North American Motoring :: Product and Vendor Reviews - R53 Front Strut Brace

Register

Forgot Password?

Welcome to North American Motoring !

Welcome to North American Motoring,

You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our community, at no cost, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is free, fast and simple, so please join our community today!

Home · Search · Member List · Register

Home » Products » Suspension » Strut and Stress Bars

Ireland Engineering R53 Front Strut Brace

Reviews	Views	Date of last review
1	18098	3/8/2010

Recommended By	Average Price	Average Rating
100% of reviewers	None indicated	8.0

supersize	supersize	supersize

Description:	I've tried another well-known strut bar on my MINI, and found only minimal improvements from it. I've even tried to measure the interaction between the wheels and a strut brace, using a suspension alignment machine, and found no benefit. However, the brace I used had a fault in common with almost all MINI strut braces - it was curved, and thus subject to shortening and lengthening under stresses. The IE brace is one of the few that puts the cross-piece in a straight line, and thus is not subject to compressive forces, unlike all curved bars. It is also aligned across the front of the strut towers, unlike others that cross several inches aft where the firewall already strengthens the tower. As can be seen in the pictures, it braces the free forward end of the tower. It is also close to the point where the Cabrio diagonal braces attach, thus reinforcing both. The bar itself is hollow rectangular-section steel tubing, nicely welded and of fixed length. It is a straight line between the minimal risers, which are attached and triangulated solidly, so it won't be compressing or stretching. The end-pieces are a surprisingly complex design, which might have some claim to torsional rigidity if the towers were to move fore-and-aft or twist relative to each other under strain. These aspects make it unique among MINI bars. The tubing has a long-way slice taken out of it above the MINI intake and ECU cover, which it clears by around 1/8". The slice has flat steel welded edge to edge, and it looks like it has maybe been filled with epoxy for strength? (you can see two filled holes on the top) Because the bar rides low and slopes toward the front, there is no interference with the hood or the under-hood blanket. There is. however, a clearance issue with the oil-filler cap. You can unscrew and slide it out backward from under the bar, but just barely, and you will need a long-neck funnel to add oil without removing the brace. The fixed-length design can make it a bit difficult to install the first time - I had to oval the holes in the brace to fit my `05 S. To compensate for the oval holes, I got some thick (5mm) oversized (22mm instead of the standard 16mm) steel washers to better clamp the bar in place (not shown in pix). How well does it work? Well, it makes the car quieter and feels more solid than the OMP bar did. As to handling, it seems to make a small but definite difference in cornering, particularly on grade changes or sharp hairpins with a drop. I also notice a reduction in impact feel over tar-strips and small cracks - the ride is improved with less thump in the bumps, and the car feeling more resistant to the impacts. I'm pretty sure I could tell if it was installed in a blind test. Overall, if you feel compelled to add a front strut-top brace to your first-gen MINI, this one is well engineered and well-made. It's the best-designed bar I've seen. Will it shave tenths of seconds off your lap times? I remain skeptical. Does it reduce noise and vibration on poorly-maintained roads? Yes, and better than most less-well-designed strut bars. Does it look cool? Yep - it looks like it belongs in a serious engine compartment, not in a glass case.
Keywords:	front strut brace IE Ireland Engineering tower bar
Web site:	http://www.bmw2002.com/

Author

AUSSIECOOPER88
Neutral

Registered: March 2010

Review Date: 3/8/2010

Would you recommend the product? Yes | Price you paid?: None indicated | Rating: 8

Pros:	straight talker
Cons:

Good honest feed-back. Thanks. GK

Click here to Send this user a Private Message

Statistics
Users	111,661
Products	445
Reviews	978
Views	7,717,781

Random Products - Strut and Stress Bars

Pilo Racing Mini Cooper Rear Stress Bar
MiniPilo

WMW TSW X brace R50, R52, R53
WayMotorWorks

Most Viewed
Way Motor Works	112,207
Alta Performance Col...	103,186
Cooper Flags	97,351
Coast to Coast USA	96,953
Burger Motorsports	96,303
Out Motoring MINI Af...	95,391
Cooper Gear	94,099
American Mini Mates	92,941
ALTA MINI Performanc...	91,340
brownflyer	90,802
Coopersport.com	79,686
Aesthetic Creations	78,112
Pilo Racing Mini Coo...	74,436
Whalen Machine	69,124
MINCORSA	66,478
Do It Yourself Hot A...	66,146
Palo Uber Mini	59,610
Helix Minisports Hel...	53,296
DDMWorks R56 Race In...	48,925
DDMWorks R56 Street ...	48,123
Craven Speed	47,491
Palo Uber CARBON FIB...	47,418
AutumnRiders	46,326
Euro Styles East	46,129
Mini Works	46,025