being an issue in NY but moreso splicing into my backup lights so they turn on when i go into reverse. seems easier and more realistic to some of us that dont' live in high fog areas.

also would help for those with dark tints.

ojedam64 07-30-2014 08:06 AM

Marcopolo, I like the idea of converting them into additional back up lights. I havnt looked at it all to see if there are bulbs in there. but since the lens is there it probably wouldn't be too hard to add a switch and lights. but of course you'd be doing all the wiring and everything.

MarcoPolo 07-30-2014 08:07 AM


Originally Posted by ojedam64 (Post 3968778)
Marcopolo, I like the idea of converting them into additional back up lights. I havnt looked at it all to see if there are bulbs in there. but since the lens is there it probably wouldn't be too hard to add a switch and lights. but of course you'd be doing all the wiring and everything.

i haven't either but word around the forums is that they come with bulbs...

- verify the fuse can handle the load
- splice the wiring...

i'll take a stab at it over the weekend.

glucklich21 07-30-2014 08:28 AM

What about just putting bright LEDs in the reverse lights? I mean the rear fogs are red, doesn't seem like the best solution.

MarcoPolo 07-30-2014 08:33 AM


Originally Posted by glucklich21 (Post 3968792)
What about just putting bright LEDs in the reverse lights? I mean the rear fogs are red, doesn't seem like the best solution.

i was just trying to make use of the rear fogs....it's like they're there, so do something with them.

that was all. i get your solution, i was looking at alternatives.

glucklich21 07-30-2014 08:40 AM


Originally Posted by MarcoPolo (Post 3968793)
i was just trying to make use of the rear fogs....it's like they're there, so do something with them.

that was all. i get your solution, i was looking at alternatives.

Gotcha!

Rocket_man 07-30-2014 09:58 PM


Originally Posted by glucklich21 (Post 3967999)
In my previous car (BMW E90), to retrofit rear fog lights was just a matter of replacing the switch for a european spec one or "enabling" the button with an exacto knife, a spring from an old pen, and a straw. Hoping for something similar on the Mini, I took the lower panel off to see what's what.

My Mini did not have the rear fogs option ticked, something that comes with buying off the lot and me being a little impatient to order. Anywho, with the panel off, I first looked at the wiring. The connector has 3 pins, a ground, a signal wire, and a wire for illumination (guessing here). There is a 4th hole in the connector for another wire that's absent. Can factory rear fog owners check and see if this is occupied? This is a generic connector 4 pin connector BMW has used since the 90's so I may just be paranoid.

http://i687.photobucket.com/albums/v...i/DSC07956.jpg



Here's the backside of the switch.



http://i687.photobucket.com/albums/v...i/DSC07959.jpg



I took apart the switch that's held together with a series of clips for a peek inside.


http://i687.photobucket.com/albums/v...i/DSC07963.jpg


Front:

http://i687.photobucket.com/albums/v...b6b1c4394e.jpg

Back:

http://i687.photobucket.com/albums/v...i/DSC07965.jpg


As you can see bits are actually missing from the circuit board, so looks like it's a no go for the spring and straw method. I'm just curious how many fractions of pennies did they save by doing this. They did splurge on bulbs in the rear foglights however. :roll:


So it looks like I'll be ordering a new switch and see where that gets me.

It doesn't make sense that they replace this circuit card if a car is ordered with rear fogs. I think it is a $100 charge. That doesn't add up. I'm not sure there is a separate switch for the rear fogs. I suspect they come on with the front fogs, so there may only be one fog light switch. Those missing bits might be for some future functionality.

Maybe the rear fogs are actually some software enabling thing??? The connector on the back of that switch is some digital control signal. So it is sending a command to some computer. $100 to make a software change sounds more reasonable and explains why there are already bulbs back there.

Did you ask the dealer if they can enable them?

rkw 07-31-2014 01:58 AM


Originally Posted by Rocket_man (Post 3969096)
I'm not sure there is a separate switch for the rear fogs. I suspect they come on with the front fogs, so there may only be one fog light switch. Those missing bits might be for some future functionality.

Is this just idle speculation? The Owner's Manual clearly shows the rear fog button and describes its operation.

In past generations of MINI, retrofitting the rear fog involved both adding the switch and programming. Depending on the model, the rear fog lamp was often already there, wired and complete with bulb even if it wasn't functioning.

CobraBob 07-31-2014 03:22 AM

The rear fogs are not just for fog. They're beneficial, as well, in heavy rain. Or any other condition where visibility to the car behind you is limited. I just tested my rear fogs last night with my wife driving behind me. She was surprised at how bright they were. I will most definitely use them in the future in heavy rain. I like the idea that a vehicle behind me can see me when I need them to. So I would not recommend converting the rear fogs to an additional backup light system. Instead, replace your backup lights with a brighter bulb.

RKW, in another thread someone confirmed that if you didn't order rear fog lights then the existing setup on your MINI is sans the bulb, switch and programming. And maybe without the wiring, too.

ojedam64 07-31-2014 06:34 AM

seems crazy they installed bulbs and a false switch...almost like it would cost pennies to finish the job.

CobraBob 07-31-2014 07:22 AM


Originally Posted by Rocket_man (Post 3969096)
It doesn't make sense that they replace this circuit card if a car is ordered with rear fogs. I think it is a $100 charge. That doesn't add up. I'm not sure there is a separate switch for the rear fogs. I suspect they come on with the front fogs, so there may only be one fog light switch. Those missing bits might be for some future functionality.

Maybe the rear fogs are actually some software enabling thing??? The connector on the back of that switch is some digital control signal. So it is sending a command to some computer. $100 to make a software change sounds more reasonable and explains why there are already bulbs back there.

Did you ask the dealer if they can enable them?

There are two fog light buttons on the dash. Top is for the front fogs and the bottom for the rear fogs.

papawhiskey 07-31-2014 07:26 AM


Originally Posted by ojedam64 (Post 3969175)
seems crazy they installed bulbs and a false switch...almost like it would cost pennies to finish the job.

I think we have determined that all the wiring is already there and the bulbs too. Costs them pennies but they charge many dollars for the switch swap and programming!

glucklich21 08-04-2014 10:59 PM


Originally Posted by Rocket_man (Post 3969096)
It doesn't make sense that they replace this circuit card if a car is ordered with rear fogs. I think it is a $100 charge. That doesn't add up. I'm not sure there is a separate switch for the rear fogs. I suspect they come on with the front fogs, so there may only be one fog light switch. Those missing bits might be for some future functionality.

Maybe the rear fogs are actually some software enabling thing??? The connector on the back of that switch is some digital control signal. So it is sending a command to some computer. $100 to make a software change sounds more reasonable and explains why there are already bulbs back there.

Did you ask the dealer if they can enable them?

No as my nearest dealer is 140 miles away and I did not purchase the car from them. The circuitry is missing completely and I doubt the Mini has adaptive brake lights like its BMW cousins do (making the retrofit 5 mins tops on said cars). I'm driving up to Montana tomorrow so I'll revisit this when I get back towards the end of the month.

hp79 12-06-2014 07:44 PM

Any update on this anyone? I didn't get the fog lights, but I was hoping this can be retrofitted with an LED to stay on while the rear lights are on.

I'm thinking a low power draw LED shouldn't trip anything, so maybe just keep it lit all the time? It might be okay if it's just bright enough.

rkw 12-06-2014 09:01 PM


Originally Posted by glucklich21 (Post 3971192)
I doubt the Mini has adaptive brake lights like its BMW cousins do

FWIW, the option is available in the programming.

https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ogramming.html

George 2014 12-12-2014 08:46 AM


Originally Posted by hp79 (Post 4020637)
Any update on this anyone? I didn't get the fog lights, but I was hoping this can be retrofitted with an LED to stay on while the rear lights are on.

I'm thinking a low power draw LED shouldn't trip anything, so maybe just keep it lit all the time? It might be okay if it's just bright enough.

Just power them directly off the battery and trigger them with a relay that's signaled by whatever circuit you please: Brakes, headlamps, whatever.

That would be a stand-alone circuit that the ECU wouldn't see, so you can any type of bulb you like.

UticaProf 12-13-2014 07:08 AM

There's quite a bit of info in a previous thread about this, including pics of the replacement switch variations, which are around $100. I did the same surgery, pulling out the switch only to determine that unlike the BMW you can't do a quick activation. And this was after coding the rear fogs, but coding by itself doesn't do a thing.

spacecadet 12-20-2014 06:25 PM

To make the rear fogs work
 
As I just posted in the coding thread, you need to do the following - not just buying the switch, but also using e-sys to enable the feature in the body domain controller (BDC)




First, purchase the version of the light switch for your car that includes the rear fog switch and fit it.


Then, the following coding is required to make them work,


1) add option 5AA rear fogs to the VO (vehicle order)


then in the BDC, code the following :-


2) 3068, NSL_Verbaut = Verbaut


(This enables the BDC to sense the switch, if you just code this and try the lights, it just activates the symbol on the instrument cluster but does nothing else)




3)


3064 Mapping_Nebelschlussl_L_output = nsl_l
3064 Mapping_Nebelschlussl_L_Function = nebelschlusslicht
3064 Mapping_Nebelschlussl_R_output = nsl_l
3064 Mapping_Nebelschlussl_R_Function = nebelschlusslicht




These options enable the correct outputs on the BDC to activate the lights. You could choose to have only one light on if you wished




After doing all the above, you will have fully working rear fogs, confirming that both the wiring is already in place, and BMW rape your wallet for a $100 option that only needs probably an extra $1 in components in the switch module. They obviously have a very savvy marketing department who have figured out perceived value of such options like this that cost them next to nothing


BTW, the OP was asking about the light switch connector. It is three wires no matter what version/options you have. Power, ground, CANBUS. This is typical of multiplexed wiring used by BMW.

SemperMini 01-08-2015 01:37 PM

anyone ever find where you could purchase the light switch/circuit and how much it would cost?

hp79 01-08-2015 02:07 PM

I don't think you want to buy the switch module. The front headlight switch cluster that's in your front dash alone costs a lot to replace. Sewell parts and other places has them. Then you also need to add the hardware information in to your VO and then do the coding. If I knew when I was ordering, I would have just ordered the rear fog light for extra $100.

FlyByMike 01-08-2015 03:13 PM

Looking here, http://realoem.com/bmw/showparts.do?...83&hg=61&fg=35 seems like there is no specific switch available

-Mike '14 MCSa

spacecadet 01-08-2015 03:26 PM


Originally Posted by FlyByMike (Post 4031072)
Looking here, http://realoem.com/bmw/showparts.do?...83&hg=61&fg=35 seems like there is no specific switch available

-Mike '14 MCSa


items #5, #6, #7, #8 all have the rear fog switch added

#5 = No front fog and regular halogen lights

#6 = No front fog and LED lights

#7 = front and rear fog and regular halogen lights

#8 = front and rear fog and LED lights

SemperMini 01-08-2015 03:42 PM

so yeah... costs over $100 to get the switch then... yeah not worth it. maybe I will just wire it in with the reverse lights to have the extra light as some people have mentioned.

hp79 01-08-2015 07:42 PM

Let us know if you do anything to the rear fog light. I'd like to see what other people have done to it other than retro fitting the fog light switch cluster for $$$. Because these are canbus, it's not just simple as connecting them to some power source. Have to carefully look at the circuit to decide where to tap in to.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:56 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands