North American Motoring

North American Motoring (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/)
-   Cooper (non S) (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/cooper-non-s-190/)
-   -   Best resonator to silence modified exhaust (https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/cooper-non-s/326790-best-resonator-to-silence-modified-exhaust.html)

miniuy 04-30-2018 01:00 PM

Best resonator to silence modified exhaust
 
Currently I'm running without the OEM resonator nor the OEM muffler.
I replaced the OEM resonator with the Vibrant UltraQuiet.
I replaced the mufler with a (very short) glasspack muffler
No drone at all.
I was happy with the sound but when I travel many kilometers on the highway, over 2500 RPM, I listen to the exhaust instead of the music.
It's a nice sound, but the volume is too loud after 2 years with this configuraion...

What is the best brand resonator that I can install (2 inch) to get my MINI quiet again?

I intend not to install a muffler, just a good quality resonator.
Any advice will be very appreciated

PS: It is a Mini Cooper Base

jcwcoopster 05-01-2018 04:47 AM


Originally Posted by miniuy (Post 4386719)
Currently I'm running without the OEM resonator nor the OEM muffler.
I replaced the OEM resonator with the Vibrant UltraQuiet.
I replaced the mufler with a (very short) glasspack muffler
No drone at all.
I was happy with the sound but when I travel many kilometers on the highway, over 2500 RPM, I listen to the exhaust instead of the music.
It's a nice sound, but the volume is too loud after 2 years with this configuraion...

What is the best brand resonator that I can install (2 inch) to get my MINI quiet again?

I intend not to install a muffler, just a good quality resonator.
Any advice will be very appreciated

PS: It is a Mini Cooper Base

Glass Pack muffler not a good idea as it burns out pretty quickly thus giving you no resonance control. I would go with the front muffler that the Mini JCW uses since its a long style muffler and tightly packed with sound resonance material far more and better than any after market solution. The part number is 18308608933. You can check the part number on bmwfansinfo if you want to see it. it installs at the bottom of the downpipe after the first cat.

KCLARK 05-01-2018 12:08 PM

Key to resonators being quieter and drone free is to get them long as possible. I didn't choose vibrant because its too short (9 inch I think) and went with the tubular magnaflow version that was 14 inch. but I don't recall them making them that small in 2 inch size. They only make 2.25, 2.5, and 3 inch diameters.

jcwcoopster 05-02-2018 04:23 AM


Originally Posted by KCLARK (Post 4386994)
Key to resonators being quieter and drone free is to get them long as possible. I didn't choose vibrant because its too short (9 inch I think) and went with the tubular magnaflow version that was 14 inch. but I don't recall them making them that small in 2 inch size. They only make 2.25, 2.5, and 3 inch diameters.

This is why I suggested the one on the JCW exhaust. Its long and tightly packed with resonance material.

miniuy 05-02-2018 08:52 AM


Originally Posted by jcwcoopster (Post 4386859)
Glass Pack muffler not a good idea as it burns out pretty quickly thus giving you no resonance control. I would go with the front muffler that the Mini JCW uses since its a long style muffler and tightly packed with sound resonance material far more and better than any after market solution. The part number is 18308608933. You can check the part number on bmwfansinfo if you want to see it. it installs at the bottom of the downpipe after the first cat.

Thank you for your advice.
I could see the 18308608933 is around $800 plus shipping.
I'm not ready to spend that money on mute the car but I will be checking the 18308608933 resonator specs to find another one similar in quality and cheaper...

miniuy 05-02-2018 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by KCLARK (Post 4386994)
Key to resonators being quieter and drone free is to get them long as possible. I didn't choose vibrant because its too short (9 inch I think) and went with the tubular magnaflow version that was 14 inch. but I don't recall them making them that small in 2 inch size. They only make 2.25, 2.5, and 3 inch diameters.

There is no problem with that.
I think the techs at the exhaust shop could adapt an in/out 2.25'' resonator to my 2'' exhaust...

njaremka 05-02-2018 09:10 AM


Originally Posted by miniuy (Post 4387205)
Thank you for your advice.
I could see the 18308608933 is around $800 plus shipping.
I'm not ready to spend that money on mute the car but I will be checking the 18308608933 resonator specs to find another one similar in quality and cheaper...

um, $581
https://www.ecstuning.com/b-genuine-...w/18308608933/

You could possibly find it cheaper than ECS, too.

jcwcoopster 05-02-2018 01:47 PM


Originally Posted by miniuy (Post 4387205)
Thank you for your advice.
I could see the 18308608933 is around $800 plus shipping.
I'm not ready to spend that money on mute the car but I will be checking the 18308608933 resonator specs to find another one similar in quality and cheaper...

It can be had for less than that. ECS tuning offers it and even cheaper from Mini of Kennesaw. You can even find the JCW exhaust used for $325-$375. You'll be hard pressed to find an aftermarket resonator as well packed with material as the OE one.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 01:34 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands