|
Dipstick for R53
So I've been reading about dipsticks breaking on the 1st Gen Mini's and I am not about to wait for that to happen. Have you guys found any worthy dipsticks? I've read mixed reviews on the Craven Speed one. Anyone here have them on their R53? I want something that won't break with an accurate reading of course. Thanks ya'll!
|
... all stock for mine ...
Motor On! |
Check out this link for the Meta: https://www.ebay.com/p/BMW-Mini-Coop...75.m4097.l9055
I had a CravenSpeed and found that it over reads due to being so floppie. Meta is stiff wire type and works great, no more worries. |
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383127)
So I've been reading about dipsticks breaking on the 1st Gen Mini's and I am not about to wait for that to happen. Have you guys found any worthy dipsticks? I've read mixed reviews on the Craven Speed one. Anyone here have them on their R53? I want something that won't break with an accurate reading of course. Thanks ya'll!
|
Originally Posted by gumbedamit
(Post 4383149)
I think the breakage has a lot to do with how they are pulled out. I've noticed most people are right handed and will pull at the dipstick with their right hands causing it to bind, I was guilty of this myself and noticed how much friction there was with me doing just that. Now I remove it with my left hand and it glides right out, no binding, just my 2cents.
|
Originally Posted by OKCmike
(Post 4383147)
Check out this link for the Meta: https://www.ebay.com/p/BMW-Mini-Coop...75.m4097.l9055
I had a CravenSpeed and found that it over reads due to being so floppie. Meta is stiff wire type and works great, no more worries. |
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383214)
That one says not to leave plugged in? |
Originally Posted by OKCmike
(Post 4383230)
What? Don't see where ya got that. Anyway just noticed on 2nd look, states sold out at this time. Sorry bout that, hopefully they'll be restocked in near future.
What about this one? https://www.outmotoring.com/917-315-...2007-2008.html |
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383213)
interwsting. I am right handed but I’ve always removed it with my left, since it’s on the left side lol |
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383233)
I clicked on the first one, and it says so in the description. It also says there are 10 available..?
What about this one? https://www.outmotoring.com/917-315-...2007-2008.html |
I broke two dipsticks before getting the Craven one. Took some getting used to but it's been working just fine for me for over a year. After measured oil change it hits the top hole right on, so I can't personally complain on accuracy.
I think I broke my factory ones by twisting slightly as I pulled (it's hard not to, esp when it's ALWAYS stuck). The shaft split and had a spiral break both times. |
@HaltCatchFire.
I just read your thread. Nice chronological detailed posts. You screen name cannot hide your geeky part and so are the posts and photos. I watched Halt and Catch Fire and really enjoyed it, though much less than Mad Men. I only wish it is less about internet and more about PCs as how the story first developed. what are the two cabinets in the garage? https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.nor...e1b89139a6.jpg |
I've been found out! I've not heard of that show actually, but seems right up my alley so I'll have to check it out. I design those chips for a living so that's where the name comes from :)
Those boxes in the pic are my other pride and joy, a restored Shizuoka AN-S CNC milling machine on the left, and the control box and paper tape reader on the right. Yes, paper tape - the system is from the 70's. Fun fact, that machine weighs as much as three mini coopers stacked! https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.nor...b06aca45f8.jpg |
I only wish I have an acreage and a barn. I would outfit it with a machine shop and a lift.
I binge watched Halt and Catch Fire on Netflix. I had mixed feeling initially but soon got drawn in. It is surprisingly good especially on the human side of the tech pioneers. What is surprising is anyone with the right mind will invest in such production as the Guardian article "Farewell to Halt and Catch Fire, the best show that nobody watched" Mad Men has a much wider appeal for average folks and you don't have to be in the creative industry to get it. |
Originally Posted by gumbedamit
(Post 4383234)
Has yours broken?
|
Originally Posted by HaltCatchFire
(Post 4383263)
I broke two dipsticks before getting the Craven one. Took some getting used to but it's been working just fine for me for over a year. After measured oil change it hits the top hole right on, so I can't personally complain on accuracy.
I think I broke my factory ones by twisting slightly as I pulled (it's hard not to, esp when it's ALWAYS stuck). The shaft split and had a spiral break both times. |
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383481)
so just pull straight out, no twisting? |
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383481)
so just pull straight out, no twisting? Inserting the dipstick is the same idea. I let it twist how it wants to as I insert it. This technique impart the least stress on the poor thing. I have a few posts on the dipstick including finding the cheapest replacement. Here is one about the bends of the steel tube. My original dipstick shows no sign of departing yet. The o-rings are a little tired. https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.nor...fb50bf217c.jpg |
Originally Posted by HaltCatchFire
(Post 4383535)
Might (?) help prolong the life. I would also wear cotton gloves and play soothing music to be safe - I gave up trying to figure them out.
|
Originally Posted by pnwR53S
(Post 4383537)
I still have the original dipstick. My technique is first twist the handle CW and CCW 15 degrees or so to break the bond between the o-rings and the steel tube. Then I pull it out and twist the same if necessary. As I pull the dipstick out I pay attention how the dipstick want to twist and let it twist as the tip (with a square cross section) negotiates the two severe bends of the steel tube. It has to twist as it negotiates the bends as the tip has a square cross section.
Inserting the dipstick is the same idea. I let it twist how it wants to as I insert it. This technique impart the least stress on the poor thing. I have a few posts on the dipstick including finding the cheapest replacement. Here is one about the bends of the steel tube. My original dipstick shows no sign of departing yet. The o-rings are a little tired. https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.nor...fb50bf217c.jpg |
I use the Craven too - I heard it adds 5 hp as well. :)
|
Originally Posted by pepperwhitejcw
(Post 4383480)
nope. |
I actually accidentally broke mine where the flat spot of the finger pull meets the capping disc.
Just put a large washer with a snap ring bellow the capping disc to be able to pull it out.... I can rig most anything if I put my mind to it.... |
The dipstick on my 2006 MCS lasted a long time but finally broke. My technique for removing it or putting it in was to let it turn however it wanted to. I didn't (don't) hold the handle tight in a fixed position, but allow the stick to rotate (almost as if it where screwing in or out as need be by what ever it is hitting internally.)
The only thing that saved me is that I always examen the stick. I found it was broke, but the outer rubber part held it together enough for me to get it out and not have it break off. |
www.partsgeek.com has these for around $15-$18 dollars. Ordered one - I'll let you know if it lasts.
|
| All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:08 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands