North American Motoring

North American Motoring (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/)
-   Drivetrain (Cooper S) (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/drivetrain-cooper-s-191/)
-   -   Drivetrain Just got the manic tune, what's next? (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/drivetrain-cooper-s/286759-just-got-the-manic-tune-whats-next.html)

JMC1 Apr 18, 2015 12:54 PM

Just got the manic tune, what's next?
 
I have a bone stock 2010 N14 R57. I got the manic stage 1 last night, super happy with it. So now I'm thinking about what's next. Should I get rid of the second cat,get a new intake or start saving for an intercooler?

Ovrclck Apr 18, 2015 01:36 PM

Second cat and intercooler. If anything, intercooler to start with.

johnso56 Apr 19, 2015 10:07 AM

But is it true that if u add any mod to your tuned car, u need to send the car back to remap it, so that the remap can take advantage of ur mods?

johntotah94 Apr 19, 2015 10:16 AM

downpipe, intercooler. Is the most important.

Then you can do a Stage 2 tune

Joeygonz Apr 19, 2015 10:38 AM

Doesn't a stage 2 require a CAI too? And $50 more for the tune?

JMC1 Apr 19, 2015 05:08 PM


Originally Posted by johnso56 (Post 4071091)
But is it true that if u add any mod to your tuned car, u need to send the car back to remap it, so that the remap can take advantage of ur mods?

I hope not..

johnso56 Apr 19, 2015 07:43 PM

that's what I heard from my local manic mini dealer, he said having your mini tune should be your very last thing to do

Minnie.the.Moocher Apr 19, 2015 08:54 PM

Maybe drive it for more than a day before lusting for more? Is that even possible with you Manic tuned folks? :lol:

velvetcows Apr 19, 2015 11:55 PM


Originally Posted by johnso56 (Post 4071091)
But is it true that if u add any mod to your tuned car, u need to send the car back to remap it, so that the remap can take advantage of ur mods?

To fully "take advantage" of a mod, a tune is required. Exhaust, intake, and intercooler can be done one at a time,
then get a tune once all three are done.

JMC1 Apr 20, 2015 05:02 AM

I guess it's no big thing, I'll just go with an intercooler and a downpipe. Because my tune would now be obsolete I'll be forced to get the stage 2.
Is that how it works, or would I need to have the stage 1 done over, then a 2?

countrymanman Apr 20, 2015 05:43 AM


Originally Posted by johnso56 (Post 4071091)
But is it true that if u add any mod to your tuned car, u need to send the car back to remap it, so that the remap can take advantage of ur mods?

Not entirely true. What is true is that in order to get the most out of any mod, you will need to tune for it. This does not mean he can't work on stage two supporting mods while running stage 1.

countrymanman Apr 20, 2015 05:44 AM


Originally Posted by Minnie.the.Moocher (Post 4071277)
Maybe drive it for more than a day before lusting for more? Is that even possible with you Manic tuned folks? :lol:

Drive a car with a manic tune and you tell me...

johntotah94 Apr 20, 2015 09:50 AM


Originally Posted by JMC1 (Post 4071336)
I guess it's no big thing, I'll just go with an intercooler and a downpipe. Because my tune would now be obsolete I'll be forced to get the stage 2.
Is that how it works, or would I need to have the stage 1 done over, then a 2?

You don't need to do any tuning done unless you choose to. Tuning is just to get the most power out of your mods. I had an intake, exhaust, downpipe, and intercooler done with absolutely no tuning. Drove on it for about a year until I got a stage 2 tune. No need to update your tune unless you want to squeeze the most power out. I am on stage 3 and I occasionally run my stock map for kicks. Doesn't hurt the car at all.

JMC1 Apr 20, 2015 10:19 AM


Originally Posted by johntotah94 (Post 4071095)
downpipe, intercooler. Is the most important.

Then you can do a Stage 2 tune


Originally Posted by johntotah94 (Post 4071457)
You don't need to do any tuning done unless you choose to. Tuning is just to get the most power out of your mods. I had an intake, exhaust, downpipe, and intercooler done with absolutely no tuning. Drove on it for about a year until I got a stage 2 tune. No need to update your tune unless you want to squeeze the most power out. I am on stage 3 and I occasionally run my stock map for kicks. Doesn't hurt the car at all.

I like the downpipe and IC being my next mods. Problem is I'm scared of the downpipe. I have no wish for a loud car. I was thinking I'd get rid of the second cat and that would be about as much noise as I could handle, that and I could get it done without spending too much.
What would be better, downpipe and keep the second cat or get rid of the cat and skip the downpipe. I'd love to do them both but the noise is a BIG concern.

johntotah94 Apr 20, 2015 10:21 AM


Originally Posted by JMC1 (Post 4071466)
I like the downpipe and IC being my next mods. Problem is I'm scared of the downpipe. I have no wish for a loud car. I was thinking I'd get rid of the second cat and that would be about as much noise as I could handle, that and I could get it done without spending too much.
What would be better, downpipe and keep the second cat or get rid of the cat and skip the downpipe. I'd love to do them both but the noise is a BIG concern.

You can do a high flow catted downpipe and delete the second cat.

JMC1 Apr 20, 2015 12:16 PM


Originally Posted by johntotah94 (Post 4071467)
You can do a high flow catted downpipe and delete the second cat.

Can anyone recommend a catted downpipe that won't brake the bank.
Also, how much power am I giving away going this route?

johntotah94 Apr 22, 2015 12:51 PM

I think CNT has a catless downpipe with a resonator on it. I've never tried it though.

Systemlord Apr 26, 2015 12:02 AM


Originally Posted by JMC1 (Post 4071532)
Can anyone recommend a catted downpipe that won't brake the bank.
Also, how much power am I giving away going this route?

Any reason why you don't just want a downpipe? A non-catted downpipe would be better than a catted downpipe, turbos don't like any type of restriction which adds to the heat collected at the turbo/downpipe. Get that heat away from the turbo/engine, cats cause heat soak that heats up you turbo/engine! Here's what you ask about, Evolve Sport Cat is a 200 Cel ($687), gives better flow than the stock 400 Cel cat. Don't know about the increase in HP and torque but I will tell you you'll get quicker spool. Keep you resonator though and delete your second cat.

cerenkov Apr 26, 2015 04:56 AM


Originally Posted by Systemlord (Post 4074035)
Any reason why you don't just want a downpipe? A non-catted downpipe would be better than a catted downpipe, turbos don't like any type of restriction which adds to the heat collected at the turbo/downpipe. Get that heat away from the turbo/engine, cats cause heat soak that heats up you turbo/engine! Here's what you ask about, Evolve Sport Cat is a 200 Cel ($687), gives better flow than the stock 400 Cel cat. Don't know about the increase in HP and torque but I will tell you you'll get quicker spool. Keep you resonator though and delete your second cat.

He stated that noise was a concern with the catless DP.

For JMC1:

I've tried both. I really wanted to like the non-catted dp but it was much too loud for me. I was hesitant to go wide open throttle because of the noise. So I installed the 100 cel dp from Akrapovic (you can find used ones on the Marketplace). The noise is still louder than stock but FWIW I did have a 70 year old co-worker who drives a Nissan Leaf tell me that my car sounds fantastic when he was driving behind me one day. I've actually never heard my car from the outside.

JMC1 Apr 27, 2015 05:45 AM


Originally Posted by cerenkov (Post 4074056)

So I installed the 100 cel dp from Akrapovic

I’ve heard I may have trouble passing emissions test going with a catted DP and second cat delete.
Thoughts?

Grizld700 Apr 27, 2015 07:00 AM


Originally Posted by JMC1 (Post 4074369)
I’ve heard I may have trouble passing emissions test going with a catted DP and second cat delete.
Thoughts?

Don't worry about 2nd Cat as its not monitored and has no effect up stream. However, you will not pass emissions with a catless DP. Even with a high flow cat you may fail an emmision test. It all depends on what kind of test Texas does. If its just a OBDII scan test, a proper tune should let you pass that. However, if they go further (like CA does) and do what they call a "sniffer" test, you will fail with anything other than an OEM Cat. (or equivalent replacement).

So if you decide to go with any higher flow cat. be aware of that. You can swap the cats out for testing and back again after, but most people don't want that hassel. Me, I wouldn't care, I can swap them out pretty quick now as I've done it 3 times now. (in, out, in).

JMC1 Apr 27, 2015 07:32 AM


Originally Posted by Grizld700 (Post 4074422)
You can swap the cats out for testing and back again after, but most people don't want that hassel.

That does not sound like a good time for me. I'm heading over to a muffler shop at lunch to have the 2ed cat and resonator removed.

I need to think about what I want to do about a DP..

Systemlord Apr 27, 2015 12:06 PM


Originally Posted by JMC1 (Post 4074369)
I’ve heard I may have trouble passing emissions test going with a catted DP and second cat delete.
Thoughts?

Install both your catts and have the smog test, go home and re-install your cattless downpipe and remove your second catt. That's the only way, hoped you didn't throw away any of your stock catts!

cerenkov Apr 27, 2015 03:24 PM

The second cat is not needed for sniffer tests in mosts states. It is there to help with fleet emissions. Depending on the state, some people here have passed a sniffer test with a high flow cat DP. A tune can bypass around the OBD2 port tests.

As report by fellow members the Manic tune will pass the OBD2 portion in Texas for people running a catless DP, do they do a sniffer test there?

Before you do buy anything, verify with a fellow member in your state.

poolguyinaz Apr 30, 2015 06:28 PM

you can do the first stage tune with just intake and exhaust, stage 2 you need the DP, here in AZ we don't have any issue with smog, stage 2+ you need the FMIC and stage 3 you need bigger turbo and then water meth.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:17 AM.


© 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands