JCW GP Disappointing
#1
#2
Originally Posted by XAlfa
Looks like no surprises out of Geneva. Only 218hp and 110lbs lighter. At 230hp/-200lbs (and at least a minimal rear seat), I would have been very interested. Being able to delete AC and DSC is nice, but... no cigar.
IMHO, come Jan, 2006, say in 11 months, many will be sitting in lots, unsold.
#3
#6
#7
OVERDRIVE
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Bowie, MD
Posts: 9,390
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Trending Topics
#8
#9
#12
Originally Posted by gr8britwjh
It must be an age thing, but I think it's grotesquely "riced-out" (no racial offense meant with the descriptor). It could have been so much better...
I think the wing is nice.....Or if you don't like the looks....At least it is truly functional unlike those piece of crap hondas sporting a 3ft indy wing
BUT..... The arches should either be painted to match the bumpers and skirts OR the black trim should extend to the bumpers and skirts like on the original AERO kit. It makes it look like an amateur body kit add-on thant dont belong.
Secondly, 8hp and is all they could find?.....Not Impressed! 110lbs is not a bad weight drop but I can yank my rear seat out and drop 40lbs for free!
#13
#14
I like it!
I have no idea why this car seems to get such bad reactions. I, for one, love it, and wish I was in a position to buy one. A factory 218 bhp MINI? Wicked.
Check out the video just released: http://motoringfile.com/2006/02/22/j...video-footage/
Gotta love that supercharger whine!!!
And by the way, yes, I do love the wheels, seriously. Most Miniacs seem to hate them. So if you buy one, and decide to take those wheels off, let me know, you might have someone to buy them off you!
Check out the video just released: http://motoringfile.com/2006/02/22/j...video-footage/
Gotta love that supercharger whine!!!
And by the way, yes, I do love the wheels, seriously. Most Miniacs seem to hate them. So if you buy one, and decide to take those wheels off, let me know, you might have someone to buy them off you!
#15
I wouldn't spend this much money on a mini anyway, but I mainly just wish they'd spent more effort integrating the sideskirts and front bumper with the fender flares - or at very least painted everything on the car.
As it is, it looks like a cheap aftermarket bodykit. I like the looks of the front bumper, but shots like this just make you wonder why that one (two) strip of molding over the front wheel is black...
As it is, it looks like a cheap aftermarket bodykit. I like the looks of the front bumper, but shots like this just make you wonder why that one (two) strip of molding over the front wheel is black...
#16
Originally Posted by JeffS
I wouldn't spend this much money on a mini anyway, but I mainly just wish they'd spent more effort integrating the sideskirts and front bumper with the fender flares - or at very least painted everything on the car.
As it is, it looks like a cheap aftermarket bodykit. I like the looks of the front bumper, but shots like this just make you wonder why that one (two) strip of molding over the front wheel is black...
As it is, it looks like a cheap aftermarket bodykit. I like the looks of the front bumper, but shots like this just make you wonder why that one (two) strip of molding over the front wheel is black...
Originally Posted by planeguy
I agree
I think the wing is nice.....Or if you don't like the looks....At least it is truly functional unlike those piece of crap hondas sporting a 3ft indy wing
BUT..... The arches should either be painted to match the bumpers and skirts OR the black trim should extend to the bumpers and skirts like on the original AERO kit. It makes it look like an amateur body kit add-on thant dont belong.
Secondly, 8hp and is all they could find?.....Not Impressed! 110lbs is not a bad weight drop but I can yank my rear seat out and drop 40lbs for free!
I think the wing is nice.....Or if you don't like the looks....At least it is truly functional unlike those piece of crap hondas sporting a 3ft indy wing
BUT..... The arches should either be painted to match the bumpers and skirts OR the black trim should extend to the bumpers and skirts like on the original AERO kit. It makes it look like an amateur body kit add-on thant dont belong.
Secondly, 8hp and is all they could find?.....Not Impressed! 110lbs is not a bad weight drop but I can yank my rear seat out and drop 40lbs for free!
#17
Originally Posted by JeffS
I wouldn't spend this much money on a mini anyway, but I mainly just wish they'd spent more effort integrating the sideskirts and front bumper with the fender flares - or at very least painted everything on the car.
As it is, it looks like a cheap aftermarket bodykit. I like the looks of the front bumper, but shots like this just make you wonder why that one (two) strip of molding over the front wheel is black...
As it is, it looks like a cheap aftermarket bodykit. I like the looks of the front bumper, but shots like this just make you wonder why that one (two) strip of molding over the front wheel is black...
Have to agree this doesn't have the look of a well thought out aero kit, regardless of whether it is or isn't. I like the sound of the thing, but not enough to overcome the look. Seems completely disjointed as if it were a designed by a commitee (of Bangles).
#18
#19
Originally Posted by jonnieoh
I have no idea why this car seems to get such bad reactions. I, for one, love it, and wish I was in a position to buy one. A factory 218 bhp MINI? Wicked.
Check out the video just released: http://motoringfile.com/2006/02/22/j...video-footage/
Gotta love that supercharger whine!!!
Check out the video just released: http://motoringfile.com/2006/02/22/j...video-footage/
Gotta love that supercharger whine!!!
Wait until Jan, 07. You will get one for a discount at your local dealer.
Caveat: Of course, this is just another opinion. Your mileage may vary.
#21
4th Gear
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Alameda, CA
Posts: 448
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by ZAMIRZ
Hopefully there will be a bunch of them sitting around unsold with huge discounts soon, that way I'll trade my car in for one, fit standard aerokit sideskirts, paint the arches and mirror caps and have a decent looking MINI.
#23
Originally Posted by gr8britwjh
Sorry, but on the track or off the track (unless you're a professional driver, which I'm guessing you're not), you're not going to feel much of a performance difference between the GP and a similarly equipped MCS-JCW; sad, but true.
#24
4th Gear
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Alameda, CA
Posts: 448
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
remember how many people were so happy that they ditch the heavy stock rims, well that plus many more pounds. because of numerous posts of that, i'm sure many people will notice the 100lbs less and especially when tossing the car around. and i'm sorry, i never said i was a prof race car driver (i don't recall ever saying or implying that, but i wished i was back when i was 5 years old though ).
#25
I like the paint color... Thunder Blue is it called?
About the red accents, I feel either do it or dont do it, meaning there is not enough red accent color elswhere on the outside to warrant red mirrors- they just look cobbled on to me. If they made some other bits red on the outside, I'd understand it more.
Ditto on the aerokit/black arches thing, but I think they're skittish on doing oem body colored arches so they dont open a factory 'Pandora's Box', meaning people will start asking for color coded arches on regular MCS's... just a gut feeling.
All in all they should have combined this performance with the MC40 looks IMO!
About the red accents, I feel either do it or dont do it, meaning there is not enough red accent color elswhere on the outside to warrant red mirrors- they just look cobbled on to me. If they made some other bits red on the outside, I'd understand it more.
Ditto on the aerokit/black arches thing, but I think they're skittish on doing oem body colored arches so they dont open a factory 'Pandora's Box', meaning people will start asking for color coded arches on regular MCS's... just a gut feeling.
All in all they should have combined this performance with the MC40 looks IMO!