R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006) Cooper (R50) and Cooper S (R53) hatchback discussion.

R50/53 i've gone from a MINI to an AUDI TT, some one week comparisons

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 11:16 AM
  #76  
Dr Obnxs's Avatar
Dr Obnxs
Former Vendor
iTrader: (7)
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 10,340
Likes: 5
From: Woodside, CA
Have you ever heard this saying about Audis?

For the first 6 months, it's a Porsche....
The rest of the time, it's a VW!

Someone told me that when I was beating the snot out of my Moms Audi 4000....

Matt
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 12:11 PM
  #77  
RenaultF1's Avatar
RenaultF1
4th Gear
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 313
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by Dr Obnxs
For the first 6 months, it's a Porsche....
The rest of the time, it's a VW!

Someone told me that when I was beating the snot out of my Moms Audi 4000....

Matt
OMG...that is classic!!!
I had an A4 2.8Q prior to my MCS and that pretty much sums it up.

I thought Flav said in another thread that his TT wasn't Quattro. Flav, is it Quattro?
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 12:50 PM
  #78  
sprp85's Avatar
sprp85
6th Gear
iTrader: (4)
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,774
Likes: 1
From: Ecity.MD
i think non-quattro audi isn't real audi and it is a vw with stretched, twisted badge.
don't flame me. but that's just what I think..!!! :impatient
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 12:50 PM
  #79  
Porco Rosso's Avatar
Porco Rosso
2nd Gear
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 142
Likes: 0
From: Austin, TX, USA
Nice comparison, flav. Some paragraph breaks would make it easier on the eyes, but the content is much appreciated. I'm surprised you didn't include the 6-speed Getrag of your old MCS in your comparison of the shifting, though. That's probably a more fair comparison to the TT's 6-speed than the MC's 5-speed.

Originally Posted by kenchan
is it like the porsche suv ?
You mean the gussied-up Touareg? Aka the upcoming Audi Q7?

3 marques, 3 models, same SUV platform. This is sort of thing that makes me worry about VW...it's that "Let's swap a few body panels on the Expedition and call it a Lincoln Navigator" mentality that is becoming all too common in the auto marketplace. The mark of a brand that has lost its sense of distinctiveness. There are positive notes, too (e.g. the new GTI), but I do worry about them. They've seemed a bit rudderless lately, and I hope they get it together.

The TT's a fine car, though, and one of their more encouragingly distinctive models. I prefer the MINI, but when I test-drove the TT it was undoubtedly a fun automobile.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 12:58 PM
  #80  
flav's Avatar
flav
Thread Starter
|
5th Gear
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 661
Likes: 0
no quattro. would have been nice but i got this TT for a really nice price and it didnt happen to have it. $16500 for a 2002 all options with 50,000 miles. had it checked by 2 audi dealerships and they said it was 100% perfect. ran a carcheck and carfax. came up perfect with nothing wrong at all. was a lease i guess. not a scratch on the entire car inside and out. no quatrro is no big deal. hondas and toyotas bla bla bla make it just fine through bad weather with front wheel drive. ive been driving in rain and snow all my life. i am pretty skilled at it. and im not tracking the car. as long as the TT is not like my 350Z, rear wheel 287 HP, 275 torque. the Z was not a very good all season car. in fact it would lose some grip even in the chilly rain, but thats to be expected. but the TT will be great with some decent tires. plus the cars is lighter with the FWD setup than the quattro by 200-300 lbs and gets slight better gas milage. but yes, the quattro would have been a nice extra.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 12:59 PM
  #81  
flav's Avatar
flav
Thread Starter
|
5th Gear
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 661
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by sprp85
i think non-quattro audi isn't real audi and it is a vw with stretched, twisted badge.
don't flame me. but that's just what I think..!!! :impatient

4 wheel drive has nothing to do with it being an audi or VW. the VWs have 4motion.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 01:50 PM
  #82  
lurch70's Avatar
lurch70
6th Gear
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 1,646
Likes: 1
From: Queens, NY
the front cabin space feels about the same as far as room to the MINI. the roofline is abit lower.
maybe if you're 5'5"
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 02:08 PM
  #83  
RenaultF1's Avatar
RenaultF1
4th Gear
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 313
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by sprp85
i think non-quattro audi isn't real audi and it is a vw with stretched, twisted badge.
don't flame me. but that's just what I think..!!! :impatient
I definitely wasn't saying non-quattro wasn't a real Audi...I was asking a totally separate question from my laughter at Doc's post but didn't want to post a second post.

Flav...I'm glad you're happy with the TT. That's all that counts!
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 02:14 PM
  #84  
eVal's Avatar
eVal
6th Gear
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 3,802
Likes: 0
From: SF Bay Area
Maybe its the time of year, but I get a uneasy feeling everytime I get an email from this thread - it looks like AUDITT
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 02:18 PM
  #85  
flav's Avatar
flav
Thread Starter
|
5th Gear
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 661
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by eVal
Maybe its the time of year, but I get a uneasy feeling everytime I get an email from this thread - it looks like AUDITT
hahahahahaha
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 02:22 PM
  #86  
resmini's Avatar
resmini
6th Gear
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,526
Likes: 1
Originally Posted by flav
thank you matt.

AND TO THE MODERATORS ANY MODERATOR, PLEASE MOVE THIS THREAD BACK TO THE MAIN TOPIC PAGE!!! IT DESERVES TO BE THERE. I AM A LEGIT FORMER MINI OWNER, NOT A TROLL. MY FAIR COMPARISON DOES NOT DESERVE TO BE TUCKED AWAY IN THIS LITTLE CORNER OF THE FORUMS LIKE IT HAS BEEN!! NOW I ASK OUT OF RESPECT PLEASE MOVE IT BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I doubt that yelling is a good way to ask for something from the moderators.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 02:40 PM
  #87  
LombardStreet's Avatar
LombardStreet
Moderator
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 941
Likes: 4
Interesting thread...

My brother has a 3.2 TT with the "steptronic" (or whatever Audi calls it) tranny. I only drove it once, but I was very impressed. It was raining lightly, so I didn't push it very hard, but I would say the brakes and cornering felt very good. Felt very strong accelerating. Much smoother riding than the MINI. (But what car isn't?) Great looking car, and I liked the the interior with the circles and dimples motif, even though it felt a bit spartan. One thing I didn't like (especially compared to the MINI) is the kind of claustrophobic feeling. It's pretty dark in there.

I think each car has a particular personality and appeals to a particular sort of driver. I think the TT is a wonderful car and I really enjoyed driving it. But I would never choose it over the MINI, even if it were priced the same. The TT has a sort of "cool" about it, but I prefer the "fun" of the MINI.

Just my $.02, of course...

There's really only one car that I look at nowadays with lust - the Lotus Elise. But it would have to be a second car. (My MINI is my daily driver.) I can't imagine driving an Elise every day. I'm not even sure I would be able to get in and out of one without some help from my chiropractor!
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 02:55 PM
  #88  
gr8britwjh's Avatar
gr8britwjh
4th Gear
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 456
Likes: 0
From: Rochester, NY
Originally Posted by MyPocketRocket
nah..just thinking. It's a great car indeed. I can't let go the S4, but talking my wife to take it so I can go with the Subie!..hehehe
Sorry, but the new STi is just outright fugly; I'd take the Evo IX anyday (and almost did, but cancelled my order for a JCW-MCS).
I've also got a modded B5 S4 which I thought I'd never part with......but the luv is sadly waning and I'll be shot of it in a month, or so.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 04:48 PM
  #89  
kenchan's Avatar
kenchan
6th Gear
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 31,439
Likes: 4
flav- no quattro? my first reason to get any Audi is for its quattro...
especially if coming from a car like our MCS.

Did you just get tired of the hatch? was it the price or your
car loan that made your decision?




Originally Posted by flav
no quattro. would have been nice but i got this TT for a really nice price and it didnt happen to have it. $16500 for a 2002 all options with 50,000 miles. had it checked by 2 audi dealerships and they said it was 100% perfect. ran a carcheck and carfax. came up perfect with nothing wrong at all. was a lease i guess. not a scratch on the entire car inside and out. no quatrro is no big deal. hondas and toyotas bla bla bla make it just fine through bad weather with front wheel drive. ive been driving in rain and snow all my life. i am pretty skilled at it. and im not tracking the car. as long as the TT is not like my 350Z, rear wheel 287 HP, 275 torque. the Z was not a very good all season car. in fact it would lose some grip even in the chilly rain, but thats to be expected. but the TT will be great with some decent tires. plus the cars is lighter with the FWD setup than the quattro by 200-300 lbs and gets slight better gas milage. but yes, the quattro would have been a nice extra.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 05:09 PM
  #90  
flav's Avatar
flav
Thread Starter
|
5th Gear
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 661
Likes: 0
i like to switch cars every now and then. get bored. never owned a TT so i got one. a quattro would have cost me a few $1000 more. didnt need it. it would have been nice but its not something i needed at all. not worth the extra $$$ to me at this point. the TT i got was in such great condition and complety trouble free (rare i heard for a TT) that quattro took a back seat to quality. looking at the car inside and out its hard to tell anybody ever drove it. and like i said im a great all season driver (snow belt all my life) and im not planning on tracking the car.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 05:37 PM
  #91  
XAlfa's Avatar
XAlfa
Banned
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 2,399
Likes: 0
From: Berkeley, CA
Originally Posted by LombardStreet
I can't imagine driving an Elise every day.
Man, you don't have much of an imagination. If I didn't need to haul kids and windsurfing gear (and had $40k to drop), I'd be all over an Elise. I'm on JCW suspension with an H-Sport comp bar and 18s, and I still want to keep cranking down my MINI. I do 80 miles a day, five days a week.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 06:13 PM
  #92  
Al Cheatham's Avatar
Al Cheatham
1st Gear
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 16
Likes: 0
From: Lewisburg, TN - Just south of Nashville
Good comparison

Flav,

I for one appreciate the comparison of the TT to the Mini. I am on my second Mini, and I love it. My first Mini was the Cooper. The one I have now is the Cooper S. Big difference! I have owned nothing but sports cars during by life. I am 61 years young, and have owned, MGB's, Porsche's, Fiat's, VW's and many other cars, but this Cooper S is the best handling of the bunch and the most fun to drive.
 
Reply
Old Mar 2, 2006 | 09:50 PM
  #93  
Dr Obnxs's Avatar
Dr Obnxs
Former Vendor
iTrader: (7)
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 10,340
Likes: 5
From: Woodside, CA
Check out eBay...

Originally Posted by XAlfa
Man, you don't have much of an imagination. If I didn't need to haul kids and windsurfing gear (and had $40k to drop), I'd be all over an Elise. I'm on JCW suspension with an H-Sport comp bar and 18s, and I still want to keep cranking down my MINI. I do 80 miles a day, five days a week.
There are some Elises whith Buy-it-now prices of just over $30k!

So, new JCW or slightly used Elise.....

Matt
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 10:46 AM
  #94  
SilverRocket's Avatar
SilverRocket
4th Gear
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 319
Likes: 0
From: Cincinnati, OH
Originally Posted by kenchan
^^ +1 it does look good. is this the same platform as the latest GTI's?
The shooting brake concept? If so that's what I've read/heard so far, it's built on the current Mk V two door Golf platform just like the last gen of TT was built on the Mk IV Golf.

I was surprised at how fun the TT quattro coupes (which use the exact same rear differential as the 4motion in the R32 w/ slightly different programming ) are, especially the VR6 s line (which is essentially an R32 w/ different weight distribution, styling, +$12K ish MSRP, and less of a back seat). The more balanced weight distribution and lower roofline really offset the extra 100 lbs. or so the TTs gain over their closest VW counterparts, but you do wind up losing alot of practicality as a daily driver for this. Like every production Audi I've driven, they are definitely built to be smooth, but are perfectly competent in the twisties despite their weight and softish dampers/springs once you get used to it, IMHO. It's also not that difficult to slap the coilover set of your choice in one if the ride is too soft for you. It's not unreasonable to expect to bring the 180hp 1.8T up to 220hp with an ECU remap, intake, exhaust, and other minor mods. Start swapping turbos, ICs and fuel systems and you can get these to almost 300 hp or beyond (although reliabilty will suffer the crazier you get with the boost).

Flav: Hope you enjoy your new ride, in my estimation they are very cool looking, fun cars to be certain.
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 11:13 AM
  #95  
kenchan's Avatar
kenchan
6th Gear
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 31,439
Likes: 4
nice. i'll have to keep my eye open for it. im due for a new car
next year to replace my commuter. im going to get me something nice
this time.
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 11:35 AM
  #96  
chows4us's Avatar
chows4us
6th Gear
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 15,478
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by LombardStreet
There's really only one car that I look at nowadays with lust - the Lotus Elise. But it would have to be a second car. (My MINI is my daily driver.) I can't imagine driving an Elise every day.
Since I've been looking into that, see http://www.elisetalk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=20339

Looks like some ppl think its OK but major worries are getting hit while parked (no bumpers) and vandalism (I can see it being a big target).
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 11:39 AM
  #97  
chows4us's Avatar
chows4us
6th Gear
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 15,478
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by XAlfa
... I'd be all over an Elise. ...
Be careful for what you dream of. As you get closer to really considering ownership, there looks like major downfalls to buying one (take a look at elisetalk.com). Examples: First year or two out, just as many new production problems as MINIs, No bumpers mean major repair costs, No space at all to go to the store, roof leaks on "all" (and mechanics say thats the way it is), vandalism target, etc.)

In other words, the grass may not be greener over there
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 11:46 AM
  #98  
ScuderiaMini's Avatar
ScuderiaMini
6th Gear
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 4,431
Likes: 0
From: Boerne/SAtown TX
with all the problems i am having with my MINI it is a matter of time going back to VW/Audi scene
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 11:52 AM
  #99  
chows4us's Avatar
chows4us
6th Gear
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 15,478
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by Dr Obnxs
There are some Elises whith Buy-it-now prices of just over $30k!
Interesting but the Elise market for used cars is dropping fast. some people have bought them as being cool only to find they are totally impractical. It would also appear that Lotus has overestimated demand with many 05s sitting their lots ... Even a few exiges sitting in our local dealers lot ...

Not a good car to hold its resale value.
 
Reply
Old Mar 3, 2006 | 03:46 PM
  #100  
SilverRocket's Avatar
SilverRocket
4th Gear
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 319
Likes: 0
From: Cincinnati, OH
Originally Posted by kenchan
cool! how about understeer? AWD's were really not that great when it
comes to cornering tight hairpins. how would you rate tight corners vs
MCS? or even a Evo8 which can do circles around our MCS.

is it preceived quick or actual quick?
Sorry for the double reply, but i didn't see this earlier.

You can get a decent amount of throttle lift oversteer with the Haldex in my opinion. Once you're rotated to the line you want, roll on the throttle hard and you're going straight down that line with a huge smile on your face (if you're like me anyways...) You're not going to be doing huge 4 wheel drifts like an EVO or STi, but you will get enough sideways action at the beginning of throttle off to get the adrenaline pumping nice and hard.

From what I've heard, good trail baking can gain you quite a bit of exit speed in these cars, but I suck at it, and would wind up too hard on the brakes, rotate too much and lose a bunch of speed, and wind up pushing sideway the whole way through the apex and most of the exit in the few autocrosses I did in my R32.

The steering is a bit quicker than the R32 in the TTs I have driven, but in stock form, neither comes close to the MCS in this department for me. One advantge to the weight and the relatively conservative springs and shocks is that you don't skip accross surface imperfections quite as much so they don't require quite as intense levels of concentration as the MCS as the car feels a good bit more stable at speed to me.
 
Reply



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:15 PM.