F55/F56 Bad air smell
#176
Took my wife's MINI to Portland for the smell "fix" (1200 miles round trip). Car is an April 2014 build S. Work order description follows:
"Verified complaint, raised the vehicle, lowered exhaust down. Removed lower heat shield and inspected AC drains. Drains look good at this time. Removed old micro filter, inspected AC drain inside the vehicle underneath the evap. Box, AC drain is good.Performed AC evaporator cleaning with solution and then self flushed evaporator. Glued new micro filter and installed into evap. box.Reinstalled side dash trim covers and lower heat shield under vehicle. Raised exhaust system into place. All work done per M64 03 14."
So, looks like the same glued filter into place that Mrdi reports. The minty smell was gone by the time I returned home. Still cold in Montana but I did try the air and it was OK, I think.
"Verified complaint, raised the vehicle, lowered exhaust down. Removed lower heat shield and inspected AC drains. Drains look good at this time. Removed old micro filter, inspected AC drain inside the vehicle underneath the evap. Box, AC drain is good.Performed AC evaporator cleaning with solution and then self flushed evaporator. Glued new micro filter and installed into evap. box.Reinstalled side dash trim covers and lower heat shield under vehicle. Raised exhaust system into place. All work done per M64 03 14."
So, looks like the same glued filter into place that Mrdi reports. The minty smell was gone by the time I returned home. Still cold in Montana but I did try the air and it was OK, I think.
#178
Mine was fixed using the most current fix ( replaced cabin filter, cleaning the system and raising the filter away from the evaporator water). Smelled minty fresh for a few weeks now smells normal. So far so good. No bad smell.
Since this issue has been documented it should be a covered repair even after the warranty expires (not that I'll be keeping the car after that anyway).
Since this issue has been documented it should be a covered repair even after the warranty expires (not that I'll be keeping the car after that anyway).
#179
#180
#181
#182
Have you noticed if the water has come back after the fix? I just dropped mine off at the dealership today for the same issue. I had my friend also check his 14 F56 and low and behold his is also soaked. So this seems to be a pretty prevalent issue across 2014 F56's. I had my ultraguage down there and it's complety ruined, and also I had a few papers and a box for my dash camera down there which were covered in mold. Definietly gonna see if I can get Mini to fork up the cash for a new ultragauge and for them to also replace the carpeting down there.
#183
That is exactly what they do. A couple beads of hot glue in an attempt to get the filter to sit up higher so that the water can drain out underneath it. It sounded to me like it was a stop gap measure for MINI to try and figure out a different filter box situation
#184
That is likely the case. Thinking it may be cheaper for them in the long run to engineer a plastic adapter that slides on the filter edge that provides the clearance needed. On future filter replacement, they simply swap the adapter to the new filter. But Hey, what do I know.
#185
That is likely the case. Thinking it may be cheaper for them in the long run to engineer a plastic adapter that slides on the filter edge that provides the clearance needed. On future filter replacement, they simply swap the adapter to the new filter. But Hey, what do I know.
#187
Smell returned yesterday, second day after the second "fix" which was done in March. First time AC was used......I will call MINI again....I'm getting tired of this....this will be my third trip.....I was "promised" the last time it was fixed. Any other bulletins I should be aware of???
Thanks
Thanks
#188
#189
We run our AC everyday we take the car out (SW Florida). No smell at all after the TSB fix. I'm wondering if the recurring issue some members are having isn't due to a dealership's service department's operator head-space error.
Hard to imagine a TSB being issued that resolves the problem and most guys having the work done once have no further issue, that it isn't a service department issue at some point.
Our dealership (MINI of Ft. Myers) service department is absolutely fantastic. Cannot say enough good things about the Svc manager and his crew. Guess I am blessed with my situation.
For those experiencing an un-rectified issue like this, perhaps taking the car to another dealership for the fix. Not the perfect solution, but may be the only way to get the work done properly.
A word of encouragement to those still having the problem. The fix does work.
Hard to imagine a TSB being issued that resolves the problem and most guys having the work done once have no further issue, that it isn't a service department issue at some point.
Our dealership (MINI of Ft. Myers) service department is absolutely fantastic. Cannot say enough good things about the Svc manager and his crew. Guess I am blessed with my situation.
For those experiencing an un-rectified issue like this, perhaps taking the car to another dealership for the fix. Not the perfect solution, but may be the only way to get the work done properly.
A word of encouragement to those still having the problem. The fix does work.
#190
I am getting discouraged, since I asked the deakership if there has been any update since my second visit and was told no. Do you have any part#'s, service bulletin #'s, or any info that I will tell the dealership as to what has been done and worked? It seems like the more I deal with repairs, the more I fell Ineed to tell others how to do their job. I do not do this by choice, but by necessity to get things done right. The dealership is just going to do the same thing, and we already know that didn't work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
#192
I think this is a similar kind of deal as with the rain sensor gel pack leaking from the windshield.
Well, maybe not the same, at least they attempted a repair for the bad smell. The rain sensor gel pack just keeps leaking on mine and I had mine replaced several times now.
I also got the bad smell fix (replaced evaporator, replaced air filter with beads of glue to make a little clearance) but I noticed the stink as soon as I was picking up my car. These days I just make sure to vent it without AC for a while before I park my car. If I start using the AC the stink will come back eventually.
Does anyone know where the air inlet is for the vent? I looked in front of the windshield and couldn't find any holes that sucks air in. I want to spray Lysol (or similar stuff) but couldn't find the hole. Then I was trying to spray it from the inside the cabin but I couldn't pull out the filter because it was so tightly stuck inside.
Well, maybe not the same, at least they attempted a repair for the bad smell. The rain sensor gel pack just keeps leaking on mine and I had mine replaced several times now.
I also got the bad smell fix (replaced evaporator, replaced air filter with beads of glue to make a little clearance) but I noticed the stink as soon as I was picking up my car. These days I just make sure to vent it without AC for a while before I park my car. If I start using the AC the stink will come back eventually.
Does anyone know where the air inlet is for the vent? I looked in front of the windshield and couldn't find any holes that sucks air in. I want to spray Lysol (or similar stuff) but couldn't find the hole. Then I was trying to spray it from the inside the cabin but I couldn't pull out the filter because it was so tightly stuck inside.
#193
#197
#198
#199
#200
F54, too
Great news! The F54 has the bad air smell issue, too.
Popped up after a string of unusually humid days. Strong vinegar-y smell.
After my SA opened a PuMA case, turns out the fix is the same as the F56/55 service bulletin.
As of Feb 2016 there's also a redesigned microfilter- 64-31-6-835-405. If the dealer looks up under service items, the old part number shows up. Searching for the part by VIN shows the new P/N.
Not sure why my car had the issue since it's an April 2016 build. I'd assume it would have the redesigned part. Regardless, hope it's a true fix as claimed.
Popped up after a string of unusually humid days. Strong vinegar-y smell.
After my SA opened a PuMA case, turns out the fix is the same as the F56/55 service bulletin.
As of Feb 2016 there's also a redesigned microfilter- 64-31-6-835-405. If the dealer looks up under service items, the old part number shows up. Searching for the part by VIN shows the new P/N.
Not sure why my car had the issue since it's an April 2016 build. I'd assume it would have the redesigned part. Regardless, hope it's a true fix as claimed.