R50/53 Opinions on Xenon headlights
Originally Posted by jds
Don't mind me...I've just never felt my visability was in any way compromised by standard lighting. I've never thought, "Gee, wish I could see better." I've thought, "Gee I wish my wipers would bo faster" during a downpour or "Gee, I wish I had more traction", but lighting?...it's never registered.
If someone wants Xenons and feels safer with them, go for it...no problem.
(...just please, please keep them out of my eyes!)
If someone wants Xenons and feels safer with them, go for it...no problem.
(...just please, please keep them out of my eyes!)
I spend all most as much time driving in dark conditions as day light,all highway,when I pass or get passed,my lights are shinning down the road further than most,not high in the trees looking for monkeys,but washing the road,the ditches,and they are bright to me,but have never seemed to be an issue for on coming traffic,never been flashed.If I lived in a city,or where there was house lights lining the roads,maybe I would not see a need for them.When I drive my 94 dakota,with regular guy headlights,I feel blind.
It's not about brightness,it's about how they are aimed.
Now a 3rd higher speed on the wipers would help
Get 'em
My night vision sucks so it was a no-brainer for me to get them. I really like how well they illuminate. I also have driving lights , and the combo REALLY lights up empty country roads on a dark night. It's like it is daytime with all of them blasting.
Anyway, I highly recommend the Xenon's...
Anyway, I highly recommend the Xenon's...
Originally Posted by SCA
My night vision sucks so it was a no-brainer for me
I guess this gets at an important issue...I do drive city streets, mostly. Fairly well lit. Even what back roads I do rarely encounter at night are for short periods and there's lots of other vehicals (so even hi-beams are generally out). So for me Xenons wouldn't always demonstrate their full potential.
If the Xenon option (or any option, for that matter) is fulfilling a legitimate purpose for the driver (whether real or imagined), that's great. If it's just for effect...well people can spend their money as they wish.... but I tend to shy away from purely "effects" stuff.
The originator wanted opinions...glad he's getting some!!!
Originally Posted by jds
Yeah, my daughter's night vision is bad, too...I guess I'll be recommending Xenons to her one of these days.
I guess this gets at an important issue...I do drive city streets, mostly. Fairly well lit. Even what back roads I do rarely encounter at night are for short periods and there's lots of other vehicals (so even hi-beams are generally out). So for me Xenons wouldn't always demonstrate their full potential.
If the Xenon option (or any option, for that matter) is fulfilling a legitimate purpose for the driver (whether real or imagined), that's great. If it's just for effect...well people can spend their money as they wish.... but I tend to shy away from purely "effects" stuff.
The originator wanted opinions...glad he's getting some!!!
I guess this gets at an important issue...I do drive city streets, mostly. Fairly well lit. Even what back roads I do rarely encounter at night are for short periods and there's lots of other vehicals (so even hi-beams are generally out). So for me Xenons wouldn't always demonstrate their full potential.
If the Xenon option (or any option, for that matter) is fulfilling a legitimate purpose for the driver (whether real or imagined), that's great. If it's just for effect...well people can spend their money as they wish.... but I tend to shy away from purely "effects" stuff.
The originator wanted opinions...glad he's getting some!!!

I have 'em, and love them. Excellent illumination at night. They are Audi "blue" when first ignited (turned on), then turn white colored after 10 seconds or so. Higher Kalvin bulbs are available for that Audi look, but the replacement bulbs run about $125 each! Here is a popular site for bulbs http://www.hidexpress.com/index.asp?...ATS&Category=5
I've had both types of headlights, (first Cooper had the standard headlights), and I can enthusiastically recommend that you order Xenons. I don't see as well at night, and the Xenons really make a HUGE difference for me.
The new Xenons are so cool-looking! They look Flash Gordon-ish in a fun, retro way! Wanda has the first generation Xenons, and when I buy another MINI, I will definitely want the Xenons again. They are well-worth ordering, either separately, or in a package.
Clover
The new Xenons are so cool-looking! They look Flash Gordon-ish in a fun, retro way! Wanda has the first generation Xenons, and when I buy another MINI, I will definitely want the Xenons again. They are well-worth ordering, either separately, or in a package.
Clover
Originally Posted by JoeDentist
[font=Verdana]I believe that the Xenons have come a long way in the last few years. The days of the blinding purple lights are over. Modern Xenons are a bright white color, and feature self-levelers so they never get into the opposing driver's eyes. They are superior to halogens, but lets face it, they are not $800 better. I bought mine as part of a package that brought the cost in line. I would never have paid $800 for them as a separate option. I own cars with Halogen lights, like my Land Rover, that seem just as good as the Mini with Xenons. Its really a "bling bling thing." More status than reality. More perceived value and snob appeal than reality. Sure, they are better, but $800 better I doubt.[/font]
I'd say the Xenon's are overkill and unnecessary. Besides, new Super Xenon's are bound to come out, giving an even better view of the road and upsetting even more drivers of approaching cars. This would require an upgade to have bragging rights for the latest and greatest headlights. The Halogen lights seem real good to me. It's true the Halogen's don't have the "cool" factor of the Xenon's, so for some the $550 might seem like a bargin.
I do constantly wish I had the auto wipers and auto dipping rear view mirror.....just kidding.
I do constantly wish I had the auto wipers and auto dipping rear view mirror.....just kidding.
resmini, have you ever driven in a MINI with Xenons? It's hard to drive in cars without them once you see the difference. When done right, the sharp cutoff and auto-levelers make them a lot better for other cars. The problem is that in the states, most Xenons are aftermarket on Civics or Integras and aren't done right...I won't even go into the jacked up trucks that have them
On the other hand, I've been blinded by Bimmer-drivers on many occasions! Grrrrrr!
Clover
Originally Posted by kapps
resmini, have you ever driven in a MINI with Xenons? It's hard to drive in cars without them once you see the difference. When done right, the sharp cutoff and auto-levelers make them a lot better for other cars. The problem is that in the states, most Xenons are aftermarket on Civics or Integras and aren't done right...I won't even go into the jacked up trucks that have them 

I know I like the xenons much better then halogens and never will go back if possible.
I have a 2005 cooper s with the xenon lights. I was one of the few options I added to the car. An excellent safety feature. I love them.
I do a lot of early morning and night driving and the illumination is excellent. I would not even give it a second thought if you are going to do a decent amount of night driving. The xenon lights really brighten up the road in front of you.
I do a lot of early morning and night driving and the illumination is excellent. I would not even give it a second thought if you are going to do a decent amount of night driving. The xenon lights really brighten up the road in front of you.
Originally Posted by erik99
Hi,
One part I cannot decide on for my MCS order is the headlights. I am going to add the driving light for the 'bling' factor.
For those who have the Xenons, would you say it is a marked improvement in night time driving? Is it worth the extra $, or do you think it is overkill with the driving lights?
I live in the SE where I do not see much fog. I also do the majority of my driving during the day.
Thanks!
One part I cannot decide on for my MCS order is the headlights. I am going to add the driving light for the 'bling' factor.
For those who have the Xenons, would you say it is a marked improvement in night time driving? Is it worth the extra $, or do you think it is overkill with the driving lights?
I live in the SE where I do not see much fog. I also do the majority of my driving during the day.
Thanks!
Originally Posted by kapps
resmini, have you ever driven in a MINI with Xenons? It's hard to drive in cars without them once you see the difference. When done right, the sharp cutoff and auto-levelers make them a lot better for other cars. The problem is that in the states, most Xenons are aftermarket on Civics or Integras and aren't done right...I won't even go into the jacked up trucks that have them 

Having retired from a nuclear power plant the word Xenon brings back bad memories. It was a fission product, "poison" that made restarting the reactor after shutdown difficult. Not my friend at the time.
I'm sure Xenon headlights are a lot friendlier.
Originally Posted by iamwiz82
I find it interesting that people have such fervery hatred of Xenons. I have to think that these people are hyper-sensitive to light.
I'm glad that our MINIs come with 4300K HID bulbs and actually appear to be clean white when viewed by oncoming traffic, rather than the "Bling Bling Blue" cast that BMW models seem to have. I hope this has not changed with the advent of the '05 HID projector design. I ordered HID lamps because I want to see better, not because I wanted to be seen.
On a personal note, my grandfather has expressed extreme dislike for HIDs in general. He recognized several years ago the his night vision is nowhere near what it used to be, and he now limits his driving to daylight hours to avoid problems. What's interesting to me about my grandfather's case is that although he is not at all shy about expressing his opinion of HIDs, but he has never commented on the lights on my MINI. Honestly, I suspect he hasn't noticed that they are HIDs, or I'm sure he would have asked me what I could possibly have been thinking when I got them...
Originally Posted by MSFITOY
The highbeams are not Xenons because they require instant on-off ability. Xenons need to warm up and their life span is limited by the frequency of cycling on and off.
Bob
Second thoughts on Xenons
I have them and don't know if I'd get them again. I love the color temp (sorry, I'm a Physicist nerd) but I don't like the lack of scatter. So while the field of vies is very bright, the off-areas are very, very dark. I've also noticed that the reflector design in many cars, not sure about the mini, has a rather high beam coming off to the side a bit. A lot of Xenons bother me most not when they're directly benhind me, but when they're one lane over!
I don't know what they cost as an add on, but I think the modern halogens are pretty bright. You can always go to a bulb with more power too! So in the cost per lumen, I'm not that happy.
But the color balance is really, really good.
Matt
I don't know what they cost as an add on, but I think the modern halogens are pretty bright. You can always go to a bulb with more power too! So in the cost per lumen, I'm not that happy.
But the color balance is really, really good.
Matt
The xenons saw some deer tonight,that decided to move onto the road tonight.Now I was not going to fast,40mph,but seeing them helped me slow,and let them cross the road.
It is not just the brightness,but these xenons have great spread from side to side
It is not just the brightness,but these xenons have great spread from side to side
Originally Posted by Dr Obnxs
I have them and don't know if I'd get them again. I love the color temp (sorry, I'm a Physicist nerd) but I don't like the lack of scatter. So while the field of vies is very bright, the off-areas are very, very dark. I've also noticed that the reflector design in many cars, not sure about the mini, has a rather high beam coming off to the side a bit. A lot of Xenons bother me most not when they're directly benhind me, but when they're one lane over!
I don't know what they cost as an add on, but I think the modern halogens are pretty bright. You can always go to a bulb with more power too! So in the cost per lumen, I'm not that happy.
But the color balance is really, really good.
Matt
I don't know what they cost as an add on, but I think the modern halogens are pretty bright. You can always go to a bulb with more power too! So in the cost per lumen, I'm not that happy.
But the color balance is really, really good.
Matt
Originally Posted by Bob ///Margolis
That can't be right. Many cars, including BMW's come with Xenon hi and low beams. BMW calls them bi-xenon.
Bob
Bob
Some prototype "HID-only" headlamp designs I have seen work by moving a sliding masking sleeve over a portion of the bulb to block the "high-beam" output, thus achieving the same effect as the offset filaments in an incandescent dual-filament bulb. Other proposed designs actually shift the bulb in relation to the reflector inside the projector assembly. The added mechanical complexity required to do this is expensive, and is a lot more easily rolled into the price of a BMW 745Li than it could be into the MSRP of a MINI.
Hella makes HID auxilliary lamps available in a size that would fit the MINI, but as much as I would like to get them, I have to admit that they are not very practical, especially for the cost. I have to dip the brights far too often during my night driving to do anything but quickly ruin a set of HID aux bulbs.



