You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our community, at no cost, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is free, fast and simple, so please join our community today!
Drove daughter's 2010 OB MC, manual tranny, sport seats, cold weather package for a couple of days. It has about 4,400 mi. on it. I drove it about 100 miles. My DD is a 2000 Z3 roadster with 96,000 mi. on it. Here's some random thoughts:
1. Great fun. The MC handled at least as good as the Z3.
2. Mileage is awesome! Computer shows 38.6 mpg, mix of city and highway.
3. Steering feels numb on center. Is this related to the electric assist?
4. Shifter feels notchy in fist and second until it's warmed up. Common issue?
5. Intake noise was distracting - I'm used to hearing the exhaust on my Z3, not the intake.
6. Seems like doors take an extra effort to close. Car is very tight, though, no wind noise.
7. Intermittent wipers should be standard (unless I missed something).
Overall a great experience. Am thinking of getting one of my own.
Thanks for listening.
Proud Dad
Last edited by 2manycars; 03-10-2010 at 04:21 PM.
Reason: Update
LOL I thought my wiper fluid nozzles or pump was out...I kept pushin the button and nothing but wiper movement... then I found that you could do the push down and get wipers to work so I am still thinking no wiper washer is working... Finally pulled it towards me on accident and got a windshield full of fluid... Success just not how I expected either
4. Shifter feels notchy in fist and second until it's warmed up. Common issue?
My 2010 MCS has the same issue. When the weather was really cold, the shifter simply did not want to go in 2nd until the car was warm. Now that the weather has warmed up, it's still a bit too notchy. Going to have the service dep't take a look at that.
My shifter used to feel notchy as well when I sat too far back. Once I adjusted my seat to a point where I didn't have to "reach" for it the notchyness went away.
I have an 09 R55 S 6-spd dealer loaner right now. It has about 20K miles on it. Our car is an R57S Auto.
Since I began driving in 1981, all but two of our cars have been manuals. I was looking forward to seeing how this thing feels with the stick.
I'm unimpressed. The shifter has long throws, is notchy, and with that huge knob feels truck-like. I wasn't exactly expecting RX7 or S2000 type shifting, but this thing feels like my early 80s Mustang or a VW Golf.
YMMV. If it were my car I'd swap out the tranny oil, put in a short shifter, and get rid of that F150 shift knob.
I wasn't exactly expecting RX7 or S2000 type shifting, but this thing feels like my early 80s Mustang or a VW Golf.
As someone who currently owns two Mustangs equipped with T5 transmissions (used in Mustangs from the 80's to present), I can say that IMO the MINIs shifter feel is better in virtually every way, especially compared to the stock T5.
Is it the best out there? No... But it's not THAT bad.
__________________ 2009 MINI Cooper : OB/W, R94s (W), Sport Package
FYI, tranny fluid, along with engine oil/filter, was changed at 1200 miles. Shifter feels like it is not quite lining up with the shifting rails (or whatever similar configuration is in the MINI gearbox). Once it's warm there's almost no resistance. Sounds like each car is a little different.
tranny fluid is lifetime in MINI's. Why was it changed at 1200 miles?
__________________
Chris / Laveen, AZ 2010 Dark Silver Cooper S | Black Roof/mirrors | White Signals | Conv Package | Premium Package | Sports Package | Cold Weather Package| DSC | Xenons | Punch Leather Seats| Anthracite Headliner| Piano Black interior Delivery on 5/19
3. Steering feels numb on center. Is this related to the electric assist?
4. Shifter feels notchy in fist and second until it's warmed up. Common issue?
Yes, partially due to the electronic assisted steering, and partially from the soft bushings that robin casady mentions.
I have no problems with the shifter being notchy in my car, smooth as butter. But, I can tell a difference between when the trannys cold and when its been warmed up....but most cars are like that.
__________________ 2006 MINI Cooper S JCW GP--GP#1599 -Stock...I think?? 2008 MINI Cooper S R56--Astro Black/White--Gone -JCW Turbo | Aquamist HFS-3 Meth injection | RMW AP Tune | Helix FMIC | DDM CAI | Riss Racing Catless DP+Invidia Exhaust
tranny fluid is lifetime in MINI's. Why was it changed at 1200 miles?
The "lifetime fluid" thing is pure BS. Just a way for them to reduce the cost of their "free" maintenance program, and to ensure that their cars don't last too long.
Here's an example of what a travesty these extended oil/fluid changes are: BMW M cars still stick by their older maintenance schedules. My '07 M Coupe called for a 1200 mile service, with a STERN warning in the owner's manual about how critical it is to the life of the car. It includes oil, tranny oil, and even differential oil changes - yes, at 1200 miles. The tranny & diff oil are changed again at every other inspection, starting with Inspection II, which comes along somewhere around 55k-60k miles. Oh yeah, one more M detail - the M cars do NOT use runflat tires, while the rest of the BMW/Mini line is completely infested with them. Why? The engineers don't consider their performance up to par (which it isn't) for an M car.
__________________
'10 MCS "Jethro". All PW, aero kit, carbon black lounge leather, anthracite h/l, Cream White c/l, convenience, cold weather, xenon, rear fogs, nav, h/k sound, white turns, H&R touring cup kit, BBS LM's (aka "Let's Motor"), Michelin Pilot Exalto PE2's. '07 Z4M Coupe, bone stock.
If she's got the cold weather package. Have her try her heated seats a bit too...
It's a known issue that the temp regulator has been a problem and may need to be replaced. Was like that in my '09 and I think may be the same in my brand new 2010. No lovely burning smells but it gets HOT.
__________________
My handmade artwork for sale!
Much MINI themed, inlcuding MINI Love Note Cards: http://www.deladriel3.etsy.com
The "lifetime fluid" thing is pure BS. Just a way for them to reduce the cost of their "free" maintenance program, and to ensure that their cars don't last too long..
Wow, I doubt "that manufacturers tailor their maintenance programs to ensure their cars don't last too long." That sounds like pure nonsense to me. I would sure like to see the proof that you base this claim on??
__________________
1713
09 MCS Pepper White,Punch Carbon Blk Leather,Cream White Color Line, Cold/Premium/Sport Packages.
2012 JCW CR Coupe,Cold Weather Pkg,Dash Surface in CR,Prem Pkg,All Mirrors Auto Dim,17" Challenge Spoke Black Wheels,Alarm,Black Headlamps,H/K Sound,BT/USB, Arm Rest,JCW Strut Brace,LL Championship Red Seats,Rear Fog
all of the engines were replaced when the car was facelifted for 2000. the range consisted of the 2.2 L M54B22 (available outside North America), 2.5 L M54B25, 3.0 L M54B30, and (for the M Roadster) 3.2 L S54B32. all three of these straight-6 engines lasted through the end of the car's run in 2002. also updated was the car's interior appointments, though the plastic window remained.
